Why Is Bitcoin Crashing?
Timestamps:
0:00 Down 50% from its all time high
0:53 Anthropic's IPO
3:11 The VIX doubled in six weeks
4:17 The dollar and a hiking Fed
5:42 ETF outflows and forced sellers
7:02 Up 7.9x in three years
8:17 Volatility is the price of monetization
9:48 The shallowest bear market yet
10:46 The thesis has not changed
Welcome Back To The Hurdle Rate
Episode 82: Is Anthropic Draining Bitcoin?
In this week’s Hurdle Rate, the crew breaks down how the Anthropic IPO is pulling risk capital from $BTC, what the SpaceX IPO says about a reversal, and why capital markets are wide open. They also discuss how Digital Credit like $SATA held up against junk bonds, why $ASST dropped mNAV, and why Strive kept selling $SATS as Bitcoin fell.
Here’s the latest with @ColeMacro, @PunterJeff, @AdamBLiv, and @TimKotzman.
Timestamps:
00:00 - Intro
01:46 - Bitcoin Meets The Anthropic IPO
06:13 - Where IPO Money Comes From
09:55 - Walmart Vs. Anthropic
11:02 - The Bubble Isn't Popping
17:13 - Digital Credit Vs. Traditional Credit
22:46 - Why We Dropped mNAV
30:49 - The Berkshire Hathaway Parallel
36:58 - The Real Work Behind Digital Credit
49:45 - Buying The Dip With SATS
$98 Million in volume traded across $SATS and $SATA today.
4.7% of the $2.1 Billion notional outstanding.
$JPM.PRD JP Morgan preferred traded $9.1 Million
0.53% of the $1.69 Billion
today, $SATS and $SATA combined provided 8.6x the turnover liqudiity than the JP Morgan pref equity.
If you haven’t figured it out yet, the main driver for $STRC and $SATA to get to par is bitcoins price.
This should be obvious, as the market is constantly repricing the credit and risk profile of the preferreds as the underlying collateral fluctuates.
Yes, raising yields help.
Yes, buybacks help.
But the main driver for price action is bitcoins price.
The best actions a company can take in volatile bitcoin events is sit tight, and let the market figure itself out.
Thankfully, the team at Strive has figured this out and isn’t shoving $SATA buybacks down the common shareholders throat at depressed bitcoin levels (Should be doing the opposite).
Open letter to Saylor and Phong Le.
I've never done this before but as a MSTR shareholder, I think this is too important not to.
Strategy needs to go back to treating STRC as a credit product, not a money product.
Marketing STRC as money or "digital money" was a big mistake. It distorted the expectations of a largely retail audience and made a promise the product couldn't keep. Now there's an obsession with reducing volatility until it trades like cash, and that's leading to mistakes.
Instead, expectations should have been set for it to trade like any other credit product, where annualised volatility is much higher depending on the rating.
If investors had been told to expect the volatility of B-rated or even CCC-rated high-yield bonds, they would be delighted with the results today. They aren't, because they were told it would behave like money.
Now Strategy is fighting market forces that can't be contained. To keep that promise, it keeps diluting common shareholders at low valuations.
Buybacks reward sellers and traders. Raising the yield rewards holders and long-term investors.
Prioritising buyers who want a quasi money market fund is an error. At this stage, the product isn't for them. Strategy can't guarantee that volatility profile and those investors would be better served by cash or a money market fund.
I have no doubt digital credit is the superior product. Over time, volatility should fall and spreads should narrow. For now, volatility is to be expected, especially in a Bitcoin bear market.
Focus on building quality credit and the volatility will sort itself out as STRC works towards an investment grade rating, and eventually, AAA.
Raise the rate and get comfortable with STRC's volatility. Seen through the lens of a new credit product, not a money product, it is doing fantastically well.
If America slows down or stops building data centers, it will eventually be defeated by its adversaries. AI is the most important front in the war for the future. Do not be stupid. Do not cede our advantage to the enemy.