Author,lawyer, board member Israel Council on Foreign Relations,former TD,Justice & Defence Minister & Irish Parl Foreign Affairs Cmtee chair. Chair MDA Ireland
Gotta love this. Especially if in the next few days u end up in a restaurant with a QR code, no printed menu & your food is delivered by a robot! Oops, think Iโm doing that tonight๐ตโ๐ซ
10 Things That Shocked Me About Living in Israel
1. Living for the moment: There is an electricity and passion for life you can almost touch.
2. The people: Israel is a true melting pot. Everyone brings a little love and life from wherever they, or their families, came from.
3. Culture: If variety is the spice of like, you have never tasted a spice like Israel. You have cultures and traditions from all over world.
4. Food: without a doubt the best nation for food. You can just randomly pick a place to eat and you will rarely be disappointed.
5. No rules: life can be chaotic, but this is part of the fun. Rules were made by the British and broken by the Israelis.
6. Economy: the growth of the country in the 18 years I have been here has been astounding. And it still continues to blossom.
7. Prices: Israel is super expensive. But worth every shekel.
8. Community: Israelis can be โrudeโ by European standards, but if you trip and fall in the street a crowd will immediately gather to help you to your feet.
9. Adaptability: most of the Western World thinks in straight lines. Israelis think in squiggles and in the bright spots between black and white.
10. The beach: I came to Israel having spent a week on Miami Beach. The beaches in Tel Aviv are a different level, and without the posing. โค๏ธ
Triple lock? PIRA & Sinn Fein never had a single lock. It was open season & human life mattered so little to them that the location of the remains of four of those PIRA โdisappearedโ remains unrevealed & unknown. Bizarre that anything said by SF on triple lock issue given any credibility by anybody. Total cognitive dissonance.
Simply an astonishing claim by two doctors working in Gaza. Hamasโ systematic use of hospitals is not up for debate.
๐ด Numerous Israeli hostages have testified that they were held hostage in hospitals in Gaza after they were kidnapped from Israel on October 7
๐ด Palestinians have been reporting for months now how theyโve been summoned for interrogations at hospitals, including Nasser Hospital where the latest IDF attacks against a Hamas operative took place.
I myself have spoken to Palestinians in Gaza who told they were summoned for interrogations at hospitals.
๐ด Hamas leader Mohammed Sinwar was killed in an Israeli strike while hiding under the European hospital
๐ด Hamas tunnels have been found under numerous hospitals, including Al Shifa
๐ด EU condemned Hamasโ use of hospitals in November 2023
๐ด Nurses and health care workers who were killed in Israeli strikes were later revealed to have been Hamas and Islamic Jihad combatants
๐ด Doctors Without Borders had to halt all their non critical work at Nasser Hospital earlier this year due to the โpresence of armed men, intimidation, arbitrary arrests of patients, and a recent situation of suspicion of movement of weapons.โ
Two of organizationโs staff members were later revealed to be members of Hamas and Islamic Jihad
๐ด Even Amnesty International published a report in 2015 confirming Hamasโ use of a hospital to interrogate and torture Palestinians
๐ด All of the above is in addition to the countless weapons IDF found inside hospitals during the war.
Here's an excerpt from a book called โUnder the banner of the floodโ written by a Hamas terrorist, Muhammad Zaki Hamad, talking openly about multiple high ranking terrorists fighting IDF inside Al-Shifa Hospital.
Sky News is a farce.
Triple lock? PIRA & Sinn Fein never had a single lock. It was open season & human life mattered so little to them that the location of the remains of four of those PIRA โdisappearedโ remains unrevealed & unknown. Bizarre that anything said by SF on triple lock issue given any credibility by anybody. Total cognitive dissonance.
Sinn Feins military wing never had a 'Triple Lock' unfortunately.
They never asked anyone.
They were judge, jury and executioners.
Today they vote in ๐ท๐บ's interests in the EU.
How democratic is Israel?
Ahmad Tibi was just appointed deputy speaker of Israelโs parliament.
He rejects Israelโs identity as a Jewish state.
He was Yasser Arafatโs political adviser.
He was reprimanded for praising Palestinian โmartyrs.โ
He refuses to call Hamas a terrorist organization.
Yet Israel gives him one of the highest positions in its parliament.
Is this the apartheid they told you about?
Hamas confirmed in a new martyr video that Gaza "journalist" Husam Ammar was a fighter, corroborating IDF claims. Ammar is the 63rd "journalist" confirmed by Hamas & PIJ and the 5th IDF identification from its recent list dismissed as "no evidence" that Hamas has vindicated.
Great 3-0 win for Ireland. 2nd in the group & Stop the Game, IPSC, Kneecap, Lambert, Bohemians, SF, PBP, SD, multiple attention seeking Irish celebs & various sports journos failed in their objective to sabotage Irish football.
There is an entire industry on this & other social media platforms asserting Israel is guilty of โ genocideโ. Thousands of individuals & bots spreading the fake message & using the ICJ to validate it. Well hereโs the President of that court making it clear that in its prlm ruling the court made no such finding nor held the allegation โ plausible โ.
And a reminder, Sth Africa, the state which initiated the court action in December 2023, in May 2026 as the initiating state secured an adjournment of the full court hearing resulting in it being postponed till 2030, proving the allegation is political propaganda. If serious a rapid court hearing wld have been sought not the case put off for 4 years. Israel opposed the adjournment.
And the Irish government, which announced its support for the genocide allegation preceding the 2024 GE as an election scam, continues to make the allegation but did not object to the adjournment nor has publicly referenced it.
A new chapter for Israel as new Knesset speaker elected by Israels anti Netanyahu parties, both Jewish & Arab, uniting & voting together for change.
There is an entire industry on this & other social media platforms asserting Israel is guilty of โ genocideโ. Thousands of individuals & bots spreading the fake message & using the ICJ to validate it. Well hereโs the President of that court making it clear that in its prlm ruling the court made no such finding nor held the allegation โ plausible โ.
And a reminder, Sth Africa, the state which initiated the court action in December 2023, in May 2026 as the initiating state secured an adjournment of the full court hearing resulting in it being postponed till 2030, proving the allegation is political propaganda. If serious a rapid court hearing wld have been sought not the case put off for 4 years. Israel opposed the adjournment.
And the Irish government, which announced its support for the genocide allegation preceding the 2024 GE as an election scam, continues to make the allegation but did not object to the adjournment nor has publicly referenced it.
This is a perfect example of how ignorance among media professionals combines with uncredible (and often unqualified) "expert" commentary to misrepresent international law & distort public perception - often, as here, to artificially turn popular opinion against @Israel.
Let's take a closer look, shall we?
The main point of this "news" report is simple enough. The ๐ฌ๐ง government (@FCDOGovUK), now under successive @UKLabour PMs, claims that licenses for arms exports to @Israel have been significantly curtailed & that no licenses for weapons systems that could be used in Gaza have been granted for quite some time.
Against that claim, reporter Brian O'Flynn has spent months piecing together "evidence" that supposedly casts doubt on whether the gov't is telling the truth. Moreover, there is ample evidence suggesting the UK's contribution to the global F-35 supply & services chain has continued despite other licensing restrictions - and @IAFsite uses these combat aircraft in the #Gaza campaign.
Tbh if the "news" report stopped there, it would be interesting enough. Ah, but as the media is so often inclined to do, @Channel4News insists on generating - fabricating, if necessary - some manner of controversy to make the story seem even MORE compelling.
That primary "controversy" is expressed by @JaninaDill, a source for "expert" commentary - indeed, the ONLY source in the entire story - at about the 2m16s mark:
According to Janina, "There are several treaties in international law that suggest that the UK should not be exporting arms to Israel and should not have been exporting arms to Israel in the year 2024. These include the Genocide Convention, the Geneva Conventions, and the Arms Trade Treaty."
That's the gist of the "controversy" that's supposed to make this scoop seem way more compelling than it actually is:
Successive Labour ๐ฌ๐งgovernments (under @Keir_Starmer & now even still today under @andyburnham) had an obligation to withhold arms exports to ๐ฎ๐ฑ, reporter O'Flynn has discovered the gov't CONTINUES allowing at least SOME exports, and in doing so it is very likely failing to comply with its own obligations AND it has - and continues to - kept this failure from the ๐ฌ๐ง public.
But the articulation of legal obligations & apparent failure to uphold them is where this "news" report comes off the rails, so this is the focus of the current analysis.
We'll get back to Janina's claims as a source of "expert" analysis in a sec (including an explanation of why "expert" warrants quotation marks), but first let's examine the initial major error in legal commentary the JOURNALIST presents (just) before we even hear from Janina.
At about the 2m mark, our "trusted" reporter tells us:
"By January 2024 ... the International Court of Justice [@CIJ_ICJ] issued a landmark ruling on Israel's conduct. It said there was a PLAUSIBLE RISK of genocide in Gaza, and hundreds of UK lawyers, including former Supreme Court justices, said in April that that ruling meant the UK must urgently suspend arms sales to Israel."
Ok, I added the all caps at PLAUSIBLE RISK because this is actually a complete distortion of what the ICJ "ruled" in January 2024.
First of all, this was not a "landmark ruling" at all. In January 2024, the Court indicated a series of provisional measures in the ongoing dispute involving application of the Genocide Convention in the contentious case of ๐ฟ๐ฆ v ๐ฎ๐ฑ. The merits RULING (decision) in that case isn't expected to be published for several years.
In the meantime, the Court has indicated a series of provisional measures. And provisional measures are, by definition, neither "landmark" nor "rulings." They're simply interim measures indicated by the Court during ongoing proceedings to protect the RIGHTS of parties until the actual "ruling" is eventually published.
Furthermore, close scrutiny of the provisional measures the ICJ has indicated thus far in this case reveals the Court has merely reiterated existing obligations that applied to ๐ฎ๐ฑ already by virtue of the Genocide Convention & @UN Security Council resolutions & such. So there's nothing "landmark" about them at all - especially since they're merely provisional (that is, interim) measures to begin with.
Now, you may have noticed that I added all caps to RIGHTS directly above. I emphasized this word because it is key to understanding why the ICJ hasn't "ruled" that there is a PLAUSIBLE RISK of genocide in this case.
If one refers to Article 41 of the ICJ Statute, one will find that this is the component that establishes authority for the Court to indicate provisional measures in the first place. According to this article:
"The Court shall have the power to indicate, if it considers that circumstances so require, any provisional measures which ought to be taken to preserve the respective RIGHTS of either party."
Once again, all caps on RIGHTS. That's because at the provisional measures stage, this is the only issue the Court has to consider - whether RIGHTS of either party may be preserved by indicating provisional measures.
Any guesses what it is NOT authorized to consider - particularly as it relates to a dispute involving the Genocide Convention?
That's right! Whether a "genocide" is even happening at all!
And THAT'S because on the merits - when a determination of whether "genocide" has actually occurred - the central issue will (almost always) be whether the offender carried out enumerated acts with the intent to destroy a national, ethnical, racial, or religious group, in whole or in part, as such - as established in Article II of the Genocide Convention.
At the provisional measures stage, there is NO assessment of the intent of the alleged offender - only the RIGHTS of respective parties. And determining whether RIGHTS of respective parties may be preserved at the provisional measures stage does not require consideration of whether genocidal INTENT exists.
And THAT is why the ICJ has not determined that there is a PLAUSIBLE RISK of genocide. For the "risk" to be "plausible", the Court would need to evaluate the INTENT of the alleged offender - not the RIGHTS of a respective party. In the absence of intent, there is no "plausible risk" of genocide.
But don't JUST take my word for it (even though, I AM right). You can hear a summary of what I just typed straight from Joan Donoghue, who was ICJ president AT THE TIME the initial provisional measures were indicated.
Indeed, the first attachment is a clip of Donoghue being interviewed @BBCHARDtalk that was initially broadcast on April 25, 2024. In this clip, she EXPLICITLY rejects the claim by the host that the ICJ found in provisional measures there is a PLAUSIBLE RISK of genocide.
Now, she doesn't go into as much detail as I do above about the difference between RIGHTS & INTENT - but Donoghue does explain that the Court was focused on "rights" at the provisional measures stage and, therefore, the common popular framing of "plausible genocide" is incorrect.
It was incorrect when this clip aired in April 2024, and it remains incorrect still today. Even so, uninformed (dare I say, incompetent) reporters like Brian O'Flynn continue spreading disinformation by claiming the ICJ has determined there is a "plausible risk" of genocide.
And to the extent that a letter published by a bunch of barristers, which O'Flynn goes on to cite immediately after the "plausible risk" nonsense, advances this claim, they are just as wrong for the same reasons.
Tbh I vaguely remember this letter, but it's not important enough to analyze for present purposes - so I'm not going to bother finding it & addressing it in depth here. The main point for present purposes is that the ICJ has NOT determined there is a "plausible risk" of genocide in ๐ฟ๐ฆ v ๐ฎ๐ฑ at the provisional measures stage, and O'Flynn's claim to the contrary is an indication at the outset that he is completely misinformed when it comes to international law considerations related to the "story" he's covering here.
The rest of the legal "analysis" comes from Janina Dill as a source for "expert" commentary. More about Janina's relative qualifications in a bit. First, let's focus on the substance of her claims involving the ๐ฌ๐ง government's "obligations" related to refusing to grant licenses to export arms to ๐ฎ๐ฑ.
As mentioned above, she is focused on "several treaties in international law that suggest that the UK should not be exporting arms to Israel and should not have been exporting arms to Israel in the year 2024." These include, according to Janina, "the Genocide Convention, the Geneva Conventions, and the Arms Trade Treaty."
Now, we'll cover each one of these sources in turn before addressing the broader issue with turning to a source like Janina for "expert" commentary.
- Genocide Convention
Unlike reporter O'Flynn, Janina doesn't connect her assessment regarding the ๐ฌ๐ง gov't's obligations to the ICJ or the "plausible risk" of genocide at all.
As she puts it (2m34s), "I would not venture to be entirely confident that the International Court of Justice will eventually find that this is a genocide, but that is immaterial to the question of the obligation of the UK government because the duty to prevent genocide is triggered when there is a serious risk of genocide, a danger of genocide, and when a state should have become aware of that danger, and that was absolutely the case at the beginning of 2024."
In these remarks, Janina expresses the legal STANDARD correctly. That is, the duty to prevent genocide (established in Art. I of the Genocide Convention) is activated when there is a serious risk of genocide (as reasonably interpreted in ICJ jurisprudence).
What Janina gets WRONG, though, is whether that obligation has been activated here. All she presents is her personal opinion that it "was absolutely the case at the beginning of 2024" - with no further explanation or evidence to substantiate her opinion.
Later in the segment, at about the 8m35s mark, Janina continues by observing. "The United States and Germany continue to supply Israel with weapons. And so that if the UK government then sends weapons to Israel for training, that other weapons are more available to be used in Gaza and the West Bank in violation of international law. The duty to prevent genocide isn't just a duty not to give the state that is at risk of creating a genocide the arms to do it, but it is a duty to use all means at your disposal to put pressure on the state to stop. And to me, that absolutely also includes sending equipment, even non-military equipment, but definitely dual use equipment and definitely military training."
Ok, a lot more personal opinion - without additional substantiation - regarding what the "duty to prevent genocide" entails. But still no conclusive evidence that the duty has been activated due to a "serious risk" of genocide to begin with.
And THAT is the most glaring deficiency in this line of analysis, because what Janina is doing - and the reporter is allowing her to do so - is substituting HER opinion as an "expert" for that of the UK government.
Ah, in case you weren't aware - and it would seem that neither "expert" nor reporter are - the UK government has already publicly determined ๐ฎ๐ฑ is NOT committing genocide.
More specifically, in response to a Parliamentary inquiry, then-Foreign Secretary @DavidLammy explained, "As per the Genocide Convention, the crime of genocide occurs only where there is specific 'intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.' The Government has not concluded that Israel is acting with that intent." (https://t.co/5RteEfIf4d)
Read that last sentence again. "The Government has not concluded that Israel is acting with [genocidal] intent."
Of course, each country is absolutely free to make its own assessment regarding whether ๐ฎ๐ฑ is responsible for genocide. And I am genuinely concerned about the number of Western middle powers that have essentially punted their sovereign authority to make that determination to the ICJ when it eventually publishes its decision on the merits of the ๐ฟ๐ฆ v ๐ฎ๐ฑ case.
Even so - as I have previously noted, as of June 2026 only about 1 in 3 UN Member States have formally concluded that ๐ฎ๐ฑ is responsible for genocide (https://t.co/vOqCi9RTSm).
The other ~2/3 have either expressed a NEGATIVE conclusion or haven't taken an official position either way (as far as I could tell, anyway).
2/3. That's 129 out of 193 UN Member States that have NOT formally & publicly concluded that ๐ฎ๐ฑ has committed genocide.
So despite the popular view that there is a "consensus" among human rights groups & genocide "scholars" & such: 1) the "consensus" suggestion is a myth; 2) human rights groups & genocide "scholars" aren't necessarily the most qualified entities to make such a determination; and 3) most importantly, there is no consensus among STATES.
And last I checked, States make interNATIONal law.
So with all respect that is due to Janina as a source of "expert" commentary, who tf cares - or should care - about her personal opinion regarding whether there is a serious risk of genocide & what measures the ๐ฌ๐ง government should take in response?
The ๐ฌ๐ง government has formally determined ๐ฎ๐ฑ is NOT committing genocide, and among UN Member States this assessment is by no means an outlier.
What matters here is what the STATE has determined, not Janina Dill. The failure to address & account for that OFFICIAL finding suggests this "news" report is either so uninformed that it should not be taken seriously or so biased against ๐ฎ๐ฑ that it can't bring itself to address that official ๐ฌ๐ง finding - or both.
Either way, for these reasons the commentary & coverage related to the Genocide Convention fundamentally lacks credibility.
- Geneva Conventions
This is a source of #LOAC "obligations" Janina mentions at the outset, but at least in the final edited clip of this segment she's not able to circle back to address.
Even so, she DOES cover this purported obligation established in the Geneva Conventions in a ๐งต here @X analyzing this Channel 4 "news" story in greater detail.
(initial post here: https://t.co/othTGogRFd; post 3 on the Geneva Convention "obligation" here: https://t.co/pango8Hvi0)
In this ๐งต, Janina further explains, "Common Article 1 of the Geneva Conventions" includes a "duty to ensure respect for #IHL, which includes broad negative duties across state parties, incl. no arms without the contested intent requirement of ARSIWA [Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts]. This is still sometimes contested, though the ICRC Commentary ๐is clear."
To this post, she includes screenshots from @ICRC Commentary arising from Common Article 1 of the 1949 Geneva Conventions.
And while it is interesting that the ICRC has concluded CA 1 of the Geneva Conventions, which establishes an obligation "to respect and to ensure respect for the present Conventions in all circumstances" (attachment 2), involves a requirement for States to encourage OTHER States "to respect" the Conventions, this position does NOT constitute customary international law.
That is, it does not reflect extensive & virtually uniform state practice with an accompanying expression of legal obligation (opinio juris).
More importantly for present purposes, the United Kingdom has explicitly REJECTED this ICRC interpretation.
For example, as then-Secretary Lammy explained in the letter to Parliament mentioned above (on the topic of genocide), "it is the UKโs long-standing view that CA1 does not impose a legal obligation to ensure that other States also respect the Geneva Conventions." (https://t.co/vHBJnL359k)
So it's great (though ill-advised & misinformed) that the ICRC interprets an external obligation into Common Article 1 of the Geneva Conventions. The UK government does NOT, and once again on this issue it is by no means an outlier.
Yet again, then, by mentioning the Geneva Conventions during the interview then expanding on that aspect of the analysis in her follow-up ๐งต, Janina is essentially attempting to substitute her own "expert" opinion for the official determination of the ๐ฌ๐ง government.
And again, she is either uninformed regarding the official ๐ฌ๐ง position or she's too biased (whether against ๐ฎ๐ฑ or in favor of humanitarian constraint ... more about that below) to convey in public that the UK does not endorse the ICRC position.
It's not enough to merely acknowledge that the ICRC position is "still sometimes contested." The ICRC interpretation - which Janina obviously endorses - is irrelevant given that the ๐ฌ๐ง position does NOT accept this interpretation AND this is a "news" story on whether the ๐ฌ๐ง government is complying with its obligations pursuant to international law.
Because of the ๐ฌ๐ง position, the Geneva Conventions & the supposed external "obligation" reflected in Common Article 1 is irrelevant to this story AND to the assessment of whether the UK government is complying with its international law obligations.
- Arms Trade Treaty
The third & final source of conventional law mentioned in this "news" story is the Arms Trade Treaty (ATT). The ๐ฌ๐ง also USED TO have an obligation to comply with the EU Common Position on arms exports, which expands a bit on the ATT - but THAT particular obligation disappeared for the UK with Brexit.
So, all we're left with on this topic is the ATT. And as is the case for the Geneva Conventions CA 1 external dimension addressed immediately above, there isn't a significant degree of in-depth analysis provided in the "news" story - though Janina does expand a bit on this obligation as well in her separate ๐งต.
From the "news" story, here's what we have that's relevant to the ATT (4m07s): "Even while there is a great deal of contestation around the question whether Israel is committing genocide in Gaza, it is hardly contestable at this point. And it was hardly contestable in 2024 that Israel is committing grave breaches and war crimes."
As Janina goes on to point out in her ๐งต on this story, the reason the assertion that "Israel is committing grave breaches and war crimes" is relevant in relation to the ATT is because that treaty includes obligations to refrain from transferring weapons to a recipient State when the sending State "has knowledge at the time of the authorization" that the weapons would be used to commit war crimes (among other offenses) (Article 6(3)), or later if it "determines there is an overriding risk" that the weapons would be used to commit the same offenses (Article 7(3)) (https://t.co/NXVg8lLgT4).
That's the doctrinal international law obligation, which Janina cites in passing by mentioning the Arms Trade Treaty, then further explains the specific provisions in her subsequent X post.
But now let's go back & review how this "news" story supposedly makes the case that ๐ฌ๐ง is perhaps not complying with its obligations pursuant to the ATT.
All we have is Janina saying, "It was hardly contestable in 2024 that Israel is committing grave breaches and war crimes."
That's it. One "expert" source, with NO additional commentary or explanation regarding how we KNOW this claim is "hardly contestable." Just a conclusory statement by a single source - and absolutely nothing else.
The (primary) PROBLEM with this assertion is that doctrinal standards for grave breaches & war crimes (let's just stick with war crimes for ease of reference) have become so fundamentally misrepresented in the court of public opinion over the last 20 years or so that we (seemingly) no longer REQUIRE a formal analysis that addresses each element of each incident we're purporting to analyze.
If we refer to the Rome Statute*** as a doctrinal template for war crimes (attachment 3), we see that we require evidence of the INTENT of each alleged offender in relation to each attack we're analyzing. And one component of "intent" is knowledge, which means "awareness that a circumstance exists".
(***a treaty that ๐ฌ๐ง has ratified but ๐ฎ๐ฑ has not - though practical application of these provisions by @IDF is substantially similar to what's reflected in Article 8 of the Rome Statute)
In relation to targeting provisions involving LOAC rules such as distinction & proportionality, this "circumstance" involves the civilian nature of the person / object that was made the object of attack.
So, in order to determine that a war crime was committed, we require evidence of the knowledge & intent for each person involved in each attack we claim to analyze. And using the distinction rule as an example (subsections i to iv of Article 8(2)(e) presented in attachment 3), that means we need evidence that the alleged offender was aware that the person / object did not qualify as a military objective AND THEY DIRECTED THE ATTACK AGAINST THAT TARGET ANYWAY .
Now, out of all these seemingly thousands upon thousands of allegations circulating in the court of public opinion claiming that ๐ฎ๐ฑ troops have committed war crimes, how many meet that doctrinal standard?
None that I recall. Yet this is the ONLY way, as a matter of doctrine, to convincingly conclude that war crimes have been committed (see attachment 4 for the abstract of my first law review article, which further addresses the issue of intent & war crimes).
As a matter of practice - that is, of doctrine - it's not enough to simply wave one's hand & claim that "it was hardly contestable in 2024 that Israel is committing grave breaches and war crimes", as Janina does in this clip.
No government lawyer advising on compliance with the ATT would make such a generalized statement because they're tasked with ACTUALLY applying the law as it exists IN DOCTRINE. And widespread "war crimes" allegations that are largely based on effects observed on the battlefield won't cut it.
Now, this "news" story does mention the fact that the Starmer gov't suspended 30 arms export licenses for ๐ฎ๐ฑ. In fact, the story then plays a clip of Lammy explaining this decision (4m54s):
"There does exist a clear risk that they might be used to commit or facilitate a serious violation of international humanitarian law."
Read that statement again. There's a clear risk these weapons MIGHT be used to commit / facilitate war crimes. Pretty weak explanation, no?
Indeed, the day that decision was announced to the public (2 Sep 2024), I posted a fairly detailed analysis of the (mis)characterizations of international law upon which those ~30 suspensions were based. (https://t.co/AiNfQ5r2Vu)
Bottom line is that the only way to reach the "clear risk" threshold was to distort the provisions of international law that were cited as the basis for the suspensions. To that end, this was merely a political stunt to appease the leftist base of the Labour Party - and the findings involving a "clear risk" of war crimes & such were - and remain - utterly unconvincing.
As does Janina's conclusory claim that it "was hardly contestable in 2024 that Israel is committing grave breaches and war crimes."
-----
Ok, that's it for the 3 conventional sources of international law cited in this "news" story to at least create the (sensationalist) appearance that ๐ฌ๐ง is failing to uphold its international "law" obligations by continuing to approve sales of arms to ๐ฎ๐ฑ.
Now let's address the broader context of why quotation marks are warranted around references to this "news" story that includes commentary from Janina Dill as the (sole!) "expert" source.
At least in Western culture, we expect our "news" media to reflect their choice of buzzwords like objective & impartial & fair & balanced & such. Yet this story, like so many (especially) involving coverage of ๐ฎ๐ฑ, reflects none of those values.
That's because the reporter misrepresents international law himself ("plausible risk") & includes commentary from only ONE source for "expert" analysis - and SHE thoroughly misrepresents the topic(s) for which she is called upon to provide commentary.
Now, this has historically proven to be a sensitive topic - so let me be clear about this: Janina absolutely IS an expert at some things, like providing her opinion about the ethics of armed conflict.
But she has no law degree, nor has she ever been admitted to the practice of law. And these are the baseline professional qualifications REQUIRED for those who actually provide advice to governments regarding compliance with the ATT & so on.
And THAT is what Janina has been asked to analyze.
By contrast, as someone who HAS graduated law school AND been admitted to practice law - plus practiced for 7 years as a military lawyer @USArmy to boot - I would never present such an abstract "legal" analysis as a source of expert commentary.
Predictably, her "expert" analysis isn't consistent with international law as it exists in doctrine. And when her "expert" commentary unravels, so, too does the credibility of this sensational "news" story.
A new chapter for Israel as new Knesset speaker elected by Israels anti Netanyahu parties, both Jewish & Arab, uniting & voting together for change.
Great 3-0 win for Ireland. 2nd in the group & Stop the Game, IPSC, Kneecap, Lambert, Bohemians, SF, PBP, SD, multiple attention seeking Irish celebs & various sports journos failed in their objective to sabotage Irish football.
Lets translate. Public attention seeking, a morally bankrupt political party, lacking any unique sellable identity, proclaims its place as a semantically & ideologically confused โcentre rightโ party ( not a โcentristโ or โ right wingโ party) while engaging in a Stalinist 1930s/1950s type communist verbiage purge & an incomprehensible political reset!.
Totally logical & understandable. Definitely a winning strategy- NOT
JOHN LEE: Simon Harris is ridding Fine Gael of Varadkarism because he knows something that Micheรกl doesn't... or doesn't want to know https://t.co/0g90b8eEq1
The rot continues as Galway University withdraws from EU co-operative research project โcontaminatedโ by Jewish academics ludicrously asserting that โ the University of Galway continues to separate the actions of the Israeli government to those of its people.โ Strange as it is โ peopleโ it has determined to boycott not the government.
Just another Irish university surrendering to Israel haters & antisemites, intellectually & internationally shooting itself in the foot!.
Wonder was anyone claiming a fake doctorate associated with this boycott campaign?
. https://t.co/tNrURbCYDI