that is NOT a straight red. i'm sorry...
he's going for the ball. that's a yellow 10 times out of 10
VAR really watched that and said yeah, send him off. in a knockout game. unreal
Under IFAB Law 12, serious foul play requires a challenge that endangers the safety of an opponent or uses excessive force/brutality. A merely reckless challenge is a yellow-card offense.
Why critics think Balogun’s did not meet that red-card threshold:
No obvious intent or lunge
He appeared to be shielding/competing for the ball, not launching into a tackle.
Contact looked accidental
Reports describe him landing on Muharemović’s ankle after trying to play or protect the ball, rather than deliberately stamping.
Slow motion can exaggerate danger
VAR replays often make a step-on look more deliberate and forceful than it was in real time.
It was a “football incident” with bad consequences
The ankle twist looked nasty, but critics argue the result of contact should not automatically turn an accidental action into serious foul play.
Inconsistency concern
Fans and commentators compared it to similar incidents that were not punished as red cards, which fuels the feeling that the standard was applied unevenly.