Funny enough, Indian philosophy anticipated a remarkably contemporary epistemological debate. Several classical Indian schools defended the view that truth is the natural condition of cognition, whereas error requires the intervention of some specific defect (doṣa) whether a malfunction of the sense faculties (indriyadoṣa), a failure of memory (smṛti), or some other distorting factor. The classic formulation of this position is the svataḥ-prāmāṇyavāda (the doctrine of the intrinsic validity of cognition) developed by the Pūrva-Mīmāṃsā tradition.
What is particularly striking is how widely influential this intuition became. Abhinavagupta, for instance, broadly accepts the same underlying principle, even while reinterpreting it through the lens of Trika Śaivism and an absolute idealist metaphysics rather than the realist framework of the Bhāṭṭa Mīmāṃsakas. More generally, much of the Indian literature on error (khyātivāda) operates within this assumption that cognition is prima facie trustworthy and that falsity requires a special explanatory burden.
For all practical purposes, this resembles a family of positions that both modern and contemporary analytic epistemologists have been attempting to articulate through different conceptual frameworks in recent years. One finds echoes of it in Michael Huemer's Phenomenal Conservatism, according to which appearances confer immediate justification unless defeated; in John Bengson's work on quasi-perceptual justification and intellectual seemings; in Thomas Reid's doctrine of common sense and the default trustworthiness of our faculties; in William Alston's epistemology of doxastic practices; and even, in a more modest form, in contemporary anti-skeptical positions that assign a defeasible but intrinsic justificatory status to ordinary cognition.
The convergence is fascinating itself: centuries before the emergence of analytic epistemology, Indian philosophers were already asking whether cognition is innocent until proven guilty - or guilty until proven innocent.
Old sages talked of the Emptiness within,
to keep that void intact with no desire to slip in,
to witness that empty void was the path to endless bliss,
to fill that empty void is the dream the moderns cherish;
1971 was THE LIBERATION WAR
OP SINDOOR is a WAR ON TERROR
India has re-discovered THE UTILITY OF FORCE
In 1971, we buried the two nation theory in the Bay of Bengal
This time, we have buried it in the Arabian Sea
@sreemoytalukdar Quiet a day it was. Too many questions mired in the deep inexplicable silences. Will the unfoldment of time answer all these? I just hope that the answers don't blow in wind this time, rather guide us towards the logical conclusions.
Where mercy is a flaw, if You sound
May my ruthlessness know no bound
And at Your gesture, through my voice
May truth strike falsehood down to ground.
He who commits wrong or condones the same,
May your contempt singe like a reed in flame.
– Rabindranath Thakur
Bengali Original:
ক্ষমা যেথা ক্ষীণ দুর্বলতা,
হে রুদ্র, নিষ্ঠুর যেন হতে পারি তথা
তোমার আদেশে। যেন রসনায় মম
সত্যবাক্য ঝলি উঠে খরখড়গসম
তোমার ইঙ্গিতে। যেন রাখি তব মান
তোমার বিচারাসনে লয়ে নিজস্থান।
অন্যায় যে করে আর অন্যায় যে সহে
তব ঘৃণা যেন তারে তৃণসম দহে।
Through consciousness, for consciousness. Clearly Advaita in action. Will that include singularity also as a structured experience in coming times? I think, it should. There lies the difference between intelligence and consciousness.
@JoeAgneya Probably mindful learning and remembrance is the prerequisite for problem solving, comparative analysis, first principle thinking, and other higher order methods.
Intuitive methods may probably bypass the learning games. However, it cannot completely root out the essence.
@suryakane What we need is the leaders of the wrath of Parshuram and the wisdom of Rama. Until these two blooms in an individual, the stark reality is gonna haunt us.
@suryakane Intuitive spiritualism and intellectual philosophies are but the means of gaining the orgasmic delight unless the political and economic conventions are taken care of. Only a healthy body can nurture a healthy mind and prepare one to achieve the Whole.