Joseph Smith (First Vision): All churches were wrong. Their creeds “were an abomination,” and “those professors were all corrupt.” (JS-H 1:19)
Orson Pratt: “Both Catholics and Protestants are nothing less than the ‘whore of Babylon’… Any person who shall be so wicked as to receive a holy ordinance… from the ministers of any of these apostate churches will be sent down to hell with them.”
John Taylor: “We talk about Christianity, but it is a perfect pack of nonsense… it is as corrupt as hell; and the Devil could not invent a better engine to spread his work than the Christianity of the nineteenth century.” (JD 6:167)
Brigham Young: “There was not a Bible Christian on the face of the earth who was known to us.” He often called sectarian clergy “sanctified hypocrites.”
You’re assuming a false choice. We don’t mean “He only used what they independently intended.” Acts 4:28 predestined the deeds, not just the results.
We also don’t mean “God authored the sin / MADE THEM DO IT.” Primary and secondary causes are different. He ordained that they would freely do what they wanted, as the kind of people they were, and that their evil would serve His holy end. Their intent is theirs. His intent is His. Same event, two meanings (Gen 50:20). God determines that the creature will act according to its nature; He does not inject the evil into the will the way a man puts words in a puppet’s mouth. That is why they remain guilty and He remains holy.
Does Acts 4:28 mean God predestined only the outcome after they independently chose, or the deeds? If only the outcome, the verse is overstated. If the deeds, then “permitted and later used” is too small.
We do say all things are unto His glory. Paul said it first (Rom 11:36; Eph 1:6; Isa 43:7). Display is the shining of what He is, not a remedy for what He lacks.
We do not say He could only be just by creating people to damn. Justice is who He is. Sin and judgment make that justice known in history, together with mercy that a fall-less world would never have shown.
“Ordained that it be displayed this way” ≠ “could not be just otherwise.”
A toy soldier has no heart. A regenerated sinner does. Compatibilism is not assuming plastic people, but real people whose love, hate, guilt, and faith are theirs.
I agree God doesn’t need a narcissism fix. He displays glory He already has.
If “real” means “undetermined,” the cross was an accident God used. Acts 4:27–28 says otherwise. Real emotions. Real guilt. Real praise. None of it outside His counsel.
P.S. Go Braves! I’m with you on that, brother.
You’re correct that Calvin didn’t teach two contrary wills in God (this despite the fact that we should only agree with Calvin where he agrees with scripture). He taught one simple will that looks manifold to us (Inst. I.18.3). What he rejected was the line you’re using: that sin happens only by “permission,” not by God’s will. He called that an evasion.
“God forbids it / man does it / God permits it” is true. But it doesn’t explain what an omnipotent God is doing when He permits what He could prevent. Bare permission is not sovereignty.
Acts 4:27–28 is the test. They did what they wanted. They were guilty. And they did “whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place.” That’s not inventing a problem. That’s the Bible describing compatibilism.
The decree/precept distinction isn’t a patch. It’s how you keep both texts: He hates what He forbids, and nothing happens outside His counsel. Drop either side and you haven’t simplified anything. You’ve denied Scripture.
Calvinists don’t fear libertarian freedom because God is too weak to “manage around it.” We deny it because Scripture never presents God as a brilliant chess player reacting to moves He did not ordain.
If “libertarian” means the agent can do otherwise in the same circumstances, with the choice not falling under God’s decree, then several things follow that the Bible will not allow:
• The crucifixion was not “whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place” (Acts 4:27–28). It was God improvising after Pilate, Herod, and the crowd freely chose.
• Joseph’s brothers meant it for evil, and God also meant it for good (Gen 50:20) becomes “God used what He never intended.”
• “He works all things according to the counsel of His will” (Eph 1:11) becomes “He works all things except the ones that actually matter.”
Omnipotence is not the power to mop up after undetermined choices. It is the power to accomplish His purpose through real secondary causes—including the free, responsible, sinful choices of men—without becoming the author of their sin.
@Soteriology101 But hasn’t God willed man to have free will to do what they choose and his omniscience understands what they will do? And he chooses to allow all that happens to come to pass? Therefore, all that happens is according to God’s will even under your understanding of the conditions.
Calvinists have never said every sin is something God approves or authors. We have said He is never surprised by it, never merely reacts to it, and never loses control of it. He permits what He forbids, and He governs what He permits, without becoming the sinner. That is what “providence” has always meant. Collapsing the two wills of God (decretive vs prescriptive) into one is what creates the contradiction, not distinguishing them.
The White Throne is not God discovering anything. It is his disclosure of judgment. Calvinism says the books are real because the deeds are real, and the deeds are real because people really chose what they loved. God’s decree includes those choices; it does not replace them.
If “God isn’t surprised” makes a judgment fake, then any view with exhaustive foreknowledge has the same problem. The text does not care whether the Judge is surprised. It cares that the dead stand there, the books are opened, and they are judged according to what they had done. That is exactly what a Calvinist should expect if God is both sovereign and just: no surprise in heaven, and no fiction on earth. Decisions in this life do indeed matter because they are what will be judged.
Laodicea is a church, not a list of individuals. Jesus loves and disciplines some of them (v. 19)—He also knocks and invites anyone who hears to open (v. 20). That is compatible with a mixed body: false members who need to be born again, and true members who have grown sickeningly self-sufficient and need to repent and restore fellowship.
“Opens the door” does not establish autonomous ability any more than “believe on the Lord Jesus” does. And “spit you out” does not establish that the regenerate can be un-regenerated any more than the pruning language of John 15 does. The I is about how life is given; the P is about how those who have it are kept—including by being told, “Be zealous and repent.” Both can stay. The objection only works if you first assume that every command implies equal ability and that every warning implies possible loss of regeneration. The passage assumes neither.
Neither Gospel claims to list every move. Luke tells us they were from Nazareth, went to Bethlehem for the enrollment, kept the Law at eight and forty days, and later lived in Nazareth. Matthew tells us they were in Bethlehem when the magi came, fled to Egypt, and after Herod’s death avoided Judea and settled in Nazareth. Those statements can be put in one order if the family stayed in Bethlehem after the presentation, the magi came later, Egypt followed, and Luke 2:39 summarizes the eventual home rather than the next calendar day. That order uses inferences—so does the claim that the accounts are irreconcilable. The texts do not force the contradiction; they force a choice about how much silence you are willing to treat as denial.
@beready4rapture The accusation is not that they are resisting an inward, regenerating work already underway in their hearts. It is that they are resisting the Spirit as He spoke through the prophets (vv. 52–53).
@pbabinski91 It developed over time, drew on available sources, was revised, and Abraham can be checked against the source and found wanting. That is not the profile of “Rain Man.” It is a 19th-century religious innovator operating within the materials and cultural ideas available to him.
@pbabinski91 Large portions of the BoM track the King James Bible (including translation errors). The temple endowment ceremony was introduced just weeks after Smith became a Mason, and members who were Masons immediately noticed the similarities in form, signs, tokens, penalties, and ritual.
@pbabinski91 The BofM was dictated over a short period with multiple scribes. The D&C is a collection spanning more than a decade. The Moses and Abraham came later. The temple ceremony was introduced in 1842. This is the work of years, with collaborators, revisions, and evolving ideas.
@LutheranAnswers baptism saves as “an appeal to God for a good conscience… through the resurrection of Jesus Christ.” So the saving power is not located in the water or the performance of the ordinance, but located in the resurrection of Christ and in the faith that appeals to God.
@LutheranAnswers Peter deliberately qualifies the statement: He tells us what kind of “saving” he does not mean: “not as a removal of dirt from the body.” In other words, not the physical act of washing, not the water itself, not the ritual as such & He tells us what he does mean: