an op-ed written with frankness + rooted in a personal place. have intentionally omitted many details out of respect for those who have borne the weight of personal costs:
https://t.co/vekZpP1h2h
Some feminist groups in Pakistan are shifting from symbolic protests to quieter, embedded collective work.
@wdf_pk’s Behnon ki Baithak on 8 March 2025 was one such experiment. @pind_wave on "After the March":
https://t.co/Zh7Df24DHf
Books are expensive and I can barely buy them anymore but the people to blame aren't the bookstores but read this thread to understand why (PS Anna's Archive and zlib etc are awesome and better for your eyes but sail the seven seas however you can because reading is for everyone)
the “ugh elitist bookstore” crowd is so annoying. yes imported books are expensive but in pakistan the 1-2 big bookstores we have left are just about the only way many reading genres enter the country at all! cos no local pipeline for most international publications.
@ba09714726 woh tau unfortunately hamare rupaye ka masla hai. who doesn't want cheaper books? glad some bookstores also have a publication unit, not enough for readers here though as options still limited.
@nunupaws__ you only get pirated copies of bestsellers. i get that the anger at big expensive bookstores is about the class gap. we need to call for cheaper locally published editions instead. piracy is another debate, don't think we can rely on it permanently/in the longer run as readers.
@M_Mahad_rk not only talking about that one thread jbtw, it's something i have seen people argue about over the years. would have tagged the post if i wanted to refer to it.
@MurtadGPT i mean he also posted his picture on a weekday when people are at work....plenty of arguments to negate what he said tbh. plus who likes buying books at a mall....i don't disagree with you at all, LB bashing aside (agree with some of it btw).
@_plushpillowsss oh no more accusations, i guess this is all you do in your free time online with your sad anon account. dhank se baat karni tau aati nahin barri aayi bhaashan dene. buss saara din yehi karti raho, embarrassing yourself 24/7 sigh.
@dezgostang UK publications are better cos they do cheaper paperbacks much faster, US and europe mein they are still pricier esp when they come here. and we can't source from india anymore so bad scene all around. :/
@dezgostang and rupee incomes are low. so i am upset for myself as a reader and still relieved that at least we STILL have a handful of big bookstores here.
@dezgostang saeed book bank is a bigger offender here waisay even though i wouldn't obviously want it to shut down (they had to in peshawar...the city used to have the best bookstores once upon a time - now gone). but LB prices are down to their commission/profit AND importing books.
@_plushpillowsss oh no!!!! you, who cannot string a single intelligent, let alone original thought, and cannot argue for shit, called my opinion unreasonable and idiotic!!!! how will i live with myself now haye haye.
@_plushpillowsss you use time during your job to be a pissy reply guy, i use mine to flesh out my thoughts sometimes - why the hypocrisy? like i said, do better. x
really hate it when "sindh KP balochistan" are brought up as a rhetorical shut up call every time a question about governance is asked. almost like the 18th amendment is a figment of one's imagination (pichli kuch amendments tau chalayn filhaal chhorayn).
شہباز اب کہو یہ بھی جعلی وڈیو ہے ۔
راتب خوروں نے صرف شاہزیب خانزادہ کے سوال رکھ کر گھنگھرو باندھے تھے ، اب زرا آہستہ آہستہ میڈیا سیل کے اکاؤنٹ سے چیئرمین بلاول بھٹو زرداری کے وڈیوز اپلوڈ ہوتے جائیں گے اور آپ سمیت وجییہ ثانی اور لندن میں بیٹھے مرتضیٰ علی شاہ نے کہنا ہوگا کہ یہ جعلی وڈیو بلاول ہاؤس میں بنائے گئے ہیں ۔
@awami_rational that's my whole point. those books were bought from/by a commercial bookstore before they were thrown out. books eventually trickle down from *someone* paying a price first. cheap books here exist because bookstores (however cheap/expensive) exist, here or abroad.
@awami_rational kinokuniya is also a bookstore chain. i have found books there to be much more expensive than even those at LB. same model on a multi-country scale.
we don't have independent bookstores, good libraries. paper duties are high. our criticism needs to be geared at int publishers who don't price for our market! NEED cheap local editions (like liberty publishing heartlamp)/trade body licensing print titles here at local prices.
to be clear, i think liberty books and readings are v much businesses and act like it. but the same lazy arguments were leveled at the last word, which was different and run like a space for readers than a sales floor. losing it hurt.