Amar Ghosh🇮🇳

I ❤️🇮🇳🪷🙏🫡 Advait Vedant(Quantum Physics),Books,Car,Chess,Dog,Hills,Serving Gov.of INDIA, Bengaluru,Once is enough(Time, Life, Wholeness), once is forever

[Rishi Bagree @rishibagree]

One of the best speeches by Modiji. #HappyBdayPMModi

[Anand Ranganathan @ARanganathan72]

Dear @Javedakhtarjadu. I'm afraid your response is as boring and overloaded as your similes and metaphors. When countered with facts, you shift the goalpost, bring in the RSS, berate the right wing, take refuge in context, cushion the bigotry, and claim Kafirs were Colonialists not Hindus.

I know countering you again is like watering a cactus and praying for leechis, but in the hope that all that knee massaging with Doctor Ortho would have sprouted some neurons, here goes:

You asked for a source because you said the quote was “quite unlike” Azad’s “lifelong sociopolitical stances.” I gave you the source: Calcutta, 27 October 1914, published in Khutbat-e-Azad. The words are his. That should have ended the enquiry. It did not. So let us walk through your new script, line by line.

1. “The khutbats were about Khilafat and British colonialism.”

Yes. That is what I wrote. Maulana Azad was telling Indian Muslims that a Turk’s battlefield thorn must be felt in a Hindustani Muslim’s heart; that Millat-e-Islam is one body; that friendship and enmity are for the religion of Allah. Then he quoted Quran 48:29 and added his own gloss: be extremely hard against disbelievers, extremely kind among yourselves, and do not pass over this as if you had not heard it. You asked for the when and where. You received both. “It was about Khilafat” is not a rebuttal. It is the context in which he said it.

2. “To claim he was quoting this about the Hindus of India will not be true. The Kafir here was the colonialist.”

I did not say the 1914 speech was a municipal circular against the Hindus of Howrah. I quoted what Azad quoted: a Quranic verse about kuffar, and his commentary on unbelief, Tawhid, and hardness toward disbelievers. If Azad had meant “kafir = only the British officer,” he knew Urdu enough to say Angrez. He did not. He used the Book’s word, then told his flock not to skip it.

And if “kafir” in Azad’s mouth was a temporary colonial nickname, kindly explain the 1920 Hijrat fatwa, published in Ahl-e-Hadith of Amritsar, in which he said Indian Muslims had no choice but to migrate, and that those who stayed and kept connection with “the enemy of Islam” would themselves be counted as the enemy of Islam. That is not a lecture on income-tax collectors. That is a theology of the land.

3. “When Ataturk took over, Azad called it a closed chapter and condoned the secular government.”

Men change. Texts do not. If later Azad made peace with the death of the Caliphate, good for the later Azad. It does not unsay 1914, nor the Khilafat years, nor Masala-e-Khilafat, nor the call that any government hostile to Turkey was hostile to Islam, not the belief in the Quranic verse damning the Kafirs. You began by saying the paragraph was unlike his lifelong stances. Lifelong includes the years he spent as a pan-Islamist firebrand. Evolution is not an eraser. It is a timeline.

4. “Read his Calcutta High Court statement. An honour no member of the Mahasabha or RSS was ever given.”

Sedition charges from the Raj are not a unique family heirloom. Tilak got them. Aurobindo got them. Savarkar was given two life terms and sent to Cellular Jail, where the honour included the oil mill, the lash, and years in a cell the size of a cupboard.

And of course, knowing your pitiful knowledge of Indian History, I guess you would not know legendary RSS names like Devipad Chaudhary, Jagatpati Kumar, Anna Saheb Deshpande, Ramakant Keshav, Vasantrao Oak, Narayan Singh, Chandrakant Bhardwaj, Dada Naik Chimur, Baburao Begade, Lala Hansraj, Balaji Raipurkar who participated in our freedom struggle and were jailed or shot.

5. “Azad was in British jails for nine years. Name one from your right wing who can match that.”

Vinayak Damodar Savarkar: roughly a decade in Kala Pani, further years in mainland jails, then thirteen years of internment in Ratnagiri. Sentence on paper: fifty years. Conditions: not Ahmednagar Fort with time to write Ghubar-e-Khatir.

By the way, you might know that your great-great-grandfather Fazl-e-Haq Khairabadi was also incarcerated at Kala Pani. What you might not know, or would want to hide, is that he wrote a grovelling mercy petition to the British, pleading to be released.

6. “In 1946 Jinnah refused to shake Azad’s hand. He hated Azad for his patriotism.”

How does this turn “be severe against the kafirs, merciful among themselves” into a sonnet about communal harmony? A man can spend 1946 refusing Partition and still have spent 1914 telling Indian Muslims that their first body is the ummah. Fairness is holding both pages open. What you are doing is hiding the 1914 page and waving the 1946 one like a flag.

7. “Your reference to Rahul Gandhi was unnecessary, I expect decency and class.”

And I expected you to have some sense of humour. The PS was a reminder that this is the second time I have had to fetch your hero’s paperwork. Last time it was Nehru’s India: books banned, editors sacked, films blocked, Majrooh jailed for a couplet.

You lecture me on class after moving from “this cannot be Azad” to “it is Azad but you must read kafir as colonialist” to “anyway he went to jail” to “Jinnah was rude to him” to “please don’t mention Rahul.” That is not class. That is a guided tour of every exit except the text.

Look, Javed sahab, let us end this here. I like you. Doubtless a lot of your work is incredible, truly it is. So in that spirit, permit me to pen an ode to you:

Javed Akhtar ko dekha toh aisa laga, jaise chhal ka nawab, jaise jhoot ki kitaab, jaise dhong ki kiran, jaise adambar ka van, jaise kapton ki baat, jaise pakhand ki raat, jaise janpath mein ho ek jalta diya.

Alvida, Shabba khair. WDTP

[Apurva Singh @iSinghApurva]

इंटरनेशनल लेवल पर 2012 में भारत की ये स्थिति थी।

[Amar Ghosh🇮🇳 @sympathyizer]

@rishibagree @SpiritOfCongres Who knows where a bar dancer opens a bottle cap from? Bottle caps are opened in so many ways.

[Mandeep RajBhar @MandeepRajBhar9]

महाराष्ट्र में पुलिस चेकिंग के दौरान एक कार रोकी गई। ड्राइवर शराब के नशे में था। कार में उसकी गर्भवती पत्नी भी थी, जिसकी डिलीवरी का इमरजेंसी केस था।

पुलिस अधिकारी ने चालान नहीं काटे, उन्होंने महिला की हालत समझी। ओर पति को पीछे बैठाया, खुद गाड़ी की स्टीयरिंग संभाली और अस्पताल पहुँचाया। वहाँ भर्ती कराया और महिला की डिलीवरी हो गई।

एक तरफ नशे में पति… दूसरी तरफ समय निकलता जा रहा था और गर्भवती पत्नी को अस्पताल पहुँचाना जरूरी था।

ऐसे वक्त में पुलिसकर्मी का मदद के लिए आगे आना उस परिवार के लिए जिंदगी भर याद रहने वाला पल बन गया।

[News18 India @News18India]

Goonj With Arpita Aarya : हर्षवर्धन त्रिपाठी ने कौन सा खुलासा किया? | JPSC-JSSC | Student Protest | Hemant Soren
#Goonj #ArpitaAaryaOnNews18India | @ARPITAARYA
#JPSCProtest #StudentProtest #Jharkhand

[Dr. Sudhanshu Trivedi @SudhanshuTrived]

पूरा देश देख रहा है कि झारखंड में छात्र शांतिपूर्ण, मर्यादित और अनुशासित संघर्ष कर रहे हैं।
न गाली गलौज और न ही अभद्र भाषा और
न कोई उन्हें अज्ञात स्रोतों से पेमेंट करके महंगे भोजन की व्यवस्था करा रहा है, न पिकनिक जैसा माहौल है।

जबकि यह सिर्फ पेपरलीक का मामला नहीं, बल्कि सरकार के साथ सेटिंग कर नौकरियां बांटने का कहीं अधिक गंभीर विषय है। फिर भी राहुल गांधी को रांची के छात्रों की ‘गूंज’ सुनाई नहीं दे रही।

कोटा से प्रयागराज तक दहाड़ने और चिंघाड़ने वाले आज रांची पर मिमिया भी नहीं पा रहे हैं।
साफ है उद्देश्य छात्रहित नहीं, राजनीतिक स्वार्थ है।

[AajTak @aajtak]

बीजेपी सांसद सुधांशु त्रिवेदी ने राहुल गांधी पर साधा निशाना
''देश के युवाओं से अपील है कि..दिल्ली और रांची को एक तराजू में तौल कर देखिए.. जो लोग छात्र हितों की बात करते हैं.. वो सिर्फ मुखौटा है.. असली चेहरा छुपा हुआ है..''

#SudhanshuTrivedi #RahulGandhi #BJP #Congress #StudentProtest #StudentIssues #RanchiProtest

[Amar Ghosh🇮🇳 @sympathyizer]

@ARanganathan72 @AmanChopra_ if these idiots are allowed to take power in the country, when there is so much rowdyism and dictatorship by them in just one state right now, what state would they leave the entire country in? And some of these Bollywood idiots are supporting them. Will always vote for BJP

[हर्ष वर्धन त्रिपाठी 🇮🇳Harsh Vardhan Tripathi @MediaHarshVT]

रवीश कुमार ने कहा- इतने संसाधन नहीं हैं कि, हर प्रदर्शन रिपोर्ट किया जा सके।
यह सुनकर माड़ भात नमक खाकर, बिना तिरपाल के भीगते प्रदर्शन करने वाले छात्रों ने सोचा होगा कि, रवीश तो बहुत गया-गुजरा है। उसके हालात इतने खराब हो गए हैं। बेचारा रवीश!

[Priyanka Choudhary @unstoppable_CH]

USA🇺🇸 is opposing FCRA
UK🇬🇧 is opposing FCRA
Pakistan🇵🇰 is opposing FCRA
Missionaries are opposing FCRA
Opposition is opposing FCRA
Churches are opposing FCRA
NGOs are opposing FCRA

India🇮🇳 must pass FCRA to restrict the flow of shady foreign funds🔥

[Padmaja Joshi @PadmajaJoshi]

No ‘Goonj’ in Ranchi?

No one will come to us from Delhi, no one even tweeted for us. Maybe because it doesn’t suit them. We feel ashamed entering home now. Ab kuchh bacha nahi hai: 2 young men sitting on Dharna in Jharkhand

[Amar Ghosh🇮🇳 @sympathyizer]

@MYogiDevnath 😄

[Yogi Devnath 🇮🇳 @MYogiDevnath]

कुत्ते को रोटी देते हुए राहुल गांधी

[Amar Ghosh🇮🇳 @sympathyizer]

@FabulasGuy Answer these leftist fools through your vote... Modi, Modi, and Modi... after him, Yogi, Yogi, and Yogi... by then, Rahul will be 90 years old... and just like Richa Chadha said—give food to old people on a piece of paper—the same should happen to Rahul

[Amar Ghosh🇮🇳 @sympathyizer]

@KanganaTeam Neither the father has any political skills nor any ideology. He just looks out for his own benefit and joins whichever party benefits him. Similarly, the daughter has neither any ideology nor any acting skills; she just speaks in support of whoever pays her.

[Amar Ghosh🇮🇳 @sympathyizer]

@indiatvnews @pradip103 @avanijeshDU @BhuvanProf @GhanendraB @peenaz_tyagi Opposition chutya hai.

[Amar Ghosh🇮🇳 @sympathyizer]

@NewsAlgebraIND Jharkhand me protest jo kr rhe hai wo student hai ya nahi...Kejriwal ke dalal

[BJP @BJP4India]

मासूम दिल से निकले शब्द, प्रधानमंत्री श्री @narendramodi जी के प्रति सम्मान की सच्ची अभिव्यक्ति। ❤️🇮🇳

इस नन्हीं बच्ची की भावनाएं सुनिए… सीधे दिल को छू जाएंगी। 🥹

[News Arena India @NewsArenaIndia]

“Come to Bengal as many times you want, your security is my responsibility.

Everyone has right to exercise freedom of speech in Bengal under new govt.”

- Bengal CM Suvendu Adhikari tells Taslima Nasreen