buybacks didn't save DeFi tokens that lost half their revenue
in my last post 12 of 16 tokens that pay holders still fell, so i widened the check to 26 DeFi tokens over the past year
for scale, $ETH fell 38% and $SOL fell 46% over the same year
what i found:
- 14 tokens lost half their revenue or more on DefiLlama (last 90 days vs the same 90 days a year ago), and all 14 fell, even $CAKE, $JUP and $SPK, which bought back tokens
- the median drop for these 14 was 44%, for the other 12 it was 11%
- the 5 tokens that went up ($HYPE, $RAY, $SKY, $UNI, $MORPHO) all kept more than half their revenue in that window, $RAY only after a launchpad wave in september
- each of the 5 also got something new over the past year, a fee switch with a 100M burn at @Uniswap, new markets and a fund treated as burned at @HyperliquidX, that launchpad wave at $RAY, cut emissions at $SKY and Apollo as a buyer at @Morpho
- keeping revenue wasn't enough on its own, $SYRUP and $LDO kept most of theirs and still fell 60% to 70%
a buyback is paid from revenue, so when revenue falls the buyback shrinks with it
the tokens that rose had both revenue that didn't halve and a fresh reason for someone to buy
$ENA has neither yet, fees are down 63%, team unlocks keep adding new tokens every month, while the fee switch needs $USDe at $7.5B and it's $5.0B now
neither for $ENA holders because this loop pays them $0
they get no revenue until the fee switch arms, and that needs $USDe supply to average $7.5B
today it's $5.0B
to be fair, paying holders doesn't guarantee a token goes up
i took 18 DeFi tokens that earn real fees, from $HYPE and $UNI to $CRV and $PENDLE
16 of them pay holders through buybacks, burns or staking, and 12 of those 16 still fell over the past year
$MORPHO pays nothing and still went up
until the switch arms, holding $ENA is a bet on $USDe supply growing
669M $PYTH is still staked in a program whose rewards have been at zero for 7 months
@PythNetwork's DAO set Oracle Integrity Staking rewards to zero in april, when the reward budget was nearly used up. that's about $34M of $PYTH earning nothing, and Pyth itself advised most stakers to unstake
the token flow has flipped since then. staking used to hand out about 7M $PYTH a month, while the DAO now buys $PYTH with revenue, 9.3M so far from october revenue alone
i think that's healthier for holders. a fixed reward pool always runs out, while revenue comes in every month
thanks for running the numbers. one thing though, if ethena unwinds it has to repay its $383M of $USDC, so aave utilization drops and lenders get out easier, just at a lower rate (~1.9%). the real exit risk for $USDC lenders is the opposite, more loops borrowing it
also it's not only ethena's own wallet anymore. since nov 20 other wallets borrowed $310M of aave $USDC against $USDe and $sUSDe, mostly for ethena's 5% reward
no quorum or supermajority. usually a 3-day poll first, then an executive vote, and a new spell just needs more $SKY behind it than the current one (6.69B right now). after that it waits 48h
the catch is who holds that $SKY. rune.eth's collateral is 3.58B $SKY, delegated to cloaky, BLUE and Bonapublica. those 3 gave 98% of the support to the last spell, and 53% of that support is rune's own collateral
on the dump part, even if liquidations got turned on, only $250K of this debt can be in auction at a time, so it'd be slow unless they change that too
good question btw, i think this deserves its own post
i don't think even 50% will get $stUSDS holders their money out
since this post the rate more than doubled to 44.78%, and borrowers paid back another $347K, about 0.2% of what they owe
the money from every one of those repayments was withdrawn within seconds, mostly by bots, so a holder clicking withdraw in the @SkyEcosystem app had almost no chance to get any of it
none of the big borrowers paid anything back. rune.eth alone still owes $77.3M, and his borrow rate rises with the $stUSDS rate, so that debt only grows faster
the docs for Sky's $stUSDS contract say "it is assumed that a max rate of 50% is enough". the rate can hit that cap tomorrow, and if that isn't enough either, everything else Sky can do needs a governance vote
Sky's risk advisor sees $stUSDS paying 50% in 4 days if nobody repays
in the last 10 days borrowers repaid only about $420K of the $162M they owe
liquidations on these loans are off, so for now @SkyEcosystem is leaning on the rate alone
when $414K was repaid today, a holder withdrew $405K of it in the very next transaction
other holders in a hurry sell on @CurveFinance, where a $1K sale today gets 1.8% to 3.3% less than the vault price
$stUSDS pays 19.74% now, and the contract already allows the next step to about 24.7%
a higher rate only helps holders if it pushes borrowers to repay or brings in new deposits, and the next 4 days will show if even 50% can do that
i think part of your $USDC yield on @aave now depends on a budget @ethena refills every week
since Aave raised the $USDC borrow cap on nov 20, loans there grew by $438M, and 71% of that went to wallets borrowing against Ethena's $USDe or $sUSDe
Ethena pays about 5% a year on $USDe deposited on Aave, but only to wallets that also borrow stablecoins. borrowing $USDC to buy more $USDe makes money while $USDC costs less than 5%
that borrowing lifted the lender rate from 1.9% to 2.5%, then almost stopped once Aave's $USDe cap filled on saturday
at today's pace, this week's reward budget runs out around wednesday. Ethena has refilled it every week since september, but if that ever stops, these wallets lose money and the lender rate would likely slide back toward 2%
if you lend $USDC on Aave, Poloniex has cut your yield in half
@Poloniex moved $1.5B into $USDC on @aave yesterday, right after pulling it out of $USDS, and Aave raised the deposit cap in the middle of it to make room
the rate went from 4% to 2%, which is about $150K a day less for everyone else lending there
its deposit is now bigger than all the free cash in the pool, so even Poloniex couldn't take everything out today
the biggest winner so far is @ethena, Aave's largest $USDC borrower, whose $383M loan just got a lot cheaper
raising caps without a vote is normal practice for Aave's risk steward @LlamaRisk
but with one supplier already holding 21.7% of the market, i think this one should have gone to a vote
$ENA halved in a month while $USDe looked like it grew
$USDe grew by $230M in that time, but @ethena's own wallet added $395M by looping on @aave. without that wallet, the rest of $USDe shrank by more than $160M
on paper the fee switch got closer. $USDe now needs to grow 54% to reach the $7.5B that turns it on, down from 63% on nov 6. without Ethena's own wallet, it needs 68%
$ETH also fell 29% in a month, so i won't blame the $ENA drop on $USDe alone. but until the rest of $USDe grows, the switch only gets closer through Ethena's own money
@conquercube agree, using it would wreck trust. but you just said the CEO and the foundation are the borrowers, so holders are basically trusting them to pay it back, there's no other lever right now
one repayment from them would end this whole debate
@conquercube@canyonnn yeah, he's right that it's not new, onchain liquidations for this collateral have been off since sep 2025, and Sky's docs called it temporary back then. didn't check the T&C page itself, but nothing in the contracts changed this week
honestly we agree on more than it looks. repayments are peanuts, and an injection or turning liquidations back on are both up to Sky, that's what my last line was about
on reserves, the stUSDS contract has a function called cut that lowers the value of every holder's share to cover bad debt, so who eats a loss is a governance call too
if the council does the injection, i'll post that
@ImperiumPaper@BoatBuilder27 thanks, that matches what i see onchain. the second biggest borrower is a Safe that has rune.eth's Safe as one of its 6 signers, is that the Sky Frontier Foundation one?
Sky's Spark covered a $104M exit from Coinbase's $BTC loans
Coinbase runs these loans through one @Morpho market on @base
yesterday a wallet that @ethena lists as $USDe backing pulled $104M of $USDC out of that market in two rounds, and both times @sparkfinance refilled most of the gap within 45 minutes
borrowers kept paying 5.2%, while without the refill the rate would have jumped to about 9%, unless another lender stepped in
Spark and @grovedotfinance, both funded by @SkyEcosystem, now supply 52% of the money in this market
so Sky is already the lender of last resort behind Coinbase's $BTC loans
i get why a week of $stUSDS posts reads like FUD
but i haven't told anyone to sell or pull out, and i post when @SkyEcosystem does things well too
- $SKY holders got 5x more after the august vote
- Sky paid holders $5.8M in october, and i asked why $SKY was this cheap
- $sUSDS paid out at $1 with no queue during the Binance hack
- @sparkfinance covered a $104M exit from Coinbase's loans on @Morpho
my problem is one product where 48% of the debt sits with rune.eth, another 25% with a Safe his Safe co-signs, and the exit has been basically shut since nov 11
the day those loans get repaid, i'll post that too
He’s been shitting on Sky for days over stUSDS, a segregated risk-capital product that was always designed for higher yield and temporary illiquidity at high utilization.
Meanwhile Sky generates ~$400M in annual fees and ~$160M in net revenue. It also holds ~$93M in liquid reserves.
People are sitting on the sidelines mainly because they’re afraid they won’t be able to exit. If the Council drops 5-6M of liquidity into the pool (which would still earn interest), the door opens and deposits would flood back in for the rate.
The only one still talking shit is him.
@BoatBuilder27 yeah that part bothers me too. onchain rune.eth has 48% of the debt, and the second biggest borrower with 25% is a Safe that has rune.eth's Safe as one of its 6 signers
so about 73% ties back to him. can't confirm 98% yet, if you have a source for the rest send it and i'll check
yeah it was built to lock up when it's fully used, the app says so too. it's just been basically full since nov 11 and the rate's about to hit its cap
a council deposit is pretty much what i meant in the last line. but every repayment since nov 19 got pulled out within seconds, so $5-6M would probably be gone in minutes too unless there's a plan for the $77M
not short, i don't hold any $SKY
698 is how many addresses hold $stUSDS, it's not new money. since nov 19 the vault got exactly one deposit, $3
in that time people bought $stUSDS on Curve 409 times, below the vault price, and that doesn't add a single dollar anyone can withdraw
the 0xbbbb… row on your screenshot is Morpho btw, that's $stUSDS posted as collateral for loans
@iwantlambo@tether the article isn't saying they'll go under. it's about how thin the safety net got, and that the january report could show under 100% backing. redemptions are still being paid
i think gold is a bigger risk for $USDT than bitcoin right now
@tether holds $16.3B of gold and only $6.0B of $BTC
a 1% drop in gold costs its safety net about $163M, while a 1% drop in bitcoin costs $60M https://t.co/Pwx5wnL3kh
@0xTraderSam@tether agree, they'd raise easily and redemptions are fine. but debt raised by the issuer itself barely moves the safety net, since it adds to what they owe. it only helps the january number if it goes in as equity
@canyonnn@CurveFinance same question here. the biggest loan is rune.eth's $77M against 3.6B $SKY. repaying from collateral means selling about $77M of $SKY, close to 5 days of its trading volume. but sitting at 35%+ and climbing isn't cheap either
selling $stUSDS on Curve now costs 16%, up from 10% yesterday
one $stUSDS sells for 0.91 $USDS in the @CurveFinance pool, while the vault values it at 1.09
the rate went up to 34.74% last night, and the next step to 39.74% can come within the hour
a 16% loss is about 7 months of farming at 34.74%
if nobody repays, the rate can reach 49.74% sunday night and hit its 50% cap on monday
the cost of selling $stUSDS on Curve went from 1.8% to 10% in a day
no borrower has repaid since yesterday afternoon, and the @CurveFinance pool has about $100K of $USDS left to pay sellers, down from $276K yesterday morning
what worries me more than the rate is the exit price, because a 10% loss equals about 5 months of interest at the new 29.74% rate
Sky's co-founder said yesterday that $stUSDS doesn't back $USDS and that more on it is coming soon
two rate hikes in a day didn't make anyone pay more for $stUSDS on Curve, so holders need his update more than tonight's next step to 34.74%