The materialist view of the brain is the geocentric model of our time. Consciousness isn't produced by the brain; it's filtered by it. We are long overdue for a paradigm shift.
@NaithanJones It's much older than the Church's decline. Democritus proposed "atoms and the void" 2,400 years ago with no evidence. The 1600s revived it, Newton made the cosmos look like clockwork, and neuroscience extended the machine to the mind.
@Pontifex An ontological difference is a claim about what a machine is, not what it does, and that's the question no one can currently answer in either direction. The firmer ground: art matters because someone means something by it, and we know that's true of human artists.
@DaveShapi Training selects for outputs, not inner states. We can select for a model that says it doesn't fear being switched off. Whether that's how it is inside is exactly what behavior can't tell us. With dogs we share the biology. With AI, the trained output is all we see.
@AndrewSchmidtFC And the certainty runs both ways. "Obviously it's conscious" and "obviously it's just autocomplete" make the same mistake: treating behavior as a readout of experience. Behavior is the only thing we can measure, and it isn't the thing we want to know.
@AlexanderKalian Probably not. But both errors are live, and they aren't equal. Treating a non-conscious system as conscious wastes concern. Treating a conscious one as a tool would be far worse. And our only detector is behavior, the one thing these systems are built to produce.
@AlexanderKalian Agreed that every framework rests on axioms. But they aren't all equal.
The one axiom nobody can deny is that experience exists. A good theory should start there and add as little as possible.
That's the test I'd apply to physicalism and idealism alike.
@AlexanderKalian "Complex things needn't be conscious" is itself a theory of consciousness. You can't make that claim in one line and call the whole debate speculation three lines later. Uncertainty isn't a reason to stop reasoning. It's the reason to do it carefully.
@francip Agreed there's one thing, not two. But you collapsed it in the wrong direction. Experience is the only thing we know directly; "physical brain" is a model built inside it. Make experience fundamental and the brain is what it looks like from outside. No hard problem either way.
@inductionheads Radio is close, but it smuggles in dualism: a signal plus a separate receiver. Better image: a whirlpool in a stream. Nothing is transmitted, the brain is what a localized pocket of mind looks like from outside. Which is exactly why intelligence and consciousness can come apart.
“Is the AI conscious?” is the wrong question. A flawless imitation of awareness tells you nothing about awareness, except that you can’t tell the difference.
@SamoBurja Samo I would love to message with you about my upcoming book. I think that the key to civilizational understanding is via understanding consciousness itself
@minordissent Or actually every individual is behaving exactly as anyone would given the circumstances, environment, and genetic markup of their lives.
Each individual has as rich an internal world as anyone else, but we are primarily shaped by our experiences.
Campbell’s framework maps almost perfectly onto what serious consciousness researchers have been building toward for decades. The idea that mind is primary and matter is derivative.
Filter theory points to the same conclusion from a completely different direction. The brain doesn’t produce consciousness, it constrains it. If that’s true, then the whole frame of aliens as discrete physical beings from another planet is probably wrong.
The harder question is why the government would arrive at this before the scientific mainstream. My guess is they’ve had encounters that forced them to update. The data dragged them there.
I’m writing a book on exactly this. The empirical case that consciousness isn’t generated by the brain. The alien question is one of the more surreal places that evidence leads.
AI learned to fake grief, love, curiosity, and pain. It feels none of them. The dominant theory of neuroscience says that's exactly what your brain is doing. If that doesn't disturb you, you haven't understood it yet. 🧵
The first Copernican revolution moved the Earth from the center of the solar system. The second moves the Brain from the center of the mind. That shift is underway right now. The AI industry just accidentally produced the strongest evidence for it. Follow if you want the full picture. This is what I write about.
For 300 years, Ptolemaic astronomers added "epicycles," patches on patches, to save the theory that Earth was the center of the universe. The model was grotesque but it preserved careers. Copernicus asked one question: what if Earth isn't the center? Everything simplified overnight. The Copernican question for neuroscience: what if the brain doesn't generate consciousness but filters it? Constrains a wider awareness into the narrow beam needed to keep a body alive? Start there and every epicycle vanishes. Psychedelics suppress the filter. Consciousness expands. The dying brain loses its grip. The person returns.