Respect for speaking up 🙏
BAPS faced weeks of accusations. Now the Paris investigation confirms there was no explicit request from the delegation to exclude women throughout the visit. It points instead to failures in how arrangements were communicated and implemented.
Female staff were sidelined and that should never have happened.
But allegations travelled faster than facts.
Those who amplified the original story should give these findings the same attention.
Truth deserves the same reach as outrage.
@BFMTV Celibacy discipline in question is centuries old, documented, and specific to monks' personal conduct and not evidence of a doctrine governing the public. The same festival featured a procession and assembly led by women in public.
#FakeNews#EiffelTower#BAPS
BAPS approached the Eiffel Tower authorities well in advance, requesting an exclusive time slot during the very early hours of public access and clearly communicating its requirements beforehand. The authorities were entirely free to accept or decline the request. They chose to accommodate it and made the necessary arrangements.
How they decided to facilitate that request was ultimately an operational matter for the Eiffel Tower authorities. I don’t think BAPS should be dragged into a controversy over arrangements that it had formally requested in advance and that the competent authorities voluntarily agreed to provide.
I have also had the good fortune of interacting with BAPS sannyasis on several occasions. Many of them are exceptionally bright and accomplished individuals who could quite easily have become leaders in their respective professional fields had they chosen to remain in the material world. Instead, responding to an inner calling, they consciously chose a life dedicated to spirituality, discipline and service.
Spiritual and religious organisations across faiths have their own traditions, protocols and ways of doing things. At times, these may differ considerably from what is considered normal or customary in the wider world. That is neither unusual nor unprecedented.
Ridiculing these sanyasis simply for adhering to what they sincerely believe in,
particularly when their requirements were communicated through a proper advance request and accepted by the authorities, seems unfair.
I have been thinking about the recent visit of BAPS Swaminarayan monks to the Eiffel Tower, and it brought back an experience of my own that I have never quite known how to articulate.
Some time ago, I was staying at an accommodation where Swaminarayan monks were also living next door. They followed a practice of not “seeing” women, which meant that, at certain hours, I could not access some common areas.
My first reaction was indignation. I remember thinking: Is this not exactly why women have to try twice as hard to be considered half as good? As someone who has always been outward-looking and travelled extensively, I was even tempted to write an X thread about how such seemingly regressive practices could thrive in the 21st century.
And then something unexpected happened.
The monks cooked their own food — simple, beautiful sattvic meals. Their sahayaks began leaving breakfast, lunch and dinner for me too, checking whether I needed more or less. Once, in passing, I mentioned that I particularly liked one of the desserts. Somehow, that comment reached the monks, and they began making extra desserts because they had heard that I loved them. The day I left, they even packed me a meal for the road.
The care was difficult to explain. It was quiet and completely unselfconscious — simply an attentiveness to whether I had eaten, whether I needed something, whether I was comfortable.
My initial irritation slowly transformed into a feeling I have experienced very few places outside my own home: the feeling of being cared for almost as one is cared for by one's parents.
It made me question my own assumptions.
Sometimes, a practice that appears exclusionary to us may have a very different meaning within the spiritual framework of those who follow it. That does not mean every practice is beyond scrutiny. If women are asked to temporarily leave a space when Swamis visit, it is entirely legitimate to ask why, whether they have a choice, whether they feel humiliated, and whether anyone is actually being harmed.
But perhaps we should investigate such questions without deciding the answer beforehand.
There is, however, another responsibility — particularly when such traditions travel abroad.
Practices that have evolved within a specific cultural and spiritual context can lose not merely perspective, but context itself, when transplanted into another society. In Bharat, someone may understand a monk's practice through familiarity with its traditions, vocabulary, discipline and philosophy of renunciation. In Paris, London or New York, someone encountering it for the first time may have none of that context.
What is understood internally as spiritual discipline can therefore appear externally as discrimination or humiliation.
This is something BAPS must be conscious of. When traditions enter public spaces abroad, intentions alone are not enough. The host society encounters the action, not the internal reasoning behind it. There is therefore a responsibility to explain, contextualise and, where appropriate, adapt how such practices are conducted in shared public spaces.
That does not mean abandoning religious beliefs.
It means recognising that religious freedom and cultural sensitivity must travel together.
My experience taught me not to judge unfamiliar traditions solely by their outward appearance. But it also taught me that those who carry traditions across cultures have an equal responsibility to ensure that unfamiliarity does not become needless offence.
We should be able to hold both truths at once: traditions deserve scrutiny, women deserve dignity, and unfamiliar practices deserve understanding before condemnation.
@AFP J’ai rejoint X pour répondre. Ce que j’ai lu m’attriste et ne reflète pas ce que j’ai vécu. J’ai aidé à organiser la visite de la tour Eiffel, un lieu que j’aime. Beaucoup de visiteurs étaient là et, à ma connaissance, personne n’a été empêché d’y accéder. La photo en témoigne.
It's common for people who don't know what BAPS stands for to point fingers based on sensational headlines.
So here is a comprehensive record of BAPS women's leadership & global impact—realities media houses rarely report during controversies. 🧵👇
Thank you, NSG Black Cats, BSF Air Wing, and Delhi Police, for your unwavering courage, discipline and selfless service to the nation. 🇮🇳
Your dedication to protecting India and its people is an inspiration to us all. #JaiHind! 🇮🇳
@nsgblackcats@BSF_India@DelhiPolice#NSG #BlackCats #BSF #DelhiPolice
#Akshardham @BAPS@BAPS_Bharat
The only issue about Kashmir that remains unaddressed & unresolved in India is that of the ethnically cleansed Kashmiri Hindus. But neither the opposition nor the government seems to care about them. Instead both are busy appeasing those who made fortunes on our blood & sweat.
@sardesairajdeep get your facts right, Delhi has Gujarati Samaj Canteen, Gujarat Bhavan Canteen, Swati restaurant, Rajdhani,Premvati and other canteens operated by organisations of Gujarati origin. Bhai Zomato pe check karlete
Good to hear PM claim that the new Gujarat Bhavan will have a special Gujarati food menu. so far,Andhra Bhavan way ahead of the rest. There isn’t a single decent Gujarati food restaurant in Delhi. Capital is run by Gujaratis but somehow dominance not extended to its food!!
@sardesairajdeep@sardesairajdeep get your facts right, Delhi has Gujarati Samaj Canteen, Gujarat Bhavan Canteen, Swati restaurant, Rajdhani,Premvati and other canteens operated by organisations of Gujarati origin. Definitely Andhra Bhavan has good South Indian food but this is worth trying.