@WonderfulJohnx The funny (or sad) thing is that this is actually a very viable outcome on paper. YouTube would lose the case due to the flawed AI revie process having massive implications on individual level, and their manual review process being highly unequal. They would lose the case.
@master_pivot@TeamYouTube It’s not a birthday present. Come on. If the decision is flawed, like most of these automated cases seem to be - then it’s not more than basic responsibility of @TeamYouTube to correct their mistakes. It’s not like they would be gifting something to you…
@wannercashcow@elonmusk X actually has a big momentum to jump into long-form now that YouTube has shown complete disrespect for the creator community due to flawed AI-driven ban / demonetization pandemic.
X needs one thing: open long-form for all users. Monetization can still be behind paywall.
@YouTubeCreators What channel? Your AI bots are blocking creators at a rate which makes these kind of ”nice little tips” seem really foolish and arrogant, disrespectful towards the creator community
@kanhasharmyw3x@TeamYouTube@YouTubeCreators@YouTube@YouTubeIndia These practices by @TeamYouTube won't stand up to scrutiny in court.
This is because the implications of the flawed AI decisions are massive on personal level, and because of the inequal treatment of creators (only fraction gets the manual review and restoration).
@SappyYT These practices by @TeamYouTube won't stand up to scrutiny in court.
This is because the implications of the flawed AI decisions are massive on personal level, and because of the inequal treatment of creators (only fraction gets the manual review and restoration).
These practices by @TeamYouTube won't stand up to scrutiny in court.
This is because the implications of the flawed AI decisions are massive on personal level, and because of the inequal treatment of creators (only fraction gets the manual review and restoration).
We are tired @TeamYouTube
We are tired of being neglected by you.
We are tired of constantly trying to reach out.
We are tired of putting in all those hours without getting paid.
We are tired of dealing with the constant AI cycles that your support system sends our way.
I am in a group with all the animators that have been demonetized, and all we want to do is just go back to animating.
Go back to how our lives were a few months ago, before we were hit with the demonetization.
It has affected a lot of our mental health. Many people are already dealing with serious issues, and the added stress from this whole situation has made it really tough to deal with.
It has also greatly affected us financially. After 12 years on your platform and millions of views, the revenue I earn from YouTube makes a big part of my income. But now it's all gone. And its the same for all the other animators.
We just want someone to take a look into our channels. It will take just a moment to look into all our channels and realize that our content is not made for kids.
The AI has made a mistake. It's fine. AI will make mistakes. But give us a proper way to appeal. Give us a real human review.
That is literally all we ask.
It's been so exhausting trying to get your guys attention.
We are tired boss.
These practices by @TeamYouTube won't stand up to scrutiny in court.
This is because the implications of the flawed decisions are massive on personal level, and because of the inequal treatment of creators (only fraction gets the manual review and restoration).
Halo @TeamYouTube, Why is it that only the channels of major, viral YouTubers get restored, while small channels receive no response? Please have a human review my case and reactivate my channel.
My Channel 'Gameplay Sakura' URL : https://t.co/jyfdiaN8gk
@arsyt124 These practices won't stand up to scrutiny in court.
This is because the implications of the flawed decisions are massive on personal level, and because of the inequal treatment of creators (only fraction gets the manual review and restoration).
I've uncovered yet another YouTube Support tactic and figured out the principle behind how these bots operate and refuse to help, all while hiding behind their usual “We're always here for you” act. They have to maintain that image to avoid public backlash when people realize just how unprofessional a company that claims to be a serious corporation actually is.
As you can see from my posts, YouTube recently told me they were working on my case and would get back to me as soon as possible. Of course, I waited two days, and then they came back with the usual “we're sorry,” claiming they had reviewed everything (which I'm 100% certain they did not) and telling me the case was final.
So here's how it works: they send you a message or email saying they're actively working on your case, put you on a 2–3 day waiting period, and then come back with a final decision and a scripted apology. In doing so, they discourage you from contacting them again, while you lose any chance of ever pursuing the same career again, whether as a content creator, an editor, or anything else.
I honestly don't understand where this is all heading, but Neal, you've certainly trained these bots well. Congratulations. That's the only thing I can give you credit for. You've shown everyone just how “powerful” your company really is and how much you supposedly “care” about creators.
You should be ashamed of yourselves. @nealmohan@TeamYouTube@YouTube@YouTubeCreators@FTC
Hahaha, yeah, you're absolutely right. You're always there for creators, once every seven months, and that's only if it happens at all.
- It's honestly disgraceful what you're doing, or rather, what your bots are doing. You give people false hope, terminate their channels for no valid reason because your stupid AI system flags them and makes decisions God knows why.
- You've managed to train your bot to sound polite, so at least you've accomplished something, while countless innocent creators are left with permanently terminated channels that may never be restored. Great job, really. Absolutely outstanding work. @TeamYouTube@YouTube@nealmohan
@TeamYouTube How about the most CRITICAL bug in your current service, is that still on the backlog?
Your flawed AI channel removal mechanism that affects livelihoods of established creators and their families, and your inability to take human responsibility over these removal decisions?
@icreatelife Technically yes, but it’s a really misleading number. Most are opening some pdf with Acrobat every now and then and that’s it : absolutely no engagement with the software, just opening a file. Quite far a away from Creative Cloud All Apps subscriber…😉
@pggalaviz I think your attitude is quite aggressive: ”stupid”, ”ridiculous”, et. If you have a different view, just share it, argument it. So, ok - flouride is not a harmless neurotoxin? Everything is fine, just participate in the discussion with your view. You don’t have to start a war
@YouTube Are you serious - do you have a PR team?
This year, @TeamYouTube has really shown their face - total arrogance and disrespect for creators, who are banned by FLAWED AI review process.
Providing manual review only for the few. AI’s mistakes ruin livelihoods of families!
🥳🥳🥰
@zNpesta__@TeamYouTube 😂 this is priceless example of this flawed automated review system, which is authorized to destroy livelihoods of established creators! It is UNREAL…how small misjudgement by the system can force this block onto creators, one wrongly interpreted word and boom - you’re gone!