@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage I think you have given me a false choice.
I am more concerned about hard itwas to get you to admits you wanted people gone who: have lived here for over 40 years and foreign carers whose income is topped up. Why couldn’t you just say that?
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage Okay, I understand your position. You want the following gone:
Some people who have lived here since before 1983
Some members of the Windrush generation
Refugees granted protection by the Home Office
And people in essential low-paid work, such as care, who have income topped up
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage So to be clear, you want returned:
Commonwealth citizens with the right to live here since before 1983
The Windrush generation
Refugees, and those who fled Ukraine and Hong Kong
Workers whose low pay is topped up
EU citizens, effecting hundreds of thousands of Brits in Europe.
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage Well you may or may not be right, but this is not how this discussion started. You were talking about migrants claiming benefit.
And I want to understand who from the following you want to return;
I will be listing them on a follow-up post
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage I'm confused. Is the problem migrants on benefits, or migrants in work holding down wages? They can't really be both at once. Happy to discuss either, but we started on benefits, so shall we finish that first?
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage The Oxford Migration Observatory, which made those ILR estimates, says they can't be compared with DWP claimant data. And two-thirds of ILR holders on UC are in work. They're low-paid workers getting a top-up, same as British claimants. Not quite the "cash machine" story.
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage 7% EEA + 6% non-EEA + 2% not recorded = 15%. DWP figures, January 2026, via a parliamentary answer on 31 July. Happy to share the link.
Can we keep this conversation courteous please.
I am just trying to understand who you mean specifically
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage 1983 is when the British Nationality Act ended new right-of-abode grants. Nothing to do with Blair. The 15% you refer to agrees with my numbers, mainly EU citizens (settled status,) long-term settled residents and refugees, all legally entitled. So I do you want to see returned?
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage Right. So you want people who have lived here since before 1983 who claim benefits to leave? Is that right?
Or are you talking about 7% EEA citizens or the 2% non EEA?
Can you be specific please, I am trying to understand the detail behind your requirement.
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage So who in the list of people I gave you above are you talking about. You said above right of abode is the problem, but the only non British, Irish people with right of abode have been here since 1983. So I assume you don’t mean them. So who do you mean?
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage Right to abode applies do All British citizens have it automatically. The only other people who hold it are a shrinking group of Commonwealth citizens who acquired it before 1 January 1983.
So who is it you want removed?
@sb559532603708@Nigel_Farage Most foreigners here on visas already can't claim benefits — it's a condition of the visa, and claiming is a crime. They also pay income tax, NI, and a £1,035 a year NHS surcharge on top. And Australia & Canada do give permanent residents healthcare and schooling.
@GBPolitcs Here’s the issue with this data.
Similar readings wouid no doubt apply to age — the younger demographic typically cause much higher crime.
And guess what? Immigrants tend to be much younger,
In fact the native born population is ageing fast, so this chart is a tad misleading.
@GBPolitcs Produce a chart which instead of nationality looks at circumstance: arriving via asylum or war, being young and single, insecure legal status, no right to work, poverty and trauma, then the chart might look very similar. In other words, correlation doesn’t always mean causation.
@GBPolitcs Brexiteers have a problem reading. Burnham said Russia tried to interfere, Doughty said they didn’t succeed “in their efforts.” Do you see the difference? If you can’t, I suggest you google the difference between tried and succeeded.