JD, MBA, MPH | Healthcare Policy, Strategy and Investing | Finance and Markets | History and Politics | Long suffering NY sports fan | Family (and dogs) first
Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks, one of the most fascinating Jewish minds of the 21st century, said in a powerful speech to the British House of Lords: “A thousand years of Jewish history in Europe added certain words to the human vocabulary: forced conversion, Inquisition, expulsion, ghetto, pogrom, Holocaust.
For my British and European friends who are "shocked" and "surprised", here are 10 reasons you didn't see this coming.
Read this short post and then read the replies from our American friends who will confirm what I'm saying.
1. Americans love their country and want it to be the best in the world. America is a nation of people who conquered a continent. They love strength. They love winning. Any leader who appeals to that has an automatic advantage.
2. Unlike Europeans, Americans have not accepted managed decline. They don't have Net Zero here, they believe in producing their own energy and making it as cheap as possible because they know that their prosperity depends on it.
3. Prices for most basic goods in the US have increased rapidly and are sky high. What the official statistics say about inflation and the reality of people's lives are not the same.
4. Unlike you, Americans do not believe in socialism. They believe in meritocracy. They don't care about the super rich being super rich because they know that they live in a country where being super rich is available to anyone with the talent and drive to make it. They don't resent success, they celebrate it.
5. Americans are the most pro-immigration people in the world. Read that again. Seriously, read it again. Americans love an immigrant success story. They want more talented immigrants to come to America. But they refuse to accept people coming illegally. They believe in having a border.
6. Americans are sensitive about racial issues and their country's imperfect history. They believe that those who are disadvantaged by the circumstances of their birth should be given the opportunity to succeed. What they reject, however, is the idea that in order to address the errors of the past new errors must be made. DEI is racist. They know it and they reject it precisely because they are not racist.
7. Americans are the most philosemitic nation on earth. October 7 and the pro-Hamas left's reaction shocked them to their very core because, among other things, they remember what 9/11 was like and they know jihad when they see it.
8. Americans are extremely practical people. They care about what works, not what sounds good. In Europe, we produce great writers and intellectuals. In America they produce (and attract) great engineers, businessmen and investors. Because of this, they care less about Trump's rhetoric than you do and more about his policies than you do.
9. Americans are deeply optimistic people. They hate negativity. The woke view of American history as a series of evils for which they must eternally apologise is utterly abhorrent to them. They believe in moving forward together, not endlessly obsessing about the past.
10. America is a country whose founding story is one of resistance to government overreach. They loathe unnecessary restrictions, regulations and control. They understand that freedom comes with the price of self-reliance and they pay it gladly.
The great advantage of living one’s life in Hebrew is that your psyche isn’t constantly buffeted by their insane obsession with you.
This urgency to deny the Jews the chance to mourn on October 7 isn’t some accidental mass-mobilization. It is purposeful and predatory. If the Jews are allowed to mourn, then the Jews are humanized, have a perspective worth noticing, dignity worth acknowledging, and a chance to recover.
But the point of October 7 was to be the start of a great and permanent cleansing of the world from the psychic irritant of the Jew. This is it. The chips are down. The Jews must be tormented constantly and mercilessly, their suffering denied, their evils magnified. They must be massacred in Israel and abused in London, New York and Twitter. Nothing can distract these great holy warriors from the sacred task of erasing the Jewish narrative and experience, and eventually the Jew (it’s no accident that Nassim is also now obsessed with Jewish genetics). And it will only get worse - both because the overall West doesn’t yet fully understand the threat of these ideologies to itself and because these holy warriors are convinced they’re on the cusp of victory.
So they torment the Jews, double down on the massacre, and defend and validate and call forth more of the same.
Fellow Jews, don’t forget you have your own language and your own polity now. We in Israel do not hear this abuse, we are mostly oblivious to it. When we do notice it, we mostly see it as a sign of societal decline, a bravado and brutality borrowed from certain Middle Eastern political and religious cultures that do not signal courage or intimidating capability, but ideological childishness and cultural incompetence. It is the same basic backwardness that hangs over our region like a stifling cloud.
My humble suggestion: Respond to this garbage as Israelis do. Turn off Twitter and go mourn with your own people. Find them in physical space, where you can see real faces and speak real words. That’s what I’m going to do.
Let our enemies rage and strut and convince themselves of the righteousness of their hatred. This is, alas, their baseline state when the going gets tough. It is their curse. You don’t have to live in it. You don’t even have to notice it. Go find some Jews.
Today is a good day to remember the words of Charles
@krauthammer, a great and learned man who truly understood the lessons of history.
He wrote this of Winston Churchill, whom he deemed “the 20th Century’s Indispensable Man."
Full article published in The Washington Post: https://t.co/mNnKJDGqSL
Featured in his book Things That Matter: https://t.co/DjS7A994oD
Sam Harris: "Of course, the boundary between Anti-Semitism and generic moral stupidity is a little hard to discern—and I’m not sure that it is always important to find it. I’m not sure it matters why a person can’t distinguish between collateral damage in a necessary war and conscious acts of genocidal sadism that are celebrated as a religious sacrament by a death cult. Our streets have been filled with people, literally tripping over themselves in their eagerness to demonstrate that they cannot distinguish between those who intentionally kill babies, and those who inadvertently kill them, having taken great pains to avoid killing them, while defending themselves against the very people who have just intentionally tortured and killed innocent men, women, and yes… babies…
If you have landed, proudly and sanctimoniously, on the wrong side of this asymmetry—this vast gulf between savagery and civilization—while marching through the quad of an Ivy League institution wearing yoga pants, I’m not sure it matters that your moral confusion is due to the fact that you just happen to hate Jews. Whether you’re an anti-Semite or just an apologist for atrocity is probably immaterial. The crucial point is that you are dangerously confused about the moral norms and political sympathies that make life in this world worth living."
Joe Biden may think he’s dividing America and Israel, but what he’s really doing is uniting American patriots who know we have to stand with our great ally Israel in its moment of need.
Hundreds of Jewish students at @Columbia just published one of the most incredible student letters I have ever read.
It's not only magnificently written, but it also clearly articulates their experiences on campus for the past six months.
Their letter tells the story of what's it like being a Jewish student right now better than any professor like myself could ever do.
Please take 4-5 minutes to read their letter.
Give Jewish students a voice.
https://t.co/nsWNScaoZS
From @WSJopinion: The anti-Israel protests are often portrayed as a spontaneous uprising of student indignation against the Gaza war. But we’re learning that behind the young idealists is an organized movement of leftists who want to spread disorder. https://t.co/sllQQGJ0rV
Foreign governments are not allowed to own our radio and TV stations for fear they might be used for anti-American propaganda and influence. The Congress just banned TikTok for the same reason.
Why then do we allow foreign governments to give money to our universities, funds that are used to set up Middle Eastern, Asian studies and other programs which can be designed to fit the desired narratives of the donors.
Our universities have a profound impact on our younger generation at a time when they are particularly vulnerable to being manipulated, that is, away from home for the first time, and young and naive.
Notably, these foreign governments concentrate their ‘gifts’ to our most elite institutions where they can influence our next generation of leaders — judges, politicians, members of the media and more.
Based on recent events on campus, this seems to have been a bad strategy for America. We need to rethink this.
An Arab Muslim world that cannot contain Jews and that out-shouts us 200-to-1 online is pretending to be “silenced” and victimized.
You don’t worry about equality or rights or freedom anywhere in the Middle East except in Israel. Because this isn’t really about equality or rights or freedom.
This is about your supremacist rage that we could not be exterminated with tanks, haven’t fled to some imagined home country we don’t have, and don’t cower and beg for you to tolerate us, as Middle Eastern Christians, Bahai’i and other minorities must everywhere from Baghdad to Algiers.
Fuck you.
The day you start to care about Hamas’s tyranny and atrocities is the day we Israelis will believe you seek peace or freedom.
No, you can’t have our self-determination and freedom. No, we will not disarm and trust to the kindness of Arab politics to keep us safe.
You have never been silenced. You have never offered us safety or equality. We know too much about you, we nation of refugees who fled every Arab land to the last man, woman and child within the living memory of our grandparents, to ever mistake your hatred and rage for any genuine call for justice and safety.
Yad Vashem chairman @AmbDaniDayan in a letter to Columbia President Shafik:
“Heidelberg University in Germany was not less prestigious than Columbia...A mob of Heidelberg students burned Jewish and other “corrupt” books in
Universitätsplatz ("University Square"). Its faculty developed pseudo-academic fields like race theory, eugenics and forced euthanasia. Heidelberg did have administrators. Unfortunately, it lacked moral leadership.”
Truly amazing! Columbia decided to hold its students accountable to the laws of the school. They are seeing the consequences of their actions. Something these kids were most likely never taught. Good SAT scores and self-entitlement do not supersede the law. I am sure you would agree that we have to teach them these valuable life skills.
Secondly, I was with those “units” last Thursday that you describe as having, “the most violent reputations.” These “units” removed students with great care and professionalism, not a single incident was reported.
The only incidents that day on campus were the student's hateful anti-Semitic speech and vile language towards our cops. I am sure you agree any hateful speech is unacceptable. You should rethink your comments to a simple thank you to the NYPD and hate has no place in our society.
Maybe you should walk around Columbia and NYU and listen to their remarks of pure hatred. I will ensure those “units” will protect you as they do for all NYers 24/7/365.
Lack of accountability = consequences✅
Hate from anyone, anywhere has no place in our city and country.✅
@NYPDDaughtry @NYPDnews@NYPDChiefOfDept@NYPDPC@NYPD1stDep@NYCPBA@sbanypd@lbanypd@CeaNypd
Some points regarding the overnight Iranian missile attack on Israel:
1. Contrary to what pundits are saying, this wasn’t designed merely as “bells and whistles” with no damage.
When you shoot 350 flying objects timed to hit Israel at the same moment,
when you use three fundamentally different weapon types—cruise missiles, ballistic missiles and UAVs,
you’re looking to penetrate Israel’s defenses and kill Israelis.
2. The US administration is telling us: “This is a victory, you’ve already won by thwarting the missiles.
No need for any further action.”
No, it’s NOT a victory.
Yes, it’s a remarkable success of Israel’s air defense systems, but it’s not a victory.
When a bully tries to hit you 350 times and only succeeds seven time, you’ve NOT won.
You don’t win wars just by intercepting your enemy’s hits, nor do you deter it.
Your enemy will just try harder with more and better weapons and methods next time.
How DO you deter?
By exacting a deeply painful price.
3. It’s incorrect to say “nobody got hurt”.
There’s a 7 year-old Israeli-Arab girl called Amina Elhasuny fighting for her life.
That’s who coward Khamenei hit.
4. The Islamic Republic of Iran made a big mistake.
For the past 30 years it’s been wreaking havoc on the region—through its proxies.
A terror-octopus whose head is Tehran, and its tentacles are in Lebanon, Yemen, Iraq, Syria and Gaza.
How convenient.
The Mullahs send others to conduct horrendous terror attacks, and die for them.
Other people’s blood.
Israel’s strategic mistake for the past 30 years was to play along this strategy.
We always fought the Octopus’ arms, but hardly exacted a price from its Iranian head.
This should change now:
Hezbollah or Hamas shoots a rocket at Israel?
Tehran pays a price.
5. The enemy is the Iranian REGIME, not the wonderful Iranian people.
The Iranian regime reminds me of the Soviet regime in 1985: corrupt to the core, old, incompetent, despised by its own people, and destined to collapse.
The sooner the better.
The West can accelerate the regime’s inevitable collapse with a set of soft and clever actions, short of military force.
Remember, USSR collapsed without any need for a direct American attack.
Let’s do this.
6. Israel is fighting everybody’s war. In Gaza, Lebanon and Tehran.
We’re considered “the small satan” by radical Islam. America is the big one.
I’ll be clear: if these crazy fanatic Islamic terrorists get away with murder by hiding among civilians, this method will be adopted by terrorists worldwide.
We’re not asking anyone to fight for us. We’ll do the job.
But we do expect our allies to have our back, especially when it’s tough—and now it’s tough.
Be on the right side and help us defeat these horrible and savage regimes.
1) I’m going to explain a few things about Jews and Zionism for the benefit of people on here who might not know or understand.
(This isn't for the watermelon/red triangle-emojis-in-the-bio people, who are beyond rational thought, but everyone else, please do read)
A thread:
Jay Sures, a regent of the University of California system, writes the best letter yet on the scandal of the academy. Really a masterpiece of clarity and outrage.
Anyone doubting the Holocaust or wondering how it possibly could have occurred, look no further than your evening news. Paris, London, San Francisco, Amman, and so many other cities are now aflame with Jew hatred. College campuses have abandoned “safe spaces” and seek to inflict maximum pain and insecurity upon their Jewish students. The argument that anti-Zionism is not antisemitism is being debunked in real time. Thank God for the State of Israel and the IDF — it is the last, best and only chance for Jewish survival.