@andy1basura@Microelastics@crulge Everybody in these circles should read We Have Never Been Woke, which is persuasive from a leftist point of view. Its observations are I think kind of obvious to the rest of the political spectrum, but some people can only admit it on their own terms.
@Jocheved4@amabphrodite I agree. Some of the people I knew in college who were least well suited for transition were neurotic and fairly sheltered females. Not the kind of people who would buy T in an unmarked vial from some guy at a gym. Which would have been a good thing.
@Jocheved4@amabphrodite True! But it will scare some upper middle class kids off. It's like making drugs illegal. It keeps some people away, not everyone.
@Jocheved4@amabphrodite I do think males who detransition face different social incentives and frame their stories differently, yes. That doesn't mean some of them weren't failed by doctors.
Most female detransitioners blame themselves, too. Twitter influencers aren't representative.
@amabphrodite You're exactly right that part of the problem is people with autism and other mental illnesses not being good at assessing whether transition will help them. Maybe that's why doctors have a responsibility beyond informed consent.
@NancyPh32842797@theblaze What damage is permanent "after a few weeks"? I've never seen anything to indicate very short-term puberty blockers (or HRT) have long-term effects.
The bigger concerns are that PBs are taken for too long, and kids on them almost never get off the medical pathway to transition.
@FrednGinger3@datadriven_tdoc That seems right to me, based on my friends' accounts. I never get harassed, no matter where I go! It's kind of insulting- I don't think I'm unattractive. Literally never happens, even when it's happening to women around me. Who knows.
@ArthurKolchak But I just sent this to my wokest queer-adjacent (dates they/thems preferentially) lesbian friend and she thinks these people are ridiculous, so I am not sure who they hang out with. Was not aware people were still doing masks like this, anywhere.
@datadriven_tdoc Verbal harassment is a bit different, and I wouldn't be surprised if it was quite a bit higher for nonpassing trans women even compared to cis women. But verbal harassment also has a lot to do with where you hang out.
@datadriven_tdoc Hate crimes are extremely uncommon, in the grand scheme of things. But it's not just hate crimes- it's any targeted violence directed at strangers. Most violence is either interpersonal or opportunistic.