@siobh_99 You’re being intellectually dishonest (again).
This is not a general population survey of transgender identities. It is a needs assessment specifically of transgender and gender-nonconforming people living with HIV.
And the samples are incredibly imbalanced.
@siobh_99 You can go and have a look at the studies yourself.
I’m being intentionally low effort, because that is the time and effort engaging with you deserves.
My only intention is to demonstrate how wrong your claim is.
I really don’t want to engage with you further 😊
@inikizo@lucyuwu008 You’re being fragile to the point of having to delude yourself in to believing none of the above makes a trans person distinct in any way.
And no, none of the above excludes you from being a man.
@inikizo@lucyuwu008 Ffs, what do you want me to tell you? That being assigned female at birth, experiencing gender dysphoria, having to disclose transness to family, and go through a process of social/medical transition has no influence on how a person engages with the world around them?
@inikizo@lucyuwu008 I never said you weren’t.
If you don’t want to go to a Sapphic event, don’t go fucking go, mate.
But you also need to know that arguing against inclusivity as an exercise in your own affirmation is toxic AF.
@inikizo@lucyuwu008 Never said that at all.
Trans men have certain experiences that shape their relationship to masculinity, patriarchy and sexuality that is due to their biography.
Cis men and trans men have different formative experiences, that should be completely uncontrobersial.
@inikizo@lucyuwu008 “Bringing trans men into women’s spaces is transphobic” as if we’re dragging them to lesbian events and it’s not just that some trans men want to attend
If you don’t want to go, do go then
The idea of being welcoming and inclusive to fellow queer identities is not transphobic
@inikizo@lucyuwu008 Yes, they are, and also trans men as a group, have a different relationship to masculinity, patriarchy, sex and sexuality than their cis counter parts due to their biography as AFAB.
And that’s fine, totally valid and doesn’t mean that they aren’t men.
@inikizo@lucyuwu008 Not fitting in neatly should be an experience that any queer person should be able to relate to and have empathy for.
Trans men being able to attend a sapphic event and to feel welcome and included feels like such a modest ask.
@inikizo@lucyuwu008 My sense is that this is important to you is the very concept of trans men being included in a sapphic setting is dysphoric, which i get, and have empathy for.
My view is trans men (and trans woman) don’t actually fit neatly in our cis-oriented world.
@Mochi_Proto@lucyuwu008 I don’t care what relationship a person is in.
Pretending that a trans person is straight is just nonsense.
No one who identifies as LGBTQIA is straight.
They can be opposite sex attracted or in a heterosexual relationship, but never straight.
Get a grip
@SaturnAlienX@Zone__score They didn’t say that at all.
The reality is trans men as a group, have a different relationship to masculinity, patriarchy, sex and sexuality than their cis counter parts due to their biography as AFAB.
And that’s fine, totally valid and doesn’t mean that they aren’t men.