@Mark_Goldberg@mgeist@MarkJCarney@UAlberta Possibly because Avnish has, for his entire career, demonstrated a commitment to fighting for those who have been treated unjustly?
@petersankoff Instead of having one offence which is broadly defined, divide into more narrow offences, as is done with with assault/many others. This will naturally ensure that RHs will be much more similar to the facts of the offence.
@petersankoff If someone was to burn their flag inside a restaurant or store or theatre, wouldn't that be interfering with other's enjoyment of property?
@charlesrusnell Having worked with Mr. Miller a number of times (whether on the same or opposite side of a case), he is a good lawyer. Judging a lawyer because of who their client is undermines an important principle of our legal system.
@ParlCharlie To give an honest answer:
Much like our system for dates, e.g. Tuesday(Norse religion), March(Roman religion) X, 2023(Years since Jesus), Christmas has transcended it's religious origin, and has become part of the cultural milieu.
@DNetolitzky@_llebrun I'd also add that the odd interpretation stems from a misunderstanding of the 'maxim' "Expressio unius est exclusio alterius.".. Their view of that maxim is that any definition that uses "includes" automatically excludes anything not listed.
@DNetolitzky@FloTempelhof@DrSarteschi Wow. Great article by @DrSarteschi, thanks for pointing it out @DNetolitzky . My only thought is that it doesn't address QR's most legitimate claim to authority... that her name is an anagram of "I am our Donald [Trump]". Can anyone point out a more legitimate claim than that?
@avnishnanda @DeanLeckey Interesting...
So you're suggesting that the invocation of the notwithstanding clause(s 33) essentially protects the legislation from the application of s 52(in regards to s 2,7-15), but s 24 remedies remain? I haven't heard that argument before.
@DNetolitzky I think you're quite right when that it goes much beyond "lawyer expense".
Remember, in certain areas(e.g. criminal matters at trial) there is a right to be represented. So the causes of SRLs there are much more narrow than elsewhere. I can send you further thoughts privately.
@RyanHClements Nicely done. Obviously I'm a bit biased, but I'm happy to see that the reasoning in Ford hasn't been diminished by the argument outlined in MM.
When a photographer was given rare permission to follow two detectives through Tokyo on a murder case, whoβd have known heβd gather a legion of fans decades later.