What changes when we stop looking only at outcomes and begin asking about the conditions that produced them?
I explore questions like this across healthcare, education and environmental systems — sharing research, observations and questions as I go.
I once visited a team of specialist nasal surgeons, expecting to introduce them to something new.
Instead, I discovered they were already using it.
That encounter opens Part 2 of Evidence in Transit.
When does a scientific observation become a claim?
https://t.co/zd8r974GRg
@JKSteinberger An interesting collection of potential risks, each unfolding on different timescales. I wonder whether the greater challenge is understanding how they interact. How do we distinguish risks that simply coexist from those capable of amplifying one another across systems?
@breeallegretti Think D. Meadows & systems thinking. Reservoir levels are the visible stock & infrastructure, investment, incentives & delayed feedbacks shape resilience over decades. Are we witnessing a drought creating a crisis, or a drought revealing vulnerabilities accumulating over time?
I’m with you on this @DrGrahamLJ & the question we should all be asking, is, given the relationship between added sugar & disease, why are we still feeding sick people this toxic substance?
I am calling for a ban on sale of foods and drinks containing added sugar in all NHS hospitals.
Yes, sugar does kill you, just not in the way you think it doesn’t.
(All evolutionary sources of sugar - eg fruit and honey - are fine)
#OralMicrobiome#OralDysbiosis#GumDisease
@ProfBillMcGuire The geological perspective is fascinating here. California's burned hillsides may take years to recover, yet another disturbance could arrive within months. How do we prepare for cascading hazards when the interval between events becomes shorter than the time needed for recovery?
@ElaineCox11 That's interesting, so perhaps there are several transitions rather than one: experiencing change, recognising it, attributing meaning to it, and then acting on it. Each may occur at a different pace. It makes me wonder what determines when one becomes the next.
*Is coffee healthy?*
I thought this was a simple question.
Several cups of coffee, an apple, a sofa, a toothbrush and a volcano later, I'm less certain. 😄
Tell me something you are absolutely confident is healthy.
Then try to break your answer.
Link here: https://t.co/qWeNWOeoLx
Why can you buy a health product in one country but struggle to obtain the same product in another?
Same product. Same evidence. Different system.
I decided to find out why.
Evidence in Transit:
https://t.co/PMZwtKtnWR
@DrGrahamLJ Interesting. It makes me wonder how much the categories we use determine what we subsequently look for. “Non-communicable” makes one distinction visible, while “microbiome-related” would make another. When does a useful classification begin to constrain what we're able to see?
@gowildannette Perhaps what's most striking is that these aren't seven independent problems. They interact. What happens when crossing one boundary changes the conditions that help keep others stable?
@TheFlowerShow Beautiful, and fascinating. The same El Niño can produce outcomes experienced as extraordinary in one place and devastating in another. When we describe a disturbance as beneficial or harmful, how much depends on where, when and what we choose to observe?
@gowildannette This is wonderful to see. Perhaps the most interesting outcome won't simply be what students learn about nature, but what they become capable of noticing after spending time learning to observe it.
@ProfBillMcGuire The UK may seem a long way from the greatest impacts of El Niño. But how far away does a disturbance have to be before we stop regarding ourselves as part of the system it affects?
@domdyer70 Fascinating. The trees haven't changed, but the category through which the system sees them has; from something to be managed towards something with rights. What changes when an institution learns to see the same thing differently?
@thetimes The headline made me wonder: do oncologists follow their own lifestyle advice and if they do, how would we know whether that knowledge changed their outcomes? Found this: https://t.co/K0WrWrCYZU
The mouth sits within the body @AAOSHconnect
The body sits within a person's life.
That life sits within an environment.
If we change the boundary around the system we're observing, does what appears to be causing the outcome change too?
@ElaineCox11 “Growth” is such an interesting word. Growth of what, measured where, over what timescale, and what has to decline elsewhere for that growth to occur?
@DrGrahamLJ Interesting, Graham. The relationship seems highly conditional: oral pathobionts encounter a different environment in the inflamed gut. How much of what we call pathogenicity belongs to the organism, and how much to the conditions in which we encounter it?