@grimmnaut@SECSupremacyFan@JoeGotBlown The 4L thing right now just really gets me - teams generally schedule for 2-3 easy OOC wins, they all do - SCAR has played two of them already, so they're 4-4 against teams with a pulse, and have lost two of those by 28 and 31...but because they beat Tennessee and 4L UF...
@grimmnaut@SECSupremacyFan@JoeGotBlown especially if it's being used to explain away losses. SOS doesn't use MOV, so lose to UGA by 3, ok...lose to UGA by 28...that's different, but SOS just says "UGA good, not a bad loss". I'm fine with Liberty not jumping #5 Texas, but why are we so sure they aren't better than OU
@grimmnaut@SECSupremacyFan@JoeGotBlown ...Bama wouldn't have known FSU would implode, LSU wouldn't have known Clemson would suck by now, and even in conference, there's nothing that OSU could have done to keep UM/PSU/Wisc from falling apart. I don't think SOS is THAT indicative...
@SECSupremacyFan@grimmnaut@JoeGotBlown and regular season still has injuries and in the early season guys working their ways in and all that - also historically the SEC has LOVED the bowl game stat when they actually win the games
@SECSupremacyFan@JoeGotBlown Yes, thank you for confirming my stat - the main flaw with regular season OOC is that most teams aren't looking to schedule OOC teams that can beat them. Not an SEC specific issue, but it's still not them going out and rolling through the elites of the other P4s.
@grimmnaut@SECSupremacyFan@JoeGotBlown and I was counting the whole of the bowl season, which was how the SEC has historically done it for their argument too - I agree that bowls have steadily become less and less indicative, but you can say that about any single game as a data point
@grimmnaut@SECSupremacyFan@JoeGotBlown I don't much care about the argument of which conference is the best, the real question is if it's actually reliable as "the 6th best team in Conf X is better than the 3rd best team in Conf Y" so that's why they have to get a playoff nod
@grimmnaut@SECSupremacyFan@JoeGotBlown They went 2-8 in the postseason against non-SEC, between playoffs and bowls, (counting that Tulane W), or are we doing the "yeah but they didn't really care about those other games" thing?
@Genetics56 There are currently 8 Ls by 4* scores by T25 teams, spread across: UK (x2), SCAR (x2), Oklahoma (1), Florida (1), Ole Miss (x2*, UF beat them by 24, technically 3 scores)...I see a pattern.
@SECSupremacyFan@JoeGotBlown Currently, 5 tms in the T25 have at least 1 FOUR score loss - UK (twice by 28), SCAR (by 28/31), OU (28), UF (28), and Ole Miss (24*/35), technically Ole Miss has a 3 and 4 score loss...I don't know how to square "all our teams are good" with "but sometimes they get walked"
@SECSupremacyFan@JoeGotBlown It does to the degree of validating if H2H v P4 in the regular season is a solid argument - last year the SEC was 12-4 on that and got SMOKED in the postseason, so is that a reliable indicator? That absolutely matters if this year the argument rests again on H2H v P4.
@Jbooty88 Right on the pods, this is purely just "we've decided full stop that Alabama is one of the best teams, regardless of any of the metrics or methods we say we use...vibes baby!"