@NCStateFan215@Kent_on1@allendwright@PackFootball@RCorySmith But it isn’t like they didn’t used to try. They did.
5 HOF QBs have coached in the NFL. None have a winning record.
There is just no evidence at all to suggest Phillips playing ability is some indicator that he can be a good play caller
@NCStateFan215@Kent_on1@allendwright@PackFootball@RCorySmith That’s my point?
If being a former elite QB was some sort of clear indicator that a guy could call plays like some fans seem to think it is, then you don’t think the billion dollar business that is the NFL would have tried to hire even 1 of those guys to be a HC and play caller??
@NCSUguy8@thelegendaryJT3@PackFootball@RCorySmith Being a good QB does not correlate at all to being a good OC. It’s an entirely different set of skills.
There has not been a single NFL HOF QB whose ever been an OC and veryyy few who were even pro bowlers.
His QB experience means nothing to whether he can call plays
Not even six months ago he was signaling support for executing race traitors, and now one bad midterm later he’s singing “I’m a moderate, I’m a gentle boy”
A lot of talk about how to fix the Players Era and it's so simple
- Take 1 team from 8 conferences
- Move the event to Maui
- Call it the Maui Invitational
- Play the title game at 11pm eastern the night before Thanksgiving
@theNCSUman@TwoManPackPod There is 0 historical evidence to suggest being a good QB correlates to being a good OC.
There hasn’t been a single HOFer or even pro bowl QB that I could find that has succeeded as a play caller
@thelegendaryJT3@PackFootball@RCorySmith Him being a play caller is a bad idea.
There is no historical evidence to back up your opinion that being a hall of fam QB will make him a good play caller
@Kent_on1@allendwright@NCStateFan215@PackFootball@RCorySmith Can you name a single Hall of Fame QB who has been a good Play caller? There isn’t one.
Hell even just a pro bowl QB whose became a good play caller.
If being a good qb was a sign of being a good play caller why don’t you think any of them have ever done it well?
@Kent_on1@allendwright@NCStateFan215@PackFootball@RCorySmith Can you name a single Hall of Fame QB who has been a good Play caller? There isn’t one.
Hell even just a pro bowl QB whose became a good play caller.
If being a good qb was a sign of being a good play caller why don’t you think any of them have ever done it well?
@thelegendaryJT3@PackFootball@RCorySmith It was Bill dadgum Belichek at UnC and we saw how that went...
He didn’t surround himself with college coaches and it totally failed. It’s a completely different game than the NFL.
@thelegendaryJT3@PackFootball@RCorySmith Because he’s never coached at College, never called a college offense and is going to have plenty on his plate as it is.
Being a great QB absolutely does not correlate with being a great play caller.
That is totally irrelevant.
@joshwgoodson Trust is earned.
Just cause we liked him as a player and think he could be the only hire that gets the money coming it doesn’t mean we have to blindly like all of his hires.
@thelegendaryJT3@PackFootball@RCorySmith I don’t think that’s a positive cause I don’t want Phillip calling plays.
But even if he is, hiring a glorified Tight ends coach with no recruiting experience or college connections still isn’t a good hire imo
@NCStateFan215@PackFootball@RCorySmith It’s not like Michael’s or Rivers have a history of coaching good offense so I don’t know how you can say that with any certainty.