It’s likely not always the case. It’s similar to how physical pain is a signal of physical distress / dysfunction in the body. In some chronic pain conditions, the issue is that the pain mechanism itself has become faulty.
Think about a fire alarm. It can go off because there’s a fire but there are also patterns that may indicate a problem with the alarm itself rather than a fire.
@JDaviesPhD I suspect you do this in good faith. I’m afraid though that good faith cannot replace your general and obviously blissful ignorance of medical practice as whole.
@kilnerevonnet Perhaps you can tell me what biomarkers or imaging tests you diagnose a concussion with? Oh, I know what that means - concussions are simply understandable reactions to head impact in sports, right? Nothing else to see there 😁
@JDaviesPhD Fair enough. We can just rail endlessly about the strawman that nobody acknowledges sports participation essentially risks sports injuries…
@VeysiCe Yes. The Clancy case requires a concept of psychosis that can be missed 44 times by 12 providers and last about 18 minutes, yet be so severe as to impair understanding of wrongfulness and self-control.
Medicine catalogs states of distress that straddle the biological & social, from symptomless biological findings e.g., early cancer to symptom-pattern diagnoses e.g., ADHD, migraine, CRPS. ADHD isn’t simply a social construct, it’s diagnosed the way migraines are: by pattern.
The term “treat” in many cases is an imprecise term clinically and many doctors who care about clarity of language pick their words carefully under different circumstances. Opioids are given for fractures, benzodiazepines to abort seizures and antipsychotic to alleviate nausea and vomiting in end of life care. These are recognised patterns of suffering/ distress for which some substances are known to produce varying degrees of alleviation. Are these treating any underlying condition? What does it matter if they alleviate suffering / distress/ disability?
@AuroraLevinson@JDaviesPhD Medicine has never been simply about bio markers. It is also about recognisable patterns. Perhaps you would like to tell me the biological markers for migraines…
Cardiologists and cardiac surgeons share the same organ and the same ICD-11 category.
Our new editorial @thelancet.com explores what would happen if neurologists and psychiatrists had a joint classification in ICD as well. 1/
https://t.co/WW1LC7UJ3w
@psychgeist52 That’s not correct and you may be at risk of confidently but ignorantly peddling misinformation. There are general medical conditions that are diagnosed on the basis of symptom report. And there are good reasons for that.
@stimimi Because antibiotics are overused (as they are in everyday practice), that means they have gone past their use by date? The question of thresholds and over diagnosis is a separate one from the utility of the diagnosis itself.
Illness or disease does not have to be fixed. Diabetes and hypertension are not ‘fixed’. Cancers can go into remission and some fractures heal perfectly without intervention. That would not mean certain cancers or fractures are not diseases or illnesses. We can argue about where the line should be drawn with ADHD (i.e at what level of severity and what degree of impairment should the behaviours be deemed clinically significant), and that’s is reasonable. It is however unreasonable to insist that even at its most extreme presentation, ADHD isn’t an illness.
The problem you’ve described is no different from two GPs or Neurologists disagreeing on the diagnosis of Migrane. You review the evidence from patient’s history and clinical interviews. Disagreement cannot be completely eradicated. The imperfections in the process ≠ overall lack of objectivity. Granted that psychiatric conditions are predominantly this way but it’s not necessarily the picture you are painting. A cognitive test for dementia isn’t entirely dissimilar conceptually from an ASD or ADHD assessment.
@JDaviesPhD The more you speak on this, you more you expose your (mis)understanding of general medicine as a whole. Perhaps time to also listen and try to understand better?
@JDaviesPhD Interesting question. Let’s see how it fits with a general medical condition. If a doctor diagnoses you with hypertension but you disagree, do you have hypertension?