Finally, I got around to making a separate account for posting and sharing stuff many people might not want flashbanging their feeds. Might share my artism struggles more openly here.
@constans There are simply too many moving parts in modern physics research to credit one or a handful of people. The machines are too sophisticated for one or two guys to do all the work. Also, the public is willfully ignorant (see: Musk's recent ignorant takes).
@Samuel_Gregson That post, and all the people mad at you is even funnier when considering that the absolute basics of the double slit experiment are literal high school physics.
@Shaun_Fosmark@Hassaan_PHY The issue is that most ideas the public hears of or thinks of, are lacking that rigor, or have already been shown to not pass that basic standard. But the average person doesn't care for that aspect of science.
@Shaun_Fosmark@Hassaan_PHY They aggressively test alternative ideas that pass the bare minimum requirement of being compatible with things we already have tested to a high level of precision.
1. Everyone else doesn't agree that physicists have lost the plot. There is a significant number of people who think this (often lay audience led astray by people like yourself), but certainly not everyone. Whoever is under the impression that everyone thinks this way is stuck in an echo chamber.
2. If a large number of people believe something, that doesn't make it true. It is more about public perception, which is clearly not dictated by facts (especially today). Large numbers of people have had many other erroneous beliefs in the past (a long list can be provided here)
3. Theoretical Physics isn't as successful in the 21st century as it was, say, in the first quarter of the 20th century. However, the reasons for this fact don't include the talking points that you have helped spread, e.g., "Physicists are lying for grant money".
#physics #scicomm
@skdh You think that physics can advance without observational data? Because that is the second part of the claim: not just that theory has stagnated, but that collecting data is unnecessary and even counterproductive.
@PeterMorganQF@martinmbauer Look, my stance is this: I’m all for being polite. However, there’s only so much abuse one can take.
These people do not want a genuine discussion about problems in physics.
They come in with an agenda.
1/
Spend all day shitting on physics, lying about the physics and economic cases for new colliders, and pumping up cranks and clueless billionaires for populist, contrarian cash from a huge platform.
Be confused as to why your audience has a negative view of physics.
Pick both.
@peligrietzer The very first tweet in the chain says claude users, what they mean by people is implied after that, they're not trying to be misleading by not constantly repeating "claude users" every time.
@Diptipper That sounds really tough man... I don't know how I would handle it. My boss often opposes my explanations for things because I don't "speak" physics, instead tending to use computing/math terms (that he views as slang), but at least he's supportive...
@Samuel_Gregson If something was so well understood that you could simulate it and know the simulation was right, you wouldn't be doing the experiment in the first place. We build these machines because we are probing things we don't fully understand our models of.
@Samuel_Gregson This is such a common techbro trap, they somehow don't get the simple fact that no amount of simulation and computation will account for the fact that you need real measurements to make real progress.
This is now the lazy, cleverest little boy take regarding physics and it’s all over the internet.
Why?
Because it sounds deep to non experts, requires no knowledge or learning to say and plays to our anti-establishment moment.
Look, I'm not an oncologist but I am frustrated by the way this dog cancer story is being interpreted from a bunch of different angles and I think basically all of this can be cleared up if people understood like...six things.
You should know these 6 things about cancer:
@YurieAkko Looking through my library, most have female chaeacters that are at least on an equal level or better compared to the main male characters. I apparently just don't watch many shows where power scaling makes sense.