Almost 100% find out the hard way ๐
The end-of-month carrier invoice is where e-commerce margins go to die. Nobody thinks about PO Boxes on day oneโuntil FedEx slaps them with an address correction fee and an angry customer email asking why their package is stuck.
Thatโs actually the whole reason we built the template library: to act like an immune system for the store.
When a merchant installs Velo, they scan the presets and realize: "Wait, carriers bounce express on PO Boxes? Let me toggle that on right now."
Turns expensive rookie mistakes into a 10-second prevention step! ๐
Building in public โ Day 6 ๐ก๏ธ
Your biggest COD return risk isn't high-value orders.
It's first-time buyers.
New customers have zero skin in the game. No purchase history, no loyalty, no accountability. They order on impulse and refuse delivery when buyer's remorse kicks in.
Experienced merchants know the trick: only offer COD to returning customers who have actually completed a previous order.
Inside Velo Checkout Rules:
๐ If customer does NOT have tag "returning" โ Hide Cash on Delivery.
New buyers checkout with Card/PayPal (money secured upfront).
Returning buyers still enjoy their trusted COD option.
Simple rule. Massive fraud reduction.
Before & after below ๐
Do you currently filter COD access by customer history, or is it wide open for everyone?
#BuildInPublic #Shopify #EcommerceContent #CODFraud
Day 7/180 โ Week 1 is done ๐
7 days ago I started this challenge with:
Velo Toolkit: 0 installs
Velo Checkout Rules: 0 installs
Today:
Velo Toolkit: 7 installs
Velo Checkout Rules: 3 installs
Biggest struggle:
Getting from "cool post" to "actual install" is a completely different game.
173 days left.
Week 2 goal: land my first beta merchant for Checkout Rules.
Builders โ what did your Week 1 look like?
#BuildInPublic #Shopify #indiehackers #Ecommerce
By far, the #1 combo is what merchants call the "Trust Threshold":
๐ Customer Tag โ "returning" AND Cart Total > $100 โ Hide COD.
It balances conversion with risk: you let a new buyer place a $25 COD order to test trust with your brand. But the moment an unverified stranger tries to order $150+, the gate shuts and card payment is required.
The second most popular is Geography + Carrier:
๐ Address contains "PO Box" (or remote postal code) โ Hide Express.
Carriers either reject PO Box express outright or slap on brutal $20+ out-of-area surcharges that completely wipe out store margins.
We actually baked both of these into 1-click templates inside Velo so merchants don't even have to configure the logic manually.
Curious, does Connectr touch e-commerce checkout flows directly, or are you focused on other parts of the funnel?
The "Smith Incentive" is officially locked into our template library! ๐ซก
You're 100% right about that crossed-out price visualโit kills all last-second hesitation before they hit Pay now.
Co-building this in public with your feedback has easily been the highlight of my first week. I'll record a clean walkthrough of the full flow and drop it straight in your DMs as soon as it's live!
Can't thank you enough for all the insights, Raymond! ๐
Building in public โ Day 2 ๐ ๏ธ
Yesterday, @rsmithrs9 gave me a piece of gold advice:
"Lead with the merchant problem, not the app name. Show before and after."
So here is one of the biggest headaches Shopify merchants face:
High-value COD fraud & returns.
Letting customers order a $500+ item with Cash on Delivery is risky. One return means eating shipping both ways + tied-up inventory.
So inside Velo Checkout Rules, I built a 30-second fix:
๐ Hide COD automatically if cart total > $200.
Hereโs the before & after in action ๐
Still on the hunt for my first 5 beta merchants to test this out. If you run a Shopify store, would you use this rule?
#BuildInPublic #Shopify #ShopifyDev #dropshipping
Not at allโmerchants can actually stack multiple signals together using AND/OR logic!
Beyond customer tags, Velo evaluates:
โข Cart value / quantity: (e.g. allow COD for a $25 test order, but hide it if a new buyer tries to order $150+)
โข Geography: Country, province/state, city, or address keywords (like PO Boxes)
โข Product attributes: Product tags or types (e.g. custom-made or high-theft items)
We keep the rule engine deterministic & native via Shopify Functions (zero latency), but if a store uses an external tool that flags users with risk tags, Velo acts as the instant checkout gatekeeper.
What signals do you usually find most reliable for spotting checkout risk? ๐ค
As a dev building the tooling for merchants, I don't run a single DTC store myself, but looking at merchant data & benchmarks in COD-heavy markets (like India & MENA):
First-time buyers make up a massive 65%โ80% of total COD orders (mostly because brand trust isn't there yet to pay upfront).
The brutal paradox? They also drive over 80% of the RTO (Return to Origin) losses.
Itโs the ultimate merchant dilemma: turning it off protects your shipping margins, but can hurt top-of-funnel acquisition.
Curious, what kind of split are you seeing across the stores you work with at MagnetX?
Closing the reward loopโsuch an essential UX detail!
Thereโs nothing worse than tapping an incentive and having that split-second panic wondering if it actually applied.
The great thing about running natively on Shopify Functions is that the Order Summary updates instantly: the shipping line reflects "FREE" (with the original price crossed out). Instant reassurance before they hit "Pay now".
Honestly Raymond, you've basically co-architected this entire flow with me over this thread haha. Might have to name this template the "Smith Incentive" inside the app! ๐
Canโt thank you enough for all the guidance! ๐
Thanks so much, Jean! That means a ton
The best part about running this on Shopify Functions is that it validates server-side right at checkout. Scalpers and bots canโt just disable frontend JavaScript or inject scripts to bypass it. Plus zero site slowdown during massive traffic spikes!
Day 5 down, 175 to go on this 180-day challenge. Feedback like this keeps the fire lit! Really appreciate the encouragement, man ๐
Building in public โ Day 5 ๐
Running a flash sale or limited inventory drop on Shopify?
Bots and scalpers buying 20+ items in a single order will ruin your launch.
Real fans get left with empty hands, while resellers flip your inventory on eBay for 2x the price.
Instead of paying for expensive anti-bot apps, you can set a native rule in Velo Checkout Rules:
๐ If Item Quantity > 3 โ Block checkout with a custom message ("Max 3 items per customer").
Lightweight. Instant. Runs natively on Shopify Functions without slowing down your checkout.
Check out the before & after below ๐
Have you ever had to deal with inventory hoarders on your store?
#BuildInPublic #Shopify #EcommerceContent #ShopifyTips
Whiskey! Such an awesome niche, but spirits shipping logistics are on hard mode
Makes total sense why they miss it at checkoutโwhen someoneโs hyped about grabbing a good bottle, they're on pure dopamine mode and blast straight past the text to the payment button. That second note in the confirmation is brilliant to stop angry support tickets in their tracks.
Did you guys ever test making it a mandatory checkbox at checkout ("I confirm someone 21+ with ID will be home to sign") before they can pay, or were you worried it would add too much friction?
Building in public โ Day 3 ๐ฆ
One of the most annoying checkout issues for Shopify stores using FedEx or UPS:
Customers selecting Express Shipping to a PO Box.
Carriers reject these shipments immediately.
Result?
โข Delayed fulfillment
โข Unhappy customers emailing support
โข Merchants eating cancellation & processing fees
Inside Velo Checkout Rules, here is the 30-second fix:
๐ If Shipping Address contains "PO Box" โ Automatically hide Express Shipping (only allow Postal Mail).
Hereโs the before & after in action ๐
Still looking for beta stores to test our delivery rules. If you run into PO Box shipping issues, drop a comment or DM!
#BuildInPublic #Shopify #store #Ecommerce
Eagle eye, Raymond! 75%+ of checkouts are on mobile, so this is such a critical catch.
Just tested it: Shopifyโs mobile checkout doesnโt truncate with "...", but because the Visa/Mastercard logos take up space on the right, 47 characters forces an awkward 2-line wrap on standard mobile screens.
To keep it clean on a single line, a punchier version works so much better:
"Card (Free Priority Shipping)"
"Pay by Card โ Free Fast Ship"
I'm setting the template default to the tighter 1-line copy so it looks flawless on mobile out of the box, while still letting merchants tweak it.
Seriously, you're saving me from shipping rookie UX mistakes!
100% spot on. Loss aversion is so realโnothing kills checkout momentum faster than thinking you unlocked a perk, only to have it pulled away after entering a promo code.
Thatโs why keeping the progress bar and the shipping rule 100% in sync is non-negotiable. The Checkout UI extension listens to the reactive net cart total in real-time, so thereโs never an awkward mismatch between the banner and the actual shipping rates.
Even better from a CRO angle: when a coupon drops them below $200, we can use our 1-click upsell block to say:
"Add this $15 item to re-unlock Free Express!"
Turns a potential bounce into an instant AOV win. Appreciate you highlighting this edge case! ๐
Building in public โ Day 4 ๐
Want to dramatically increase your store's AOV?
Reward high-ticket shoppers with Free Express Shipping.
Here is a common checkout friction on Shopify:
A customer builds a huge cart ($200+), but at checkout, they're still asked to pay $15 for Express delivery. Big spenders expect VIP treatment, not an extra shipping fee at the finish line.
Inside Velo Checkout Rules, here is the setup:
๐ Condition: Cart Total > $200
๐ Action: 100% off Express Shipping (Express becomes FREE)
Bonus for Shopify Plus stores:
You can drag & drop our native Checkout Progress Bar right into the Checkout Editor. Shoppers see live progress, and when they hit the goal:
"๐ You have unlocked Free Shipping!"
Before: Express is $15.
After: Express is discounted to FREE.
Check out the breakdown in the image below ๐
Shopify merchants: do you offer upgraded/free express shipping to incentivize larger basket sizes?
#BuildInPublic #Shopify #ShopifyPlus #Ecommerce
This comment from @arnavsawantt blew my mind ๐คฏ
I thought PO Boxes were the most annoying shipping issue, but the 21+ adult signature trap is on a whole different level:
1. Customer orders an age-restricted item (wine, vape, supplements, high-ticket gear).
2. Carrier requires an adult (21+) signature.
3. Carrier attempts delivery at 2 PM while everyone is at work.
4. 3 failed delivery attempts later โ package bounced back, merchant eats the return fees, customer is furious.
A simple checkout warning isnโt enough because shoppers scroll right past disclaimers.
Merchants selling age-restricted products: how do you prevent failed deliveries from adult signatures?
Do you force a checkbox at checkout, or call them beforehand?
#BuildInPublic #Shopify #Ecommerce #shipping
@tionguyen_dev po box plus express is a dumb way to lose a day lol. ours is the adult signature. order looks fine until the carrier needs a 21 plus signature at a door nobody answers
Thanks so much!
As a solo dev who loves coding but finds distribution to be the hardest challenge, that definitely hits home ๐
Curious, do you have salespeople in your network who specifically specialize in the Shopify / e-commerce ecosystem? Would definitely be interested in taking a lookโfeel free to shoot me a DM with the link! ๐ค
Itโs checked AFTER the discount (post-discount net total)!
Our rule reads Shopify's native `cart.cost.totalAmount`. So if a customer has a $220 cart but applies a $30 coupon (dropping it to $190), the rule won't trigger.
We defaulted to this specifically for margin protectionโpreventing customers from stacking a heavy promo code while still grabbing an expensive Free Express delivery perk.
From a CRO perspective, do you usually prefer keeping it post-discount to protect margins, or checking pre-discount subtotal so buyers don't feel "penalized" for using a coupon?
Huge congrats on hitting $3k MRR with that playbook, Chris! Thatโs massive.
Targeting high-intent merchants actively searching for solutions on Reddit is so much smarter than just shouting into the void.
Curious, how did you navigate Reddit's strict anti-self-promo mods? Did you usually just explain the solution in the comments and drop the app link, or offer to help in DMs?
Really appreciate the golden advice! ๐
Day 2/180 of building Shopify apps in public ๐ ๏ธ
Current scoreboard:
Velo Toolkit: 3 installs ๐
Velo Checkout Rules: 0 installs
178 days left to find my first batch of merchants.
Shopify owners: whatโs your biggest shipping headache right now? Accidental express to Post Office Box, or customers picking the wrong shipping rate?
#Shopify #indiehackers #Ecommerce #Tips
Yes, absolutely! We go way beyond just delivery methods.
Velo Checkout Rules is built to handle rules across the entire checkout flow:
โข Delivery: Hide, rename, or reorder shipping rates based on cart value, address, or product tags (e.g. hiding express for fragile items).
โข Payment: Conditional payment gateways (like hiding COD on high-ticket orders, or restricting Klarna to specific countries).
โข Validation (Hard blocks): Blocking checkout with custom error banners (e.g. max quantity limits to stop bots/scalpers, or B2B company checks).
โข Shipping Discounts: Dynamic discounts for VIP tags or local regions.
Curious, are there specific shipping restrictions you see stores struggle with the most? Always looking to expand our templates! ๐ค
"5% reads like math, free shipping feels like a perk" โ that is an absolute gem of a quote, writing that down!
The beauty is that Velo Checkout Rules already supports payment method renaming natively via Shopify Functions.
So a merchant can literally set this up in 2 clicks:
1. Hide COD for orders over $300
2. Rename Credit Card โ "Credit Card (Includes Free Priority Shipping)"
Placing the reward right where the thumb taps is genius. I'm turning this into a pre-built template in the app today.
Can't thank you enough for shaping this product with me, Raymond! ๐