Sofist

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@hashimiyy_ Ash'ari Usul al Thalathah😭

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@ZaatarHoney @hashimiyy_ @Afumedo0 @KItreal512 How exactly is kalam nafsi = mu'tazilite view?

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@dzanfidahija Hi, you will?

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@arnesa_kustura "Serbs haven’t been reduced enough"

Is true though.

Their "insanity" justifies this position.

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@ShantihMuse @AndaluciaMaliki @KaafiyahChannel Al Bidayah fi al Usul al Din by Nur al Din al Sabuni says this explicitly

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@TaymiFawaid @AlJazari_ So you arent disagreeing with me, you just dont think that practically it is likely to happen?

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@CorboKenan Najzanimljivije je kako nijedna današnja skupina ne tvrdi da je Allah prostorno sveprisutan, a ovi se dignuli da tekst ilahije u ilmihalu koja glasi "on bdiije svuda oko nas" i misle da bdije znači biva.

Nepismenost prije svega

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@Hanbali2024 What is the issue with objects of speech?

When someone is a subject to speech (say informing that "sky is blue") sky would be the object of that speech since it is being signified by it.

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@Hanbali2024 For you to critique kalam nafsi, you firat have to understand the position.

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@Hanbali2024 You said kalam nafsi is composed.

I answer by clarifying the doctrine, the sifah isnt composed, but it signifies multiple things -> composition is in the number of objects of speech and types of relations between speech and those objects

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@fawiddchannel @RyanDrake181839 @ZouhairsMurid He says that he doesnt hold to takwin

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@stjepankotroman @bh11226j Jugoslavena je bilo 8% od cjelokupnog stanovnistva, ne od poginulih. Procitaj opet!

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@Hanbali2024 One Knowledge connects to multiple objects-of-knowledge without having parts.

One Speech connects to multiple objects-of-speech.

Objects to which the attribute is related to are multiple, not the attribute.

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@AdelIsic272961 @Uthmani1463 @aqalmn3 Regarding this, was the takfir made for the utterer, or only if the utterer had less than yaqin?

Given that those who allow saying it define iman differently, it seems strange to takfir upon it.

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@AdelIsic272961 @Uthmani1463 @aqalmn3 Tabdi' for Asharis rejecting attrinutes of action (takwin) and human choice (iradah juz'iyyah)?

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@TaymiFawaid @AlJazari_ If someone believes that his famous athlete is granted a karamah such that Allah creates for him a perception of a person uttering a request and the athlete, upon hearing it, wants the request fulfilled, and Allah fulfills it, is it still shirk?

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@abdurraheem_iv Per the hanafi madhab, she is obligated to cook and clean

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@badtripllama @_ClassicalSoul Why?

[Sofist @sakibuloni]

@ZaatarHoney @hashimiyy_ @Afumedo0 @KItreal512 1. Quran says Allah is a speaker
2. Every speaker is a speaner due to an inherence of speech within Him
-> Allah has Speech

Since He is eternal, His Speech cannot be conditioned ( letters/sounds are conditioned and specified)

-> Kalam Nafsi