@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 I don't doubt the seriousness of trauma,
as it has nearly ruined my life
It's just that I see how history operates.
Not sure if I can sit through a podcast about trauma
until I'm a little more healed
Thx again - maybe we should do a podcast!
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 :) Thx for the discussion
I still don't understand how my analysis is scientifically unsound, as I've been into economic data for 50 yrs & have a degree in history
I think you're over-estimating trauma & underestimating economics
But am willing to keep an open mind
Til next time
@AndrewCicchett1 @odvss @DrEmmaKatz That was my question too
My "acute" abuse started when I was pregnant
But he got me pregnant in a sneaky, non-consensual way, so was that really the first abuse?
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 Trauma fits as an influencing factor, or even the spark of inequality, but not a burning fire. There was no burning fire before they started trading women for goats - just a spark
But the cruelty & inequality wouldn't happen without the economic system
The spark woulda died out
If I don't talk about my trauma, my PTSD, the therapy, the eating disorder
It's because my abuser still uses these things against me to harass me and in court
And I don't want to give him more fodder
Or more satisfaction to think how much I was damaged
Because he's a f*ing sadist
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 I now think that trauma could have been the spark and not just the commodification of women
But still think economics is the main driver
Wouldn't it be fun to do this on a panel discussion?
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 Well we can disagree
I think trauma influences our decisions
But economics influences more decisions
and may be based on security, not just greed
Either way,
they both play are role and are integral in the solutions to overcome inequality
So we both have a lot to do!
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 You've opened my eyes to the influence of trauma on our bad behavior & social inequality
But I still think that crap economics is the cause and the fuel of patriarchy
We have traumatized societies that are still egalitarian
We can disagree on this and explore it further sometime
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 There are too many cases when violence against women and opportunities for women are reduced or increased in countries that have changed their economic systems, like the post-Soviet countries for example.
Trauma influences inequality, but economics drives it
in my humble opinion
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 Trauma responses are serious, unnatural and f'd us up big-time and the new disfunction had to exist before the economic cruelty
& influences history as a pre-existing condition
But it's economic incentive that drives the cruelty
Most don't act on it, unless they are paid to
@McClureShawn The word for "god" among the plains tribes means
"the great mystery"
The elders seem to indicate to me that we are just stupid 2-legged mammals that haven't grasped what "god" really is
and that maybe it's presumptuous to act like we do
@AndrewCicchett1@assoc1counsell It wasn't just greed alone that drove economic inequality
I think people also made decisions on economic security in a developing system of limited choices
They went along with it, in other words, to feed their families
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 I'm using the last 6,000 yrs of data of western civilization, not anecdotes
Not sure what you think is scientifically incorrect
My position: economics drives patriarchy
Men didn't have the social/political leverage to act on their psychopathy alone
They had economic incentive
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 I totally believe you
You're the professional
I never thought that psychopathy just happens
and didn't mean to suggest that.
It's serious and real.
@assoc1counsell@AndrewCicchett1 Economics is more than 1% of why/how we got patriarchy.
You've opened my eyes about the influence of emotional disfunction that sanctions the patriarchy & is a pre-existing condition that allows it, but I can't believe that it's the driving force.
Economics is the driving force.