@pind_wave It's not about being anti-elitist. The wording of the original post implied that people aren't reading anymore. We're only pointing out that you can't use an expensive bookstore to support your point. We rely on used copies and piracy because most readers aren't born to luxury
@fimanallah@pasta_ani@alphaSG472ciri@floatingwordist It's in the very study people are citing. Net conversion in Islam is now in the negative. Ten years ago the projections were positive. So either apostasy rates have increased, or conversions have decreased.
https://t.co/1LXwn5iynF
The most notable thing about the latest pew projection is that muslims are in the negative when it comes to religious switching. This is surprising because in the older projection from ten years ago, the net change was positive!
@hamzakaramali No, that's not my view. Mechanistic just means the opposite of volitional, it doesn't mean physical. We can posit an immaterial, eternal source of the big bang that necessarily generates this universe as part of its mechanistic nature. It can't do otherwise.
@hamzakaramali Well we only see one universe and it's laws are absolute. The big bang produced one static set of natural laws that have run consistently to this day. So I don't understand how that qualifies as "variety". Isn't consistency a sign of mechanism rather than volition?
@Quranic_Islam Ok, but how far can we stretch it? If someone is genuinely attracted to a postmodernist, feminist, pro-lgbt type of Islam, is it still appropriate to say that's his fitra?
Liberty is the worst bookstore in the country. Only pretentious DHA boys go there. Our libraries are libgen and AA because money is tight. Literally everyone in my class reads ebooks.
@hamzakaramali Hm? Almost every cause produces a variety of effects. The sun generates heat, and also light, and also causes cancer. Plants generates oxygen, and food, and regulate the water cycle. The moon causes light to reflect, but also causes tides, etc etc.
@UqbaNafi@CenterPopulist@ryanburge Yeah, but the data supports the idea that genuine self-reflection is more likely to lead one away from religion, rather than towards religion. That's a valuable takeaway for now.
The most notable thing about the latest pew projection is that muslims are in the negative when it comes to religious switching. This is surprising because in the older projection from ten years ago, the net change was positive!
@UqbaNafi@CenterPopulist@ryanburge Yes, but conversion is actually a net negative in Islam. Which means that people that actually reflect on the arguments are more likely to leave the religion :)
@hamzakaramali -language because this style of speaking about things having purpose was descended to us from theists. Otherwise we can substitute our terms by saying the heart has a disposition (not purpose) to pump blood for example. If you do live QnA on youtube I can join and discuss more.
@hamzakaramali -like the wind, magnetism, etc. As for the design argument, you say the argument hinges on primise 3, but I think premise 1 is begging the question. The word design already carries the meaning of intentionally created. So why would an atheist grant 1? We use teleological-
Ngl, this point Andani made against Jake a few years ago about the yad of Allah being an arbitrary amount still pops up in my mind occasionally. Some muslims adopted Rasmussen's argument from limits, but idk how they can solve this.
@PolakPetroziil@hamzakaramali True, your love for Islam has blinded your heart to the clear and obvious deception exhibited by this sheikh. I'm looking forward to reading the revised edition to see if he refines his case.