@Willibee64@rcolvile I agree with your revenue point but you are wrong on bonds. Bond yields are pushing their long term historical average. I believe Gilt yields were pushing 15% in the 1980’s. Looks like you are both wrong!
Increase taxes and you reduce supply at a given price
Because they’re not going to go to the effort of supplying without a profit
So prices have to rise
Doesn’t matter whether it’s input costs, labour costs, tax costs, any increase in costs will push up prices
@Collectors_Way That’s socialism. What makes you think the government are best placed to look after people? ‘I’m from the govt, and I’m here to help’ the most terrifying words in the English language!
@Collectors_Way Are you not advocating for a socialist economy with greater government interference (acting like a family) with knock on effect of higher taxes?
@Collectors_Way Furthermore, in the system you crave- you don’t have a Jack Walker like figure who can transform the fortunes of a football club to go from second division also rans to PL champions. Jack was an uber capitalist, with a love for his people. He did more good than any govt!
@Collectors_Way IMO people don’t want to ‘make sure’ some people have more than others. It’s more that they want the potential for work & risk to be rewarded without being plundered for tax. Also self interest is one of the most powerful tools in improving the economy & bringing everyone up.
Why is a wealth tax evil?
There is no voluntary element to it. It is seizure of property.
It’s a thin line but most taxes are technically voluntary.
A person who doesn’t want to pay 40% income tax can withhold their labour at £50k. Many people do this.
A person who doesn’t want to pay stamp duty can decide not to buy a house. Millions of older people are currently refusing to downsize for this exact reason.
Many people refuse to buy a new car because of the 20% VAT on the purchase.
One of the reasons there’s no VAT on basic food, clothing and accommodation is because these things are not a choice. One of the reasons the first £12k isn’t taxed is because it’s deemed to be the poverty line and not a choice. The concept of voluntary participation is a built in consideration in a free market system.
Wealth taxes are different. The government reaches into your life and simply takes what they deem “fair”. There’s no transaction involved. There’s no choice in the matter. You have it, so they take it.
It breaches the concept of taxation being triggered through some sort of voluntary action.
It’s a slippery slope. Give government that power and who knows where it will end. Socialists minded people have proven time and time again they want it all.
"Capitalism is the force that drove down the price of almost everything it touched. The state is the force that blew up the price of almost everything it captured. And young people blame the first for the crimes of the second."
@DanNeidle@kevinhollinrake By the same token-If you don’t have iht relief on AIM shares, do you not disincentivise companies listing in the first place? Thus, disincentivise a route to gaining more capital to grow.
@GingertabsT@cosmograf That comes down to financial discipline. I know plenty who have it. Also depends on the amount but if a married couple have less than £250k, you could get 4.75% risk free & tax free in today’s environment.
@MckeownEithne@paullewismoney Also why does David Reuben have a responsibility to help me or you? He’s probably paid more into the system than me or you would in 100 lifetimes. Maybe we should consider what we can contribute first before we question his morals.