@KakoFLR@moontheloon22@madYouRetard Of course there is such a thing. It was also used by the Americans, Canadians, etcetera. Countries don’t go from 100% native to 85% white without it.
@KakoFLR@moontheloon22@madYouRetard The Falklands speak English because the indigenous population arrived from Britain. Colonisers, yes, but colonising empty islands; very different from Argentinian-style genocide-colonisation.
@KakoFLR@moontheloon22@madYouRetard You cannot actually believe this. Argentina is 85% white! You’re not a colonised population who resisted. You’re the colonisers.
The US, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand speak English because of colonisation. Their populations are, like Argentina, mainly European settlers.
@alzonotdead@DanielJHannan I’m curious. How did an Argentinian end up speaking Spanish? IIRC Spanish isn’t native to South America, but presumably there’s no colonising DNA in Argentina?
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood Location of birth is not nationality. Two Japanese tourists having their baby in Scotland do not give birth to a Scot or Brit. Meanwhile two Scottish parents having their child abroad still have a Scottish child.
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood I’m both. And also European. All to different extents. I’m not going to go around calling half my family foreigners because they live on the other side of a subdivision line.
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood FWIW my preferred model would be a handful of devolved English regional governments, with Westminster being only for foreign policy etc.
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood Isn’t it more cowardly of your o disavow any Scottish responsibility?
I could as easily say ‘well my region is a minority, smaller than Scotland, why do I have any responsibility’. I don’t because that’s silly.
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood Of course it’s normal. And independence movements driven by misguided nationalism are normal. See Brexit, or see Catalonia, or the Basque country, or Sicily, or Quebec, or any number of regions with independence movements around the world.
But normal =/= good.
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood But frankly everyone loses if you tear up the Union. It won’t make anyone’s dreams come true any more than Brexit did.
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood Within every country large enough to have regions, some regions have more people than others. That’s not unique to Britain.
Agreed that the wave of independence won’t be pretty, though! It will tear families apart, devastate economies, and only England will do okay fiscally.
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood So Britain’s actions are the collective responsibility of all British voters. The English are perhaps more responsible in sum, but not individually so. In fact they have mildly less ‘say’ than Scottish, Welsh, or N. Irish voters who have devolved governments AND a national say.
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood Apply your own logic. It’s not England, it’s the South because they’ve got the majority of MPs. But it’s not the South, it’s the South-East, because they’ve got the majority of MPs in the South. But it’s not the South, it’s London because…
This is how every democracy works.
@Indy_Quint@Pango987@admcollingwood Every democracy in the world means the most populated region gets the most say. Arguing for anything else makes you look like those American Republicans who post election maps where the empty desert votes Red.