If you think Zionism is more Nazi-like than the ethnonationalism of, say, Saudi Arabia, or—scratch that—Hungary or Poland (EU member states), or Ukraine (darling of western liberalism), or even the anglophone or francophone worlds, then you know absolutely nothing of history and are probably not a keen observer of the politics of the present either.
OK this is silly. If I gave you 100 clips of Jews saying awful things and 101 clips of Jews saying the opposite, which is representative?
And nope, no “program” to “get with,” if by “program” you mean Europe’s 1000-year-old program of demonizing Jews (with so-called “evidence”). Sorry not joining that club.
Read “Europe Against the Jews” by Götz Aly if you want to understand the tradition you’re carrying on.
https://t.co/bVAySSyvPd
K dude, sharp turn onto conspiracy theory lane is when I check out, because no amount of evidence to the contrary can counter a false narrative you’re determined to hold. ‘twas ever thus.
European Christian mobs who burned Jews at the stake for using Christian blood on Passover were acting with reason and righteousness once you set aside the pesky fact that they were incited by blatant lies. There’s no reasoning with such beliefs. I hope you can one day see that. Ciao.
I’m guessing you’re trying to tie this to Israel. So, genuine question: suppose all the world, incl. Israelis, wake up tomorrow and see your point and agree, what happens then? Do you genuinely believe that Zionism overall, or the state of Israel action’s in particular, are driven by a mistaken belief re LLX vs MT?
You are aware that Zionism was conceived, implemented, and largely continues to be a secular movement, correct? And that Herzl and Ben Gurion, along with much of Israel’s founding generation, were hostile to religious belief and practice, right? So you’d need a theory for how any interpretation of a given Biblical passage affects anything beyond polemics. At best it’s an academic issue. How do you see it affecting Israel’s actions?
You’re being unclear on the specific argument you’re making. I found a thing you said intriguing even if I disagree; but I got here in the middle, so pardon me if I’m not following your larger point. Is your argument here linguistic? Historical? Political? Religious? What’s at stake here?
This isn’t how evidence works. “Greek translators… wouldn’t fuck that up” has exactly the same validity as “The Masoretes wouldn’t change the Hebrew.” Both are reasonable claims; both without evidence. But it stands to reason that a translation would introduce variation in a way that transcription wouldn’t.
I can’t quite explain why this made me spit my coffee.
Dude’s upset with the Talmud saying Gentiles go to heaven, because “it’s not the same heaven homie.”
I’d really like to know if anyone has solid info on “Jewish heaven” vs “plain heaven.” Is it like a first-class vs economy thing?
“Have a share in the world to come” doesn’t mean it’s the same heaven homie.
Everything else you asked grok is common Islamic doctrine.
Just as Jews who believe gentiles who follow the Noahide laws will go to heaven, though it’s SEPARATE, Muslims believe if you convert to Islam you’ll go to heaven too.
It’s the same heaven though😚.
Now, I’ll ask my question again, do you believe Jesus is the messiah or did you relinquish that belief to be a true Noahide?
For 1000 years they persecuted Ashkenazi Jews as Christ-killers. And suddenly it’s convenient to say, “Actually, you were never even there”? Could these Jew-haters get their goddamn story straight?
Also, is Joe Rogan actually this dumb? I mean, seriously, what’s the theory? A majority of the world’s Ashkenazi Jews live in the US. Is Israel just hoping they’ll keep their 23andme results secret?
New: Joe Rogan reveals to comedian Sam Tallent that the real reason Israel restricts DNA ancestry testing is because most of the people over there aren’t Semites and are actually just European Jews:
ROGAN: “The real Semites are the Palestinians. Benjamin Netanyahu’s family is from Poland.”
CONTEXT: Israel does have restrictions on DNA testing.
According to Israel's Ministry of Health, paternity and family-relationship DNA tests generally require a COURT ORDER, even when everyone involved consents.
And there's an especially surprising detail.
MyHeritage, an ancestry-testing company HEADQUARTERED IN ISRAEL that offers DNA kits internationally, explicitly lists ISRAEL among the countries where its consumer ancestry tests are unavailable.
But that does NOT establish Rogan's allegation about WHY these restrictions exist.
Israel's genetic-information laws address matters including consent, family relationships, privacy, and potential consequences for children.
There is no substantiated evidence that the restrictions were created to conceal the ethnic origins of Israel's Jewish population.
And when Rogan brings up Netanyahu's Polish family roots, he's referencing something with a documented historical basis.
Netanyahu's father, Benzion Netanyahu, was born in WARSAW in 1910, before his family immigrated to what was then British Mandatory Palestine.
But European family history doesn't automatically mean someone has no ancient Middle Eastern ancestry.
In fact, scientific research reveals a much more complicated story.
IMPORTANT NOTES: A major genetic study published in NATURE in 2010 found evidence connecting many Jewish diaspora communities to shared ancestral origins in the LEVANT.
And a 2020 study published in CELL examined ancient DNA from Bronze Age populations in the region.
Researchers found substantial genetic continuity between ancient Levantine populations and multiple populations living in the region today, including Jewish and Arab communities.
In other words, the evidence points to a history of shared regional ancestry, migrations, and intermixing. It’s not a simple genetic division between two populations.
Then Rogan takes the discussion even further.
He questions whether the term ANTISEMITISM should instead be called “anti-Jewish,” arguing that Palestinians have a stronger claim to being called Semites.
But there's another important historical distinction.
“Semitic” originally refers to a LANGUAGE FAMILY that includes Hebrew and Arabic, not a scientifically defined genetic race.
And the word “antisemitism,” despite its linguistic roots, has historically referred specifically to hostility or prejudice toward JEWISH PEOPLE.
For 1000 years they persecuted Ashkenazi Jews as Christ-killers. And suddenly it’s convenient to say, “Actually, you were never even there”? Could these Jew-haters get their goddamn story straight?
Also, is Joe Rogan actually this dumb? I mean, seriously, what’s the theory? A majority of the world’s Ashkenazi Jews live in the US. Is Israel just hoping they’ll keep their 23andme results secret?
הליכוד:
הבחירות במדינת ישראל נגנבו על ידי מפלגות ערביות שתומכות בטרור ובחיסול המדינה היהודית באמצעות עבירות פליליות חמורות של שוחד, איומים, אלימות, זיופים ושימוש בתוכנות אסורות להמרצת מצביעים.
מפלגת הליכוד מעבירה למשטרה, לשב״כ ולוועדת הבחירות מאות עדויות וראיות על גניבת בחירות בקלפיות ערביות רבות- אלפי מעטפות עם כסף מזומן ופתקי רע״ם, איומים ואלימות כלפי חברי הקלפי, ריבוי מצביעים מאחורי הפרגוד, הצבעות בזהות כפולה, פערים בי�� מספר המעטפות למספר המצביעים, שימוש בתוכנות המרצה אסורות ועוד.
אנו דורשים מהמשטרה ומהשב״כ חקירה יסודית בגין גניבת הבחירות על ידי המפלגות הערביות ומיצוי הדין עם העבריינים.
אנו דורשים מוועדת הבחירות התייחסות מיידית לחקירת העבירות הפליליות הללו שפגעו באופן קיצוני בטוהר הבחירות בישראל ובתוצאות הבחירות.
זו פגיעה חמורה בדמוקרטיה הישראלית ובזכות הבחירה של אזרחי ישראל. גופי האכיפה מוכרחים לפעול ביד קשה ובאופן מיידי.
@amalmerzouk@dzfeldman Except Taleb doesn’t criticize a state. His obsession is arguing that Jews don’t belong in the Levant. Funny that when Jews lived in Europe, some argued they didn’t belong there either.
@KIVUNature@mhdksafa You imagine wrong, but what’s more fascinating is how utterly unself-aware you are in putting your ignorance on full display. You clearly know nothing about Israelis. OTOH Inventing shit about Israel is very fashionable these days, so at least you’re in lockstep with the herd.
@RaafatAbualazm Genocide is bad.
Is that all took? Will people now no longer commit crimes against any Jews who “are not the state”?
Is this how you think anti-Jewish violence works?
“I venerate Judaism.. I stand with the Jewish people.., but not Israel.”
This simply cannot be said with sincerity.
Essential to Jewishness—religious or secular—is the idea that we are one people. The Jewish world today is split right down the middle between the US and Israel; to now demand half the world’s Jews stop caring about the other half is not only unreasonable, it is cruel—and also an impossible, unnatural demand.
To say to Jews, “we love you—just so long as we can hate the Jews in the next town over,” is just a modern twist on the oldest hatred and not a bargain most Jews will take. I think it’s time we make it clear: if that’s the deal you’re offering, we sure as shit don’t love you back.
@Worst_Human_Eva Jews may tell other Jews all sorts of things, as we are a famously argumentative people. But “the goyim will hate us if we don’t accept their lies” isn’t an argument we’ve historically found persuasive.