Two big arguments I see defending @Pontifex on the death penalty. Both fail.
Argument one: we can lock people up now, so execution is unnecessary.
Francis undercut this himself. In Fratelli Tutti 268 he called life imprisonment a "secret death penalty." If a life sentence is morally equivalent to execution, it can't be the humane alternative. The argument refutes itself.
The "we have the technology" claim also assumes prisons reliably protect guards, inmates, and the public. The 2018 change to CCC 2267 rests on that prudential judgment about detention systems, not on a new revelation.
Argument two: execution violates human dignity.
If so, the Church violated human dignity for 2,000 years. Innocent III's 1208 profession of faith for the Waldensians affirmed that the state may exercise "judgment of blood."
The Roman Catechism of Trent treats execution as an act of the Fifth Commandment, not a violation of it.
A doctrine that flips it in 2018 wasn't "development."
Tradition also answers the dignity claim directly. Aquinas (ST II-II, q.64, a.2, ad 3): by sinning, man falls away from the dignity of his manhood.
Pius XII (1952) said the condemned man has, by his crime, already deprived himself of the right to live. The state doesn't take his dignity. His crime forfeited it.
Mercy and justice aren't opposites. Punishment that fits the crime is itself a good for the offender, the victims, and the common order.
"Wouldn't it be funny if we put women in government and they started doing insane things like banning videos of women saying they're happy being wives?"
"That's hilarious! Could you imagine? What kind of a society would be crazy enough to do that?!?"
Fun game - talk to a public school teacher about why they hate charter schools and they’ll deploy their usual talking points about funding and if you press even a little bit harder they’ll admit that good students with proper families hate public schools and if they leave the teacher will be left with only dullards and teachers hate the dullards so they want the good kids to be forced to stay.
This usually takes about 40 seconds of pushing.
Another bishop for China under the secret Sino-Vatican deal.
54yr old Fr Giuseppe Liu Hengping was consecrated bishop of Xiamen today, after being approved by Pope Leo on October 15
He was elected as bishop-designate by the Chinese state church on June 29
His consecration was performed by Bishop Yang Yongqiang, vice-chair of the state-approved bishops' conference which is still not publicly recognised by the Holy See.
As a thank you to our followers, we will be giving 5 followers a Large Print 1962 Roman Catholic Daily Missal, Marcel Lefebvre the Biography, 2027 Liturgical Daily Planner, Treasury of the Sacred Heart, and Flowers of the Passion!
Here are the 4 steps for you to take.
1)Like this post.
2)Comment which book you would like.
3)Follow Angelus Press.
4)Repost.
All comments must be on the original post in order to be eligible. End date November 30, 2026.
It seems that Trent Horn has left Catholic Answers.
Trent donated to my son's funeral costs last year, and he was quite generous. I am very grateful to him for that.
His last year has been pretty hard, with his wife being so ill and needing significant medical care.
I can relate, and it is a very heavy burden to carry.
I wish him all the best, and I hope people are very kind to him, given all he has been through and will continue to endure as they navigate their trials.
May they have a long and happy marriage together, and may we all rejoice together in Heaven one day.
I'm aware of how much time and money Democrats spent trying to lock up their political opponent, in opposition to democracy, and they still lost.
I'm also aware of the Democrats appointing their candidate for the last presidential election, not through elections, in opposition to democracy.
I was at a dinner once with a lib who kept peppering me with politics. I kept politely declining saying no I don’t talk politics at dinner, but she was relentless. Finally I explained why.
“You’re a horse trainer. Imagine if I sat here and said your horse should be a thoroughbred not focused on dressage. And you should use a different bit because he’s 19 hands. You’d laugh at me because it’s clear I don’t know what I’m saying. And if this happened over and over again, you’d eventually get annoyed. That’s how I feel when people not in politics talk to me about politics. This is not my opinion it’s my job. And it gets annoying having to talk about it with people who only know words.”
Needless to say it didn’t go over well. Point was made.
That’s what this debate is. Spicer is former WHSpox and an accomplished political professional. The little Twinkie is just that. Nothing. It’s annoying to have him “debate” Spicer when he only knows words.
The loser in this conversation is the audience. Political debate can be interesting but not when it’s a horse trainer trying to talk to a professional who just wants to get thru dinner and go home.
>Catholic church has a book “how to be Catholic”
>book explicitly says you cannot support abortion and remain in good graces with Catholic Church
>”there is no contradiction between being Catholic and supporting abortion”
Your parents paid for the wrong lessons
There’s a video game produced by a major USAID grantee that trains protest organizers how to overthrow governments using riots. The game teaches that you need to get the local mayor and police chief from where you want to riot on your side, so they don’t arrest your rioters.
@AbdulElSayed Meanwhile, people in Canada are getting MAID pamphlets and zero healthcare, coming to the US to get treated.
You're such a disingenuous clown.
Trent Horn no longer works for Catholic Answers.
Additionally he has had an incredibly difficult year in his personal life.
His mom passed away and his wife had cancer.
If you can, please consider supporting him here 👇