On pay: it's scored as top-of-grid divided by provincial average earnings, precisely to net out cost of living and local incomes. Nova Scotia and PEI score above BC on that ratio. It's one of five components; drop it entirely and the top three are the same.
On the other axis: I have that chart too. Same y-axis as the WSJ one, ExcelinEd's 18 literacy-policy principles scored province by province from legislation and policy documents. Same result: U.S. pattern doesn't hold.
Every input, weight and source is written down, and where your points landed I've said so and re-run it. If you'd score it differently, build it; I'd read it with interest.
The one province that looks like your case is Manitoba: no strike right, binding arbitration as the backstop, and a 2024 deal that puts its teachers among the best paid in the country. The index gives it full marks on pay for exactly that reason. It scores zero on strikes and zero on legal regime because it can't strike and its wages were held under the 2017 restraint law until that was repealed. Net, it lands near the bottom: well paid, no strike leverage. Those are different things, and the index is built to keep them apart.
It's there because the credible threat is the leverage, and the only way to observe a threat is when it gets used. The "wins without a fight" case is covered by the other components: pay premium and legal regime both score a union that gets its terms without striking.
It's also testable. If unions were winning / had power they could exercise by not striking, the quiet provinces would be the well-paid ones. They're the opposite. The three provinces with no strikes in the window, NB, NL and PEI, have three of the four lowest top-of-grid salaries in the country. Manitoba, where teachers can't legally strike, had a wage freeze legislated in 2017. Quebec's 22-day strike in 2023 won 17% over five years. In Canada, striking is (often) how teachers enact leverage.
On ministers: yes, and that's the finding. Union strength doesn't predict which provinces acted. Cardy in NB, Ontario after the OHRC inquiry, Alberta, Saskatchewan after its commission did. "Unions are influential everywhere" and "union strength doesn't explain who reformed" are the same sentence.
On SES and independent schools: also maybe yes, and I some numbers there too. Demographics do a lot of work separating the Atlantic provinces from the rest, and with ten provinces sometimes tough to say which demographic it is; income, immigration, rurality and private-school share all sort the same way. But they don't order provinces within the two groups. Quebec is 5th on immigrant share and 2nd on score; Manitoba is 4th and 9th. P.E.I. leads the Atlantic four by nine points with a provincial assessment since 2007 and a coaching model. Inside each group the ordering seems to follow explicit instruction and external testing, not composition.
My graphic. Is that including private-school teachers? Public-school teachers are members by law everywhere (Rand formula in Quebec), and the gap you describe matches independent-school enrolment: BC 13%, QC 12%, AB 8%, Atlantic 1β4%. If so, my original ranking focused on leverage over policy not outside it. But I like adding it. good idea. Did a re-run. Sask and Ontario swap at 6 and 7. Otherwise all the same.
@rastokke Excellent piece. Gimli shows the problem isnβt Canadian children; itβs the choices weβre making. England showed under Sir Nick Gibb that coherent, evidence-led reform can lift results nationally. What would it take to bring the best learning outcomes to every classroom?
I think we disagree on the premise. I donβt think public figures owe us a rememption arc. We (I) want competence. Mulaney didnβt do anything save for his job. Iβd hope Tory woulda done the same. Maybe the conditions in Canada make this harder ? Meanwhile, if you want to argue Mulaney had better PRβ¦agreed.
@anotherglassbox Fair point on engagement being low. On the fix, I don't think penance from ex-mayors moves the needle. What moves it is an inspiring candidate worth voting for. Isn't that the actual problem, not insufficient public redemption arcs?
@anotherglassbox TOs structural deficit is 20yrs old / belongs partially to ON / not any one mayor...Tory wasn't perfect fiscally (Chow is worse?) - both have been painfully slow on efficiency + tech. Alternative timeline he is probably winning another term?
@anotherglassbox Not endorsing what he did β but I dont think he ran in shame...saw what was coming and stepped down before it hurt the people around him more. Also not sure John as +20yr public servant owes us pennance?