Jensen is a visionary. He's right about selling into China. Restricting Western nations from selling to China is the dumbest policy ever. Why? Because they did it themselves. They have the whole supply chain for industrial CNC machines. Top to bottom. They don't need us. Why? Because we weren't allowed to sell to them. I remember sitting in large meetings in DC, arguing with them about the OODA loop of engineering. Whoever has the most cycles wins. If you restrict our market, we get fewer cycles. China has no restrictions; they get more cycles, and they've taken the industry almost completely over.
Don't even get me started on Boeingโthe poorest-run company ever since 2000.
If you think China needs our manufacturing prowess, you don't understand the situation.
I spent 30 years designing and building some of the most sophisticated CNC manufacturing systems in the world. These were $5 million to $25 million machines, operating at the very highest end of industrial manufacturing.
I've watched China go from producing junk in the 1990s to producing some of the most impressive manufacturing equipment on the planet. The transformation is absolutely astonishing, and I don't think most Americans have a clue how far they've come. And our government is filled with stupid people who don't understand it either.
In the 1990s, we bought our critical machine components almost exclusively from American, Japanese, and European manufacturers. THK, NSK, SKF, INA, FAG, Bosch Rexroth, Siemens, Allen-Bradley, and dozens of others. FANUC was the king of CNC controls and servo systems, and in my opinion, still is.
I own an older Chinese CNC router, and it's full of those familiar Western and Japanese components. China could build the machine, but much of the critical technology came from somewhere else.
Not anymore.
Today, you can buy virtually everything needed to build a sophisticated CNC machine directly from Chinese manufacturers. Precision bearings, linear guides, ball screws, rack-and-pinion drives, servo motors, spindles, controllers, sensors, electronics. You name it. The prices are ridiculously low, and the quality is often so good that I can hardly distinguish it from the premium components we used to buy.
And then there's Bambu Lab. I recently bought one of their sophisticated 3D printers, and I'm blown away. The engineering, the integration, the manufacturing quality, the price. It's an extraordinary machine. This isn't China copying Western technology. This is China doing some remarkable engineering of its own.
Now here's the part that really pisses me off.
Years ago, our government decided that our advanced automated fiber placement (AFP) equipment was too sophisticated to sell into China. I spent FOUR YEARS fighting those export restrictions before finally giving up.
We had developed some of the most advanced manufacturing equipment in the world, and our own government wouldn't let us sell it to one of the largest markets on Earth.
Brilliant.
So what did China do? Exactly what any capable, ambitious country would do. They developed their own technology, built their own manufacturing capabilities, and created their own supply chains.
We didn't stop them. We gave them another reason to become independent of us.
And now the flywheel effect is incredible.
Better components make better machines. Better machines make better components. Higher volumes drive down costs. Lower costs open new markets. Those markets fund more engineering, more factories, more innovation. And the whole thing accelerates.
China isn't just assembling machines anymore. They've developed an enormous, deeply integrated manufacturing ecosystem that can produce virtually everything needed to build them. And the speed at which they can develop, manufacture, and improve products is breathtaking.
Meanwhile, our government keeps imagining it can protect American industry by restricting trade and deciding who we're allowed to sell to. Not having access to the Chinese market hurt us badly. It takes product cycles to improve and grow. Whereas Chana sells everywhere and we sell only in NATO, China gets way more reps than we do and it fucking shows.
It's insane.
You don't make American manufacturers stronger by denying them customers. You don't preserve technological leadership by isolating your engineers and businesses from the world's largest markets. And you certainly don't stop innovation by giving your competitors every incentive to do it themselves.
I look at my older Chinese CNC router, then at my new Bambu printer, and I can see 30 years of industrial transformation sitting right in front of me.
We used to worry about China copying our technology.
Pretty soon, we'll be the ones doing Chinese BluePrinting. I've already learned some cool things from them by looking at their machines. They are smart, proud and sophisticated. I can see it because I lived it. My teams were much the same way. Our products similar.
Out government is full of hubris. Yet, they are mostly dipshits.
@OwenBenjamin What would have been funny about the alternate ending is how many people would have reposted it without knowing the last phrase. I mean, who watches a video to the end?
Chickens, garden, water, solar, generator, and fresh air a long way from those perps.
But what to do? IDK. I listen to Brett and Heather and love them. I have no talent for SM and talking. I'm a doer of physical things. So I build out resiliency in a very small community. Not what I had ever planned to do, but what is necessary.
@johnrich@TenGallonTroub Standing under a cedar tree in his back yard and sending the yodels. Buddy Mac makes me happy when his stuff crosses my screen.
@DocteurPEB1 IT's ok. I barely do anything on SM. I check X in the morning to see how bad the world is behaving, and then I see this nice video. Made me think of my 4 labs and that I have a new one coming soon. I've seen my labs do intelligent and kind things just like this.
@DocteurPEB1 I've had 4 labs. 2 of the 4 were almost like children to me; they were definitely important and impactful family members. But unlike children, they were with me every minute through every activity. It leaves a BIG hole when they go. I need another soon.
Reminds me of visiting my grandma. They had a small TV screen (by today's standards) in a giant wood cabinet. She and Grandpa always watched the Lawrence Welk show. And she'd always say..."Isn't that beautiful?" I wish I could tell her, "Yes, Grandma, it is beautiful. Back then, I didn't know. I just liked her homemade pizza and being at Grandma's house. She and Grandpa were of the greatest generation. They lived through the Great Depression and WWI and WWII. She said that when they were kids, they were dirt poor, but didn't know it.