Great to see that Max has left Eth's extended core dev community.
Ethereum is for everybody, and Eth has many earnest critics, but Max wasn't one of them.
Max has joined Solana. He writes:
> In my first 100 days, I plan on writing a spec for as much of the Solana protocol as I can get to.
Critics like Max have frequently claimed that Ethereum needs to become more like Solana. But in reality, Ethereum's strategy of a maximally decentralized L1 scaled by a marketplace of L2s is apex - no strategy changes are needed. What's actually happening now is that Solana is taking big steps to try to become more like Ethereum, not vice versa.
Solana will try to buy things Eth already has, including client diversity, a real protocol spec, a research community, and much more onchain capital. Max is now part of Sol's effort to become more like Ethereum. That's ironic considering he kept saying Ethereum had to become more like Solana.
However, all of Solana's money will not enable them to buy decentralization.
Decentralization is something that must be grown intentionally over many years. You can't buy it at the "decentralization store".
Solana is fundamentally centralized. That's going to limit their growth in a huge way as global partners see the much higher level of risk and liability on Sol vs Eth.
Sol is a data center chain (10gbps upload recommended). They are years away from achieving client diversity, if ever. Their token is famously closely held - it's more like an enterprise token. Much of the supply is still uncirculating. And lots of the circulating supply is owned by a small circle of Sol insiders. The EF owns 0.25% of all ETH, ~100x less than just the percentage of uncirculating SOL.
Solana's technology is also increasingly obsolete. They have built a real community and app layer when compared to failing alt L1s. But their monolith will soon be slower and more expensive than the fastest L2s, by a lot. L2 app and dev ecosystems are growing faster than Sol. Eth interop is improving rapidly. Soon, cross-L2 UX will be seamless. Solana's pivot to try to become more like Ethereum - in terms of growing their L2 ecosystem and attempting (and mostly failing) to become more decentralized - is their tacit acknowledgment of their major tech strategy weakness.
In short, Solana is mostly a paper tiger with deep pockets. Unsurprisingly, that's a great fit for Max.