If you're wondering why $STX and $WDC trade at 30 P/E while $MU and $SNDK at 5 P/E, here's why:
HDD has always been a data center product while DRAM and NAND have historically been used in consumer electronics.
Data centers have mostly been on an uptrend the past two decades, while computers and smartphones have had a boom and bust cycle. On top of that, older DRAM and NAND were fungible with a lot of suppliers, while HDD was made by just these two companies. Even $WDC felt the weight of SSD cyclicality and spun out SanDisk in 2025 to get a more structural valuation.
But the demand environment has now changed. Latest DRAM and NAND are data center products and account for majority of $MU and $SNDK revenues. Their complex manufacturing is now concentrated into just 5 companies. Their barrier to entry is high as well because of 20B+ startup costs, yield uncertainty and patent walls.
So DDR5 and NAND are no longer cyclical in the traditional sense, the same as HDD, and should be given a higher multiple. My bet since last year has been a re-rate of $MU to a 15-20x PE which would more than 3x the stock price.
@OptionsMir And โon the groundโ I donโt feel the same stock market enthusiasm as 1999/2000 with everyone talking stocks. Last night I attended an NCAA neighborhood party, not one mention of stocks. Wtf. ๐คทโโ๏ธ