I always used to call Phil Foden overrated, how he is weird to profile. I stopped calling him that after he almost single handedly led Manchester City to a title in 23/24.
But now, I am starting to think maybe he just isn't that good. Maybe 23/24 was just a complete anomaly, and the previous seasons were more his level, a normality.
2 seasons of being lacklustre now. His only truly "elite" seasons were 20/21, and 23/24. The rest? Average, never saw the hype.