God let @JarrinJackson learn the real fundamental law from @RealDaveCares4u and molly whop appeals court judges face to face with it.
God is mighty. Wow.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Sixth Circuit Reverses Dismissal of Stefanie Boone's First Amendment Claims Against Lowell Area Schools
Published appellate decision recognizes that government officials cannot use threats to silence parents who criticize public schools
November 14, 2026
PORTAGE, MICHIGAN: The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit has reversed the dismissal of First Amendment claims brought by Stefanie Boone against Lowell Area Schools, holding that she plausibly alleged that the school district violated her constitutional rights through an unconstitutional prior restraint and speech ban.
This is a significant victory for the First Amendment rights of all parents and citizens who have stood against the continued efforts of school districts that try to silence parents who criticize schools, teachers, and administrators.
Significantly, the November 10, 2026 decision in Boone v. Lowell Area Schools, No. 25-1948, is designated for publication. Its holdings will serve as binding precedent, extending well beyond this case and these parties.
Decision found here: https://t.co/Ljor9nxxa3
Matthew S. DePerno, attorney for Mrs. Boone, said: "The decision confirms what we have known for a long time: school districts cannot use threats of costly litigation to silence parents who criticize schools, teachers, and administrators. Government officials cannot accomplish indirectly, through threats and intimidation, what they are prohibited from doing directly."
Background of the Case
Mrs. Boone has been an outspoken critic of Lowell Area Schools, including its librarian. She has alleged they promote LGBTQ+, alternate sex, and liberal political ideology through manipulative behavior and without parental consent by giving children access to sexually explicit books.
Through private meetings with school administrators, teachers, and the librarian, as well as public comments at school board meetings, Mrs. Boone repeatedly asked the school to adopt an opt-out policy for certain adult-rated LGBTQ+ inclusive books that contain sexually explicit material. Lowell Area Schools has refused to adopt such a policy, even after the Supreme Court's decision in Mahmoud et al v. Taylor et al, 606 U.S. ____ (2025).
Rather than address the substance of her concerns about parental rights and age-appropriate library materials, the school district chose to target the parent raising those concerns, through lawfare and weaponizing government resources against her.
On January 19, 2024, Lowell High School Principal Steve Gough sent Mrs. Boone a cease-and-desist letter demanding that she "immediately cease and desist from any reference to any Lowell Area Schools employee on social media and/or other public communication platforms." In that same letter he threatened that failure to comply could result in "all available legal remedies."
Think about what that meant. A public-school parent was being told she could no longer publicly discuss or criticize any school employee, regardless of the subject or content of her speech. The demand came from a school official on school letterhead, backed by an explicit threat of legal action.
The Sixth Circuit's Decision
Mrs. Boone filed suit. The district court dismissed her claims stating "[t]he policies alleged here bear no resemblance to such restraints or anything cognizable as a ban." The Sixth Circuit disagreed, and recognized the constitutional problem with the school's approach. It reversed the district court on two separate First Amendment theories: prior restraint and speech ban.
First, the Sixth Circuit held that the threats against a parent, even without the threat of criminal prosecution, can be sufficiently coercive to violate the First Amendment.
Second, the Sixth Circuit recognized that the school district's threat amounts to a speech ban. The school district called the threat a "request." The Sixth Circuit rejected the school's label, but instead focused on what matters: the substance of the communication, the threat of adverse consequences, and its effect on protected speech.
A Decision that Extends Beyond One School District
This case is about more than one parent and one school district. This decision affirms that all parents have a constitutional right to criticize public officials, school administrators, and the policies of their children's schools. That right does not disappear because school officials find the criticism uncomfortable or disagreeable. School boards and administrators throughout Michigan and the Sixth Circuit must now accept that they cannot continue to weaponize government resources and generate lawfare to force parents into silence.
Mrs. Boone's claims will now return to the federal district court for further proceedings once the mandate issues. Mr. DePerno said: "We look forward to pursuing these claims on remand and obtaining discovery, including correspondence, memoranda, and other documents which the school and its employees have had a continuing obligation to preserve."
Parents should praise Mrs. Boone for her determination to stand up for her constitutional rights. She spoke out despite the school district's efforts to intimidate and silence her. She stood up when the school district, school board, and others used threats and government resources against her. This decision is an important recognition that constitutional rights do not depend on whether government officials agree with the person exercising them.
Matthew S. DePerno
Attorney for Stefanie Boone
Case: Boone v. Lowell Area Schools, No. 25-1948 (6th Cir. Nov. 10, 2026)
You tired of political parties not protecting you? What if you could stand on law and be free? Set a reminder for my upcoming Space! https://t.co/BqJ5BVyI2p
The law and govt have zero to do with personalities or politics.
@grok fill in the blank, 1 word.
MAXIM: ______ makes the government, not the name by which it is called.
I joined @kaitlancollins on CNN’s The Source last night to explain why I brought forth Articles of Impeachment against @SecWar Pete Hegseth.
Some argue Hegseth has been effective. I would agree. He’s been effective at breaking the law and violating the Constitution.
@RepTimmons With due respect, the Articles are about breaking the law and violating the Constitution, not policy disagreements.
For instance, Article III clearly describes how he is in violation of the law requiring congressional approval for a conflict that lasts more than 60 days.
@RealDaveCares4u 1.
Each time you open up a space and the people speak on truth in law it encourages us, brings hope, and strikes fear into the bad actors.
I’m thankful yall do heavy work.
@RealDaveCares4u Regarding one of the oral arguments from today talking about Bivens bull.
Cato institute guys telling maxims and going after qualified immunity as hoax.