The below is excellent. Well thought out, clear & in my opinion, absolutely correct.
As a club, we should be aiming higher & be expecting a lot more. The below lays out what is needed to begin to do that.
#readingfc
Reading FC: Where is the progress, and who takes responsibility?
A bit of a longer post from me after today's game. I wanted to get a few thoughts out of my head, particularly the frustration of watching what feels like a decline many of us could see coming some time ago.
I've been thinking about where things have gone wrong at Reading since the takeover, and I don't believe there's one simple answer. There are several factors contributing to the lack of genuine progress, and for me, responsibility starts at the top.
The owners and CEO
Whenever a football club is taken over, it becomes a project. There's a vision, a plan and an expectation of what the new owners want to achieve.
So, how is our project progressing?
I know it's still relatively early in the season, but I want to make a comparison with Sheffield Wednesday.
Their new ownership project started roughly 12 months after ours. In theory, we should be further along in our development, or at the very least showing clearer signs of progress.
Let me be clear: I'm not comparing the size of the two clubs.
Sheffield Wednesday are a club capable of attracting 30,000 supporters in League One. With that level of support and revenue potential, they should be challenging in the Championship, if not higher.
Reading are in a very different position, and that arguably makes the challenge facing our owners even greater.
We don't have 30,000 supporters turning up regardless of results. If our owners want to grow attendances by another 12,000โ14,000 and eventually fill the stadium, they need to give people a reason to come.
That means winning football matches, playing entertaining football and building a team that supporters believe in.
Sheffield Wednesday managed to attract huge crowds despite winning just once at home last season, on the final day. Reading simply don't have that same level of unconditional matchday support.
And that's where setting realistic expectations becomes so important.
Expectations versus reality
There are plenty of supporters calling for Leam Richardson's head. But why are expectations so high?
Because promotion was presented to us as the minimum expectation.
That, for me, was the first major mistake made by the ownership, and it's one they continue to compound.
You cannot publicly set the expectation of promotion without building a squad genuinely capable of delivering it.
We've made some excellent signings. Earthy, Lisbie, Marriott and Godwin-Malife are examples of players who have added genuine quality.
But we've also brought in players who, in my opinion, look like panic signings. Players who simply aren't of the standard required for a promotion-chasing side.
When your strongest players are injured or suspended, as we've seen in recent weeks, the replacements need to be capable of stepping in without a significant drop in quality.
Ours aren't.
So whose responsibility is that?
The players? The manager? Or the people responsible for identifying, recruiting and approving those signings?
For me, the greater responsibility lies with the latter.
Recruitment has not been good enough
Throughout the summer, we repeatedly heard that our preferred targets had chosen Championship clubs instead.
Well, that suggests one of two things.
Either we were targeting players who were never realistically going to join us, or we hadn't done enough scouting to identify credible alternatives.
Neither reflects particularly well on our recruitment strategy.
We also lost out on players who joined other League One clubs.
Why?
I can only speculate, but perhaps those players weren't convinced by our promotion ambitions. Perhaps we weren't prepared to meet their financial demands, including agent fees.
If it's the latter, I can understand that. Clubs need financial discipline.
But if players were choosing other League One clubs because they weren't convinced by our project, that's a much bigger concern.
Could they see the same weaknesses in our recruitment strategy that many supporters could see over the summer?
Ultimately, the owners and CEO must take responsibility for the expectations they've created and the squad they've assembled.
You reap what you sow.
And you cannot set ambitious targets, fail to provide the tools to achieve them, and then appear frustrated when supporters question the decisions being made.
Supporters don't need constant communication. They need honesty.
After everything we endured under Dai Yongge, I understand why the new ownership has placed so much emphasis on being open with supporters.
But I think there's a difference between openness and honesty.
We don't need to hear constantly about the project, the ambition or how much everyone cares about the club.
We need an honest assessment of where we actually are.
We're a club struggling to attract 10,000โ12,000 supporters per game after some of the most difficult years in our history.
Was automatic promotion genuinely realistic this season?
With the squad we've assembled, I don't believe it was.
Could we still reach the playoffs? Of course.
But that requires the people running the club to acknowledge where they've made mistakes, learn from them and be prepared to act decisively when the January transfer window opens.
Does Leam Richardson stay?
For me, the answer is no.
I don't believe he's the manager to take Reading forward.
That doesn't mean I hold him solely responsible for our current position. Far from it. I don't believe he's been given the strongest possible squad to work with, and the recruitment issues I've outlined have undoubtedly made his job harder.
But six wins from 16 league matches simply isn't good enough for a club supposedly targeting promotion.
Four draws. Six defeats. Ten league matches without a victory.
After today's defeat, Richardson said, "It wasn't our day."
Well, it hasn't been our day in 10 of our 16 league games this season.
At some point, that stops being an unfortunate afternoon and becomes a much bigger problem.
But what concerns me just as much is what I see as a weakness in Richardson's management. He doesn't appear strong enough to make difficult decisions, particularly when it comes to established players.
Lewis Wing is the obvious example. He has been poor all season, yet he continues to be selected. We all know what he's capable of, but reputation and past performances shouldn't guarantee anyone a place in the starting XI.
At some point, a manager has to be prepared to make those uncomfortable decisions, even when it means dropping one of your most influential players. Otherwise, what message does that send to the rest of the squad?
Look at Sheffield Wednesday.
They've recognised the need for change and appointed Dave Challinor, a manager with a proven record of building successful teams and winning promotions.
Already, there's a sense of direction about what they're trying to achieve. A clear identity, a manager supporters can get behind and a project that appears to have some joined-up thinking.
Compare that with Reading, where the atmosphere between sections of the fanbase, management and ownership feels increasingly toxic.
People will say booing the players doesn't help, and they're right. But after everything our supporters have endured in recent years, I find it difficult to criticise those who are frustrated.
When the expectations being sold to supporters don't match the reality on the pitch, it's hardly surprising that people feel misled.
So what happens next?
If you've read Rescuing the Royals, the book documenting Rob Couhig's first 12 months at Reading, you'll know there was a substantial offer for the club from someone referred to as "Teddy".
Couhig rejected that offer because he believed he had unfinished business at Reading.
I have no issue with that.
In fact, I want owners who are committed to building something successful here.
But commitment needs to be demonstrated through decisions, not just words.
For me, there are two things that need to happen.
First, appoint a new manager.
Someone with a different personality. Someone with fire, passion, honesty and the ability to improve the players already at the club.
Not simply someone who talks about performances, but someone who establishes standards, demands accountability and creates a recognisable identity on the pitch.
Give that manager the next four to five weeks to assess the squad properly before January.
Second, back that manager with genuine first-team quality.
When the transfer window opens, every signing should be capable of competing for a starting place immediately.
No more filling gaps with players who aren't good enough.
No more out-of-contract signings from clubs like Gillingham simply because they're available.
No more taking chances on loan players who haven't played competitive football for eight months because of injury.
We need players of the standard of Earthy, Lisbie and Dokes. Players who improve the squad rather than simply increase its numbers.
And crucially, don't leave another manager short of the quality required, as happened with Hunt and, in my opinion, Richardson.
If we get those decisions right, there's still an opportunity to challenge for the playoffs.
But I think we also need to be realistic. Promotion this season looks increasingly unlikely.
And that brings me to next season.
If we don't go up, the preparation for 2027/28 needs to start immediately.
By 1 June, we should already be in a position to strengthen the squad.
Get the recruitment done early. Give the manager a full preseason with the players he wants. Stop leaving important business until the final days of the transfer window.
Learn from the mistakes of the last few seasons.
Make sure we're ready to compete from 1 August, rather than spending the opening months trying to fix problems that should have been addressed during the summer.
And then go and achieve what we were told to expect this season: promotion.
My final point is this.
I don't expect perfection from our owners, CEO, recruitment team or manager. Everyone makes mistakes.
But I do expect accountability.
Reading supporters have been incredibly patient through years of uncertainty, financial problems and disappointment.
We don't need another season of promises about what this club could become.
We need to start seeing evidence of what it is becoming.
Because right now, I struggle to see the progress we were promised.
#readingfc
๐ฅ๏ธ The audio version of this week's podcast isn't quite ready yet, but the video one is!
Head on over to our YouTube channel for the full episode, featuring an in-depth chat with @catania_rick15, appearances from TTE pod hosts past and present, and loads more.
#ReadingFC
"We've had some absolute shockers over the last few years, but that, as a result, is up there for me."
@mrblthomas unloads after a horrendous 1-0 defeat for #ReadingFC at home to Bromley.
@catania_rick15 Thank you for acknowledging it. Big changes are needed in the overall mentality of a lot of people (not all) at the club. Too many are too comfortable and are missing the bigger picture of what this club, community & town are about.
Not the clubโs fault of course, but having this at 12.30 when most grassroots games are still going on/yet to start means that a fair number who would go canโt because they are prioritising their own teams. Mad #readingfc
It's our first Schools and Grassroots fixture tomorrow lunchtime for the visit of Bromley!
Take a look at our What's On Guide below and make a day of it at the Select Car Leasing Stadium๐
๐https://t.co/GZ8NNVBIKx
Pleased to be joining the board of trustees @RFCCommunity to help grow & develop the education offering to local communities. Thank you to @AndyTow & the rest of the trustees for the opportunity #readingfc
@EthanLewendon Thoughts with you and the family. Used to see Reading Elvis every day on my commute and heโd be holding up one of the Kingโs records to everyone who drove by. Rest in peace.
๐๏ธ The loss to Stockport is our main topic on the next episode of the pod.
Let us know your thoughts on:
- Areas to strengthen squad-wise
- Leam's performance as manager
- Where #ReadingFC will be in the league on Christmas Day
@mrblthomas
Basically flat track bullies arenโt we. Give it the beans (mostly) against the weaker teams & collapse like a warm Easter egg against the better ones #readingfc
Went to my first @WelshRugbyUnion game in 1995. Iโve seen us plumb the depths & scale the heights in that time. Today, I saw us beat NZ for the 1st time in 73 years, when my Nanaโs cousin, Ken Jones, played. Just an unreal day #wru
MATCH DAY! Get prepped for Reading home as Steve sits down with Ben from @TheTilehurstEnd โฝ๏ธ
We cover:
๐ Early season form
๐ Summer transfer activity
๐ Key players to watch
๐ฏ Match predictions
Catch the full show now! ๐ฒ๐
https://t.co/sjbSSxPtog
#StockportCounty #ReadingFC #tsbw #TheRoyals