Semlang Udon

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@luisdizon Luis, come on you’re making stuff up. Everybody knows that the root SH-L-M means “0K, perfect”. @InspiringPhilos

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@Dustin19462475 @ZakirHussainMDI @Jay_49erTikTok @MrAdnanRashid @AbuZakariyaMPOM You can also check my previous threads. The most recent one is a whopping 35-post-thread.

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

1/35 More plagiarism, misuse of sources and flawed argumentation in “Abraham Fulfilled: A Biblical Study
of God’s Plan for Ishmael and Arabia”? (Sapience Publishing 2024). By @AbuZakariyaMPOM,
@MrAdnanRashid and @ZakirHussainMDI. Read on and judge for yourself.

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@Dustin19462475 @ZakirHussainMDI @Jay_49erTikTok @MrAdnanRashid @AbuZakariyaMPOM Hi Dustin, I don’t do live-streams.But you can check my three academia edu papers here, for my take. I go into it in some detail. https://t.co/mluBKjKIAA

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@Jay_49erTikTok @ZakirHussainMDI @MrAdnanRashid @AbuZakariyaMPOM No problem. I also have a longer, more technical discussion here: https://t.co/5Up481ProM

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@Jay_49erTikTok @ZakirHussainMDI @MrAdnanRashid @AbuZakariyaMPOM And here: https://t.co/eJzE1Urhod

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@Jay_49erTikTok @ZakirHussainMDI @MrAdnanRashid @AbuZakariyaMPOM You can see further discussion here: https://t.co/vTj5zj3MdD

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@MrAdnanRashid @ZakirHussainMDI @Jay_49erTikTok @AbuZakariyaMPOM @HATzortzis and @SapienceOrg your thoughts on such similarities with the book published by you namely, “Abraham Fulfilled” and other sources?

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@ZakirHussainMDI @Jay_49erTikTok @MrAdnanRashid @AbuZakariyaMPOM On p. 54, Kalimi also mentions Ben Gurion, making the same point and gives the same reference that also appears in your book (endnote 467, p. 431). Is all this supposed to be a“coincidence”?

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@ZakirHussainMDI @Jay_49erTikTok @MrAdnanRashid @AbuZakariyaMPOM What is more, you can clearly see that the paragraph on p. 340 in “Abraham Fulfilled” has some “similarities” with p. 52 from Kalimi’s book as depicted below.

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@Jay_49erTikTok This is hilarious, is @ZakirHussainMDI, @MrAdnanRashid and @AbuZakariyaMPOM saying Zionist leader and Israel’s first prime minister, David Ben-Gurion, is a Rabbi? That would be a major historical blunder, wouldn’t it? Perhaps they should read up on their “Rabbis”?

[chonkshonk @chonkshonk1]

UPCOMING AMA!

In a few days, on May 13th, the linguist Dr. Marijn van Putten @PhDniX will answer ANY question from the community on r/AcademicQuran. Get your questions ready — questions will be submitted the day before, on May 12th.

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@Qasim51065629 @aktash111 @KhalilAndani @Abe_Kuyper Maybe I’ll do a thread about it at some point.

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@MercifulMessage From where did you get that “the Dead Sea scrolls, which are still only released in parts while the majority is under lock and key…”? Please tell me you’re not relying on obsolete info and repeating long discredited conspiracy theories. Anyways, can you provide sources for this?

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@luisdizon You forgot the wāw! Aramaicists will not be happy :-)

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@luisdizon Congratulations!

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@JordanAcademia0 @doofgeek4011 If that is Davis’ main point, then I think he should have avoided the problematic statements as I pointed out above.

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@JordanAcademia0 @doofgeek4011 That still doesn’t explain Davis’ way of framing it though.

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@doofgeek4011 @JordanAcademia0 Also, scholars have warned about making a too simplistic distinction between a collective and individual for quite some time now, a point I also note in the above paper (p. 30).

[Semlang Udon @SemlangU]

@doofgeek4011 @JordanAcademia0 Within, the songs, a division whose validity is disputed, there is to my knowledge, no consensus concerning the identity(ies) of the servant. I talk about this in the second half of the paper.
https://t.co/5Up481ProM