Republicans spent 4 years attacking Hillary Clinton because a special operations compound in Benghazi wasn't fortified enough.
But they're completely silent about Trump leaving a military base 60 miles from Iran unfortified.
An ROTC kid would've known it would be a target.
“@MarshaBlackburn announced Josh Smith, a Knoxville businessman who served five years in federal prison on a drug conspiracy conviction before receiving a presidential pardon from Trump, will serve as the state's next corrections commissioner…”
https://t.co/Rmz8AEUIs0
Trent, let me get this straight.
When the late Senator Lindsey Graham was subpoenaed in a criminal investigation of efforts to overturn Georgia’s 2020 election results, you went to the Supreme Court and argued for broad protections under the Speech or Debate Clause.
But now that Senator Elizabeth Warren is preparing to investigate possible corruption involving Trump’s wealthy donors, you’re suddenly emphasizing how limited those protections are?
That’s quite a change in emphasis there, buddy.
And here’s what makes it even more interesting.
In October 2022, you were counsel of record on an amicus brief supporting Graham. You cited Gravel v. United States (1972) and discussed how the Speech or Debate Clause protects members of Congress from intimidation by executive officials.
You understood the importance of congressional independence when a Republican senator was facing a grand jury subpoena.
So why aren’t you expressing those same concerns now that a Trump-appointed U.S. Attorney is threatening a Democratic senator with potential criminal prosecution over investigations she hasn’t even conducted yet?
And since you brought up the Eleventh Circuit’s ruling in Graham’s case, let’s talk about what it actually says.
Yes, the Speech or Debate Clause has limits. Nobody disputes that. But the court also recognized that legitimate legislative fact-finding is protected, citing Eastland v. United States Servicemen’s Fund (1975).
In Graham’s case, the courts distinguished protected legislative activity from potentially nonlegislative conduct involving Georgia election officials.
Warren, meanwhile, wants to investigate whether wealthy donors received favorable government treatment in exchange for political contributions. That’s a subject that can plainly serve a legitimate legislative purpose.
Her comments on TV aren’t automatically protected legislative acts. Fair enough. But that doesn’t mean her proposed congressional investigations would be unconstitutional, much less criminal.
And even when the Speech or Debate Clause doesn’t apply, that doesn’t automatically mean someone has violated 18 U.S.C. §§ 241 or 242.
You graduated magna cum laude from UNC Law. You know the difference between conduct that falls outside legislative immunity and conduct that actually constitutes a federal crime.
Here’s what I’d really like you to explain.
Why did you argue so forcefully for protecting Lindsey Graham from outside interference in 2022, yet now, when the Trump DOJ is warning Elizabeth Warren about potential criminal liability for anticipated congressional oversight, you’re highlighting the limits of those very protections?
I’m not saying Graham and Warren’s situations are identical. They aren’t. But the underlying constitutional principle shouldn’t depend on which political party the senator belongs to.
If protecting Congress from intimidation was important when Graham was under investigation, it should matter when Warren is preparing to investigate the Trump administration, too.
Congressional independence isn’t a privilege reserved for Republicans.
As secretary, I made sure to leave air travel in better condition than when we arrived. We reversed a decade of decline in air traffic controller staffing, drove down runway safety incidents, and when I left office we were experiencing the lowest flight cancellation rates in years.
As part of that work, I launched a project to transition the FAA's communications system from copper wire to a modern network. I am glad the Trump administration has continued that work, but they have so far failed to explain why their execution of it triggered the worst FAA communications breakdown this century.
I support more funding for FAA upgrades, but this episode is another blow to the public’s confidence that the administration can deliver. The Trump administration owes Americans an honest accounting of how they have spent the billions of dollars already authorized, clearer answers on why their repair work brought down the entire system on Friday, and an explanation of what they are doing to make sure this failure is not repeated.
JD Vance told Congress on Fox tonight to “give us the resources” to fix the FAA and promised “we will absolutely get it.” Before anyone hands over $50 billion of our tax dollars, we should look hard at the two men who would be spending it, because what’s in the records is alarming from a taxpayer's perspective.
Sean Duffy runs the Transportation Department. His old campaign account sent $1.75 million to the super PAC that elected his son-in-law to Congress. Companies doing business with his department gave too. For instance, Boeing’s PAC wrote his son-in-law a check 11 days after Duffy’s FAA gave Boeing back the power to certify its planes. Boeing also gave $1 million to the nonprofit that paid for the Duffy family’s reality show, according to the WSJ. Duffy’s former spokesman sits on that nonprofit’s board and lobbies for Peraton, the company hired to manage the FAA rebuild. Duffy's son-in-law will vote on the $50 billion in January.
Then we have Bryan Bedford who runs the FAA. Before he took the job, Republic Airways, the airline he ran, paid him ~ $21.5 million in cash. His ethics deal required him to sell his Republic stock by October 7, 2025. He sold every other stock on his list on time but he kept most of his Republic shares until his department approved the airline’s merger and the stock started trading publicly. Republic valued the shares at $9.8 million; Senators say his sales may have topped $25 million.
Now he’s the one deciding whether L3Harris pays for the outage, and a real investigation would put his agency on trial too. His FAA handed L3Harris a no-bid deal in April that goes through 2045, rushed the network work after government auditors warned it could disrupt air traffic, and still tracks maintenance on paper.....PAPER.
Now let's look at the money they have already spent. The FAA has paid L3Harris $2.56 billion since January 2025. A router on the same L3Harris network caused a nationwide failure in 2009, and the FAA kept renewing the contract without competition. No penalty for this outage has been announced. Politico also reported FAA officials were frustrated that Peraton, another contractor, had “basically not done any work,” and the FAA kept paying it anyway, including on the day of the outage.
One more finding that is strange, the foreign contracts. About one in three FAA contract dollars since January 2025 went out without a real competition. The radios controllers use to talk to pilots went to a German company and an Austrian company with no bid. The German company’s lobbyist happens to be a former senior Transportation Department aviation official, and her first quarter on the job was the quarter it got its first no-bid contract. That deal grew to $4.9 billion. Coincidence, I'm sure.
So, the people asking for $50 billion more have already been handed billions, and the network still went down. Before Congress writes another check, these contracts need a hard, independent look. If a contractor breaks the system, that contractor should pay for it, not the American taxpayer. Just sayin'.
@Joeoltmann#Republicans have done the exact same thing in prior elections, quit crying. You lost, the party lost because they put faith in a loser instead of actual policy.
@Sandy1Texas Well if the Senators are saying “No” it probably means the nominees are not qualified, or their only “qualification” is blind loyalty to tRump. Is “blind loyalty” to a person really something you want in a judge who is supposed to by unbiased and should consider facts in a case.
Aaron, did you actually write this letter yourself, or did Stephen Miller tell you what to say?
Because I have a hard time believing that someone who graduated from the University of Texas School of Law doesn’t understand the difference between legitimate congressional oversight and political persecution.
In Watkins v. United States (1957), the Supreme Court explicitly recognized Congress’s authority to investigate government corruption. And in Eastland v. United States Servicemen’s Fund (1975), the Court held that congressional investigations conducted within the legitimate legislative sphere are protected by the Speech or Debate Clause, even when improper motives are alleged.
Elizabeth Warren wants to investigate whether wealthy donors received favorable treatment from the Trump administration in exchange for their political contributions. That’s a perfectly legitimate subject for congressional oversight.
Nobody is suggesting that supporting Donald Trump is a crime. But supporting Trump doesn’t give someone immunity from scrutiny if there’s reason to suspect corruption, either.
And I’m genuinely curious how you arrived at the conclusion that investigating possible pay-to-play arrangements could constitute a criminal violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 241 or 242.
You’re a federal prosecutor. You know what the elements of those offenses are. Where’s the evidence that Warren has engaged in a conspiracy to deprive anyone of their constitutional rights or willfully violated anyone’s rights under color of law?
Or are you just throwing around criminal statutes in the hope that she’ll back off?
Which brings me back to my original question: Did you come up with this argument yourself, or did someone at the White House or DOJ headquarters put you up to it?
Because if the goal was to intimidate an incoming Senate committee chair into abandoning legitimate oversight of the Trump administration, that raises some rather serious questions of its own.
@trigeki@Joeoltmann The library isn’t a government building. They have oversight of the records made available in the library through NARA.
See the difference!