Pre-order my book! "A myth-busting glimpse into the inner workings of the Supreme Court." Fun for lawyers and non-lawyers alike, including John Jay's head injury, why the end of the filibuster is bad for the judiciary, and who is watching Slow Horses. https://t.co/b3wqEHJvZ5
There's a stuckness to a lot of these debates. The surge pricing is to get more drivers on the road. I'm not defending the specific way Uber does it but as with the expensive-groceries-in-NYC debate there's an assumption that greed and only greed explains the pricing.
@whignewtons@whignewtons I liked your closing point on @ThisWeekABC this morning. #Democrats won the House and Senate. Let’s use that power to pass bills that address what families deal with every day. Put those bills on the president’s desk. If he wants to veto them, let him.
Poor Bo French tried to do some light blood and soil to make himself feel better after losing his election…only to get owned by a notary public and youth coaching legend. Now the entire country knows he financed his waterbed and didn’t letter in 💩.
@dilanesper You might be right. But that would also have to be true for cabinet spots etc right? Meaning you’re required to have a vacancy—potentially for a long time—while the confirmation process winds its way?
Sarah's discussion of this on Advisory Opinions reminded me of something I wanted to talk about.
"Resignation upon confirmation of a successor" is a violation of the Constitution, perpetrated by both the executive branch and SCOTUS.
BREAKING: #SCOTUS, 8-1, green lights Trump admin's border wall construction in Big Bend preserve in Texas, lifts district judge's order blocking project. Justice Jackson dissents. Doc: https://t.co/haqFDKHvRi
@joshtpm Nothing gave the VP power to reject election results in a constitution of limited powers. Here, POTUS has power to nominate for an office and senate has power to A&C. The office can’t be held by two people at once (hence the KBJ commission problem). That’s the only limit.
@Atomic_Walrus Except he didn’t. He submitted a letter with his *intent* to resign after the court finished handing down merits decisions and if a successor had been confirmed. No date and two contingencies. Would it matter if Alito said he intended to resign sometime in the next 2 years? Why?
Alito won't retire in the lame duck and he doesn't need to. Trump can nominate someone to the Supreme Court and the senate can confirm without a vacancy. Then Trump can wait to sign the commission any time in the next two years. The question isn't Alito, its Cornyn/Tillis/Thune.
Speaking of historical precedents for dealing w judicial vacancies: Trump could also do a recess appointment to fill a vacated SCOTUS seat à la Bush in 2004.
https://t.co/dOWuAU56QM
Once again, I am *describing* an option that is contemplated by the constitution. Do I think this is a good idea? No. Would it be bad for the court as an institution? Yes. Would it be totally lawful? Also yes…
@baseballcrank KBJ's commission was signed months before Breyer left. Under Marbury, it would have been effective even if Biden had left office before Breyer left.
@joshtpm They signed the commission for a justice without a vacancy (which under marbury would mean it would have been effective even if Biden had been replaced). There's no legal significance with an "intent to resign."
@BenjySarlin Not this time around. But with confirmation wars landing where no potus gets any noms without an aligned senate, this is where we're headed.
@mehdirhasan Here's the Biden OLC opinion. They nominated, confirmed, and in fact signed KBJ's commission before there was a vacancy. Agree the politics are way different for this--but not the law! https://t.co/uOd88tKesk