@ArhamSidh@Astryx_en I know the regions of India brother. I know UP and Bihar people when I meet them. I’m not doubting that they have good Urdu. The whole discussion was about one guys Indian guys accent which sounds Pakistani because of PTV influence.
@ArhamSidh@Astryx_en Unless an Indian grew up watching PTV, all their accents suck. I have lived in UAE all my life and not one accent from Indians was worthwhile. Punjabis, Sindhis and Pashto speakers speak Urdu as their second language. What’s your excuse?
میں نے سنا یہاں کسی نے کہا کہ کلٹ آ گیا ہے کلٹ پورے ملک میں نہیں پھیلے ہوتے کلٹ کسی رائیونڈ میں خیمہ لگا کر بیٹھے ہوتے ہیں کوئی گڑھی خدا بخش میں قبروں پہ بیٹھے ہوتے ہیں آپ اپنے گھروں میں جا کر دیکھیں وہاں سارے کلٹ گھسے ہوئے ہیں ، کسی نے لقمہ دیا ساری بیویاں ، دن کو جس کلٹ کو برا بھلا کہتے ہو رات کو اسی کلٹ کے ساتھ سوتے ہو ( اپنے بچوں کے ساتھ ) ! مطیع اللہ جان ۔۔
@urdu_kangz Dr Saab lived and died in Lahore. His team was full of Punjabis including Dr Abdus Sami who is the head of their Quran Academy to this day. Please know what you’re talking about. And you’re bringing in nationalism while claiming a guy who fought nationalism his whole life
@abdurrxhmaan@Confetti87@RelativelyMS@FibroFogFig@firaqist The whole discussion started because someone said Sharjeel sounds like an average guy from Karachi which he does. His Urdu is not like regular accent from Awadh region of today, instead he sounds like a guy from Karachi and I think I finally understand why.
@abdurrxhmaan@Confetti87@RelativelyMS@FibroFogFig@firaqist Studying Urdu won’t change someone’s accent. Do you sound British when speaking English? It’s our national language, not the mother tongue for the majority. Even Urdu Speakers in Karachi have a dozen accents.