@EmGO43@TNFreedom21 You’re mixing concepts. Impulsive and intentional can and must coexist to prove murder 2. Intent means the mental state towards the criminalized outcome: knowledge, desire, extreme recklessness. Impulsiveness, otoh, stands in contrast to premeditation. Was this premeditated?
@EmGO43@TNFreedom21 2nd degree murder hasn’t been a capital crime since the late 18th century, early 19th. When impulsive killings were capital crimes, juries frequently acquitted guilty murderers because they didn’t want their execution on their conscience. It’s better to avoid that, right?
@HetBeestNL@MakotoDonoghue@BortonDoug@NotifNews1 IDK about UK law (aside from English common law from an American perspective), but I think it would be tough to prove intent (desire, knowledge, extreme recklessness) to cause grievous/serious bodily harm from a single punch. I don’t know anything about this case, though.
@TNFreedom21@EmGO43 That’s first degree. He was found guilty of second degree. The difference is premeditation. Think hot blooded vs cold blooded. Here, this seems “hot blooded” because it was road rage. Sentencing guidelines for second degree with no prior qualifying felonies maxes at 25 years.
@Tacometer@joeyboy6684@levijunior220 Literal textbook 2 degree. And good luck producing evidence the driver desired for the passenger to shoot, let alone knew passenger was going to shoot, let alone knew passenger had a gun. And the Judge picks the sentence from sentencing guidelines. Nobody knows how the law works.
@DreamsOfTaos@DKThomp So far so good, the workload keeps building though, but I’m getting faster/lazier at briefing to match the acceleration. Torts is my favorite class, followed by contracts and crim. Civil procedure is understandable, just so unenjoyable and boring
@DreamsOfTaos@DKThomp I think recklessness or negligence is a good fit here. A prosecutor would have a difficult time showing that the hacks were practically/substantially certain to result from the training/benchmarking, IMO.
I’m only 4 weeks into law school, though.
If you think about it, the job of a judge is really simple. Just interpret the law faithfully, apply it objectively, have results that follow common sense, and apply the law so that good people win and bad people lose.
@ProfRobAnderson I’m only in my first week, so I have exactly 3 classes of contract knowledge to analyze this, but I don’t see why it wouldn’t be? Except that it looks identical to a barter, save for the fact they’re exchanging paper money, not really a contract.
@deltatheta105 @EgregiousFilben Reality:
And anyways, when have you heard an American boasting about our soccer prowess? Like idk what your point is, I have yet to have met someone who 1) gives a shit about soccer and 2) thinks the USMNT is a prospect for quarter final run