very apt analysis!
Dar-e-Nijaat is a fine show. Some ppl on X need to get over their cultural snobbery & realise that not every pop-culture phenomenon deserves to be ridiculed or dismissed as problematic. Some are simply meant to be enjoyed for their entertainment value!
I have recently been following some of the criticism of the Pakistani drama Dar-e-Nijaat. Some people are saying that the characters are not realistic and do not make psychological sense.
I am not here to judge the drama or Umera Ahmed's writing. But there is an interesting debate here about fiction. Does every character have to be relatable? And relatable to whom?
When I wrote my novel Hold On, I wanted to write a story that was socially grounded in Pakistan. The characters, their relationships and the situations they go through are quite familiar to many people in our society.
But I have received very different reactions. Some readers find the characters and situations very relatable. Some say they cannot relate to certain characters or their decisions. And some find the story too close to reality.
I think much depends on where we come from, our upbringing, social class, beliefs and personal experiences. Something that looks unrealistic to someone from an upper class family may be quite normal for someone from a middle class family. And the other way around.
But there is another question. Does fiction always have to be so close to reality? Can't a writer create characters who are unusual, relationships that are rare, or situations that we may never have experienced ourselves?
Of course, we can question how well a character has been written and whether their actions make sense within the story. But just because we have not seen such a person in our own lives does not mean such people cannot exist.
I think this is an interesting challenge for anyone writing fiction in Pakistan. We live in the same country but our lives and experiences can be very different. We read and watch the same stories but see them from our own perspectives.
What is unrealistic for one person may be very relatable for another. And what is relatable for some may be too ordinary for others.
Perhaps that is also what makes fiction interesting. We don't all have to relate to every character or agree on how a story should unfold.
While India just wrapped up high-stakes assembly polls in key powerhouses like West Bengal, Tamil Nadu, and Kerala (plus others) — with dramatic shifts, anti-incumbency waves, and millions voting — Pakistan's mainstream channels acted like it never happened. No prime-time debates. No panels dissecting the results. Barely a mention. Why the indifference?
Trump:
I would go to Pakistan, yeah. Pakistan has been great, they've been so good.
Islamabad—I’ll be—I might go, yeah, I might go. If the deal is signed in Islamabad, I might go.
Iran FM on talks
"Iran's position is being misrepresented by U.S. media. We are deeply grateful to Pakistan for its efforts and have never refused to go to Islamabad. What we care about are the terms of a conclusive & lasting END to the illegal war that is imposed on us'