Answering Catholics

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

Scripture Alone is true because:
1. Oral apostolic tradition outside of Scripture is lost.
2. Scripture is clear that tradition is fallible.
3. And it is obvious that Popes, Councils and the modern invention of the modern ordinary & universal Magisterium are all fallible.

[MrCasey @MrCasey62]

No, the reason “Sola Scriptura” is bogus is because it claims “God’s *WRITTEN* word is the *ONLY* infallible authority”. The Bible NEVER says that. It DENIES that.

These people don’t even know their OWN definitions. 🤣

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@ShaneSchaetzel @KalaDeeDee False.
James had primacy and passed judgment at the Council of Jerusalem.
And Paul rebuked Peter to his face because Peter was in the wrong. And then Paul made the incident public by writing about it.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@ShaneSchaetzel Why is Pope Leo the Leftist excommunicating SSPX but taking no action against Joe Biden, Nancy Pelosi, German heretics and LGBT-affirming priests?????

Schismatic Popes have now caused schisms by excommunicating:
the Greeks,
Martin Luther, and
the SSPX.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@ShaneSchaetzel @KalaDeeDee False.
James had primacy and passed judgment at the Council of Jerusalem.
And Paul rebuked Peter to his face because Peter was in the wrong. And then Paul made the incident public by writing about it.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

Why is Pope Leo the Leftist excommunicating SSPX but taking no action against Joe Biden, Nancy Pelosi, German heretics and LGBT-affirming priests?????

Popes have now caused schisms by excommunicating:
the Greeks,
Martin Luther, and
the SSPX.

[Shane Schaetzel †☧ @ShaneSchaetzel]

Do I think Pope Leo XIV made a good decision by excommunicating the entire SSPX and declaring them in schism?

No. I think it was a bad decision.

Do I accept it as valid and legitimate, as in one that must be obeyed?

Yes.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

Is anyone really stupid enough to believe that?

Why is Pope Leo the Leftist excommunicating SSPX but takes no action against Joe Biden, Nancy Pelosi, German heretics and LGBT-affirming priests?????

[Uche is a girl 🇻🇦 @UcheMaryOkoli]

“We declare, say, define, and pronounce that it is absolutely necessary for the salvation of every human creature to be subject to the Roman Pontiff.”

- Pope Boniface VIII, the Bull Unam Sanctam, 1302.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@Catholic_bro Parody account?
Or just a parody post???

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@valorthodoxia Being Orthodox is easy.
Despise God’s word by worshipping idols.
Teach that Mary was a lousy wife by agreeing to marry her husband and then sinfully refusing to have sex with him.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@CatholicDrip___ Why?
Popes owned slaves.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

Why the first 1,500 years?
Why not the first 60 years?

Because most man-made Roman Catholic nonsense was made up after the apostolic age but before the Reformation???!!!!

[Cameron Riecker @riecker]

If you cannot name a single Christian from the first 1500 years of Christianity who believed what you believe,

You’re wrong.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@riecker Why the first 1,500 years?
Why not the first 60 years?

Because most man-made Roman Catholic nonsense was made up after the apostolic age but before the Reformation???!!!!

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@TheGr8terGood @CCCorliss And Peter is the Apostle to the Jews and was never Bishop of Rome.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@kyotoisreformed Good for your friend!

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@MrCasey62 That’s a bald faced lie @MrCasey62.
Neither Matthew or Mark says Jesus brothers weren’t his blood brothers.

Like any good Jewish wife, Mary had sex with her husband.
Stop the idolatrous slandering of her.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@CatholicDrip___ @JamesDitto12 But Ambrose said this:
“Faith, then, is the foundation of the Church, for it was not said of Peter’s person, but of Peter’s faith, that the gates of hell should not prevail against it; it is the confession that has conquered hell.” On the Incarnation (5. 34.)

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@ShaneSchaetzel To which you have no historically accurate response.

What next? Are you going to try and tell us Catholics did not violate the safe conduct given to Jan Hus?

Or that the Waldenses deserved to be persecuted?

Or that both sides were wrong for the Church condemning Galileo????

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@swamthetiber25 Don’t be silly.

Mary is mentioned nowhere in Acts outside of the first chapter and there is no mention of her by name in any of Paul’s or John’s epistles.

To put it bluntly, there is not a shred of evidence that she was still walking the earth when Scripture was written.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

But symbolizing “buried” requires immersion rather than washing.

So the more serious question is whether immersion is a requirement or whether immersion is just the analogy used since it was the actual practice referred to in Romans 6 and seen throughout the gospels.

[Garrett Ham @garrettham_esq]

I hear this argument regularly, almost exclusively from people who don’t know Greek or who have had maybe one year of it. βαπτiζω has a larger lexical range than “immerse.” For example, the word is used to describe ritual handwashing that involved pouring water over the hands, not submersing them.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@garrettham_esq @SwordMasterPub But symbolizing “buried” requires immersion rather than washing.
So the more serious question is whether immersion is a requirement or whether immersion is just the analogy used since it was the actual practice referred to in Romans 6 and seen throughout the gospels.

[Answering Catholics @AnsweringRCs]

@garrettham_esq I don’t like crackers and grape juice. … But … Does Scripture actually say what was in the “Cup”?