Eastern Cardano Council statement to the Cardano Community
A new Cardano Constitution has now been enacted on-chain.
Our vote on the Governance Action that presented it to the Cardano Community: gov_action1jxne7hynfd7frcczwumd2eggps4kvy0msjztz9t0mutpy870ksgqqp6vps addressed how the Constitution was produced, not what has now been enacted.
With the new Constitution now in force, we will take the time needed to carefully review and understand its implications before considering further governance actions.
During this period, we will not vote on constitutional matters on behalf of the community. This pause is intentional and responsible. It ensures that any future decisions are made with clarity, accuracy, and respect for the Constitution as it now stands.
We will update the community once this review is complete.
------------------------------------
*Eastern Cardano Council - ECC Statement on Cardano Forum
https://t.co/ZbP3epuOyp
The Eastern Cardano Council has concluded its review of Harmonic Labsโ response to our vote on their governance action.
We carefully evaluated the points raised but found that the arguments presented are not consistent with our interpretation of the constitution. As such, our vote remains unchanged.
We appreciate the Harmonic Labs team taking the time to respond to our rationale and for engaging in constructive, open, and transparent governance dialogue.
Our full response is available on the Cardano Forum:
https://t.co/LGADpPKBOT
The Eastern Cardano Council has concluded its review of Harmonic Labsโ response to our vote on their governance action.
We carefully evaluated the points raised but found that the arguments presented are not consistent with our interpretation of the constitution. As such, our vote remains unchanged.
We appreciate the Harmonic Labs team taking the time to respond to our rationale and for engaging in constructive, open, and transparent governance dialogue.
Our full response is available on the Cardano Forum:
https://t.co/LGADpPKBOT
In the link below we directly address the @EasternCardano vote
TL;DR
We believe the ECC decision to be antithetical to the spirit of the Cardano constitution and largely misguided, resulting in double standards undermining the constitutional principle of equality
Following further review of the argument made in this post, the Eastern Cardano Council have agreed (7-0) that the 350 million ADA NCL Info action should be assessed based the constitution that was active when the governance action was submitted, which was the previous constitution.
As the previous constitution did not permit the Constitutional Committee to veto Info governance actions based on constitutionality, and the NCL Info action was approved by DReps, we have therefore determined that the NCL is active and can be used when assessing treasury withdrawal governance actions.
Note, this is a reversal of our previous position about whether the NCL is active, which was based on the current constitution. That decision was prior to the argument being made that we should be assessing the NCL Info action with the previous constitution.
@MicheleHarmonic Thank you for preparing this response to our vote Michele. We will review it and if it highlights any parts of your proposal we may have missed, we will re-evaluate our decision.
Following further review of the argument made in this post, the Eastern Cardano Council have agreed (7-0) that the 350 million ADA NCL Info action should be assessed based the constitution that was active when the governance action was submitted, which was the previous constitution.
As the previous constitution did not permit the Constitutional Committee to veto Info governance actions based on constitutionality, and the NCL Info action was approved by DReps, we have therefore determined that the NCL is active and can be used when assessing treasury withdrawal governance actions.
Note, this is a reversal of our previous position about whether the NCL is active, which was based on the current constitution. That decision was prior to the argument being made that we should be assessing the NCL Info action with the previous constitution.
Important Follow-up on the NCL Status
We have continued to deliberate the NCL status issue and in doing so have identified additional considerations that have created tension with our previous determination.
Please review a further statement from us on this matter at https://t.co/94ddKRmHSX
This newly argued interpretation and the uncertainty it generates, further highlights the importance of properly funding governance resources, coordination infrastructure and process design.
@phil_uplc Thanks for your reply Phil ๐
Could you please review our post regarding this๐as it addresses some of the points you raised?
https://t.co/AXIMMzjI6j
Following feedback from the community about our NCL Status announcement, we have provided more information regarding our rationale in a post on the Cardano Forum.
https://t.co/IGvdRfmbsi
We look forward to working with the community to develop more robust processes and frameworks, to help alleviate issues relating to the NCL and other governance matters in the future.
Net Change Limit Status
The ECC team recently discussed the status of Cardano's Net Change Limit (NCL) and have determined that there is currently NO active NCL. This means that we will be required to find the treasury withdrawal governance actions currently on-chain as unconstitutional.
The previously active NCL (gov_action169kllwhfmp488je5x5rwvufd08p8sztdcf0ghf5sp6ey2gnjdwaqql47xry) ended at the conclusion of epoch 612. While 2 governance actions were recently submitted to establish a new NCL, neither have met the criteria necessary to be considered ratified.
While the Info action titled "Net Change Limit (Epoch 613 to Epoch 713)" (gov_action1m3xx08yv788vfxqh6nfvrjtvmqpwezsy0ggaczctkyjmttc2wmxsq4jsr7q) did meet the 50% DRep approval requirement, it did NOT meet the constitutionality assessment threshold by the Constitutional Committee.
The latest NCL governance action titled "Net Change Limit of 300 Million ADA for Epochs 613โ713" (gov_action1wwjwkg2g0qwr0mehey9r8gwn6qz3r28wl6wdl2s75kfmpy8j87tqqtft9tp) did NOT meet the 50% DRep approval requirement.
Important Follow-up on the NCL Status
We have continued to deliberate the NCL status issue and in doing so have identified additional considerations that have created tension with our previous determination.
Please review a further statement from us on this matter at https://t.co/94ddKRmHSX
This newly argued interpretation and the uncertainty it generates, further highlights the importance of properly funding governance resources, coordination infrastructure and process design.
Following feedback from the community about our NCL Status announcement, we have provided more information regarding our rationale in a post on the Cardano Forum.
https://t.co/IGvdRfmbsi
We look forward to working with the community to develop more robust processes and frameworks, to help alleviate issues relating to the NCL and other governance matters in the future.
Following feedback from the community about our NCL Status announcement, we have provided more information regarding our rationale in a post on the Cardano Forum.
https://t.co/IGvdRfmbsi
We look forward to working with the community to develop more robust processes and frameworks, to help alleviate issues relating to the NCL and other governance matters in the future.
Net Change Limit Status
The ECC team recently discussed the status of Cardano's Net Change Limit (NCL) and have determined that there is currently NO active NCL. This means that we will be required to find the treasury withdrawal governance actions currently on-chain as unconstitutional.
The previously active NCL (gov_action169kllwhfmp488je5x5rwvufd08p8sztdcf0ghf5sp6ey2gnjdwaqql47xry) ended at the conclusion of epoch 612. While 2 governance actions were recently submitted to establish a new NCL, neither have met the criteria necessary to be considered ratified.
While the Info action titled "Net Change Limit (Epoch 613 to Epoch 713)" (gov_action1m3xx08yv788vfxqh6nfvrjtvmqpwezsy0ggaczctkyjmttc2wmxsq4jsr7q) did meet the 50% DRep approval requirement, it did NOT meet the constitutionality assessment threshold by the Constitutional Committee.
The latest NCL governance action titled "Net Change Limit of 300 Million ADA for Epochs 613โ713" (gov_action1wwjwkg2g0qwr0mehey9r8gwn6qz3r28wl6wdl2s75kfmpy8j87tqqtft9tp) did NOT meet the 50% DRep approval requirement.
Our interpretation of the new constitution is different to this.
While what you say was the case in the previous constitution, the new one introduced a requirement for the CC to vote on the constitutionality of Info governance actions.
It didnโt exclude NCLs as an Info governance, so we believe therefore that NCLs are included in that requirement.
@mikerogero We will always abide by the decision of the CC, even if it is different to how we voted as one of seven. If this had sufficient โconstitutionalโ votes to meet the required threshold, then we would consider it a valid NCL.
๐ณ The Eastern Cardano Council (ECC) recently cast its on-chain votes on GA75 and GA76.
Curious about the reasoning behind our decisions?
We invite you to read our official rationales and explore the principles that guided our votes โฌ๏ธ
GA75 โ https://t.co/hZfkgrCdmv
GA76 โ https://t.co/XFxVHLxggD
CC:
@selfdrivenMark@phillewisit@yojoflo@Hahero7@OscarW3st@andreassosilo@CardanoMiyatake
#Cardano #Governance #Voltaire #ECC
๐ฃ Official Announcement from the Eastern Cardano Council
The Eastern Cardano Council has issued a formal statement regarding the current validity status of the Constitutional Committee and the resulting temporary suspension of voting participation for Governance Actions submitted after November 26, 2025.
We invite the community to review the full announcement for complete context and procedural clarity:
๐ Full Statement:
https://t.co/CuwQdlHqX1
The ECC remains committed to upholding transparency, constitutional integrity, and responsible governance across the Cardano ecosystem.
CC: @selfdrivenMark@phillewisit@yojoflo@Hahero7@OscarW3st@andreassosilo@CardanoMiyatake
๐ณ Recently, the Eastern Cardano Council (ECC) voted "Constitutional" on GA74: "Reimburse Ikigai Info Governance Action Deposit"
Want to know why?
We invite you to read our rationale and understand the principles behind our decisions โฌ๏ธ
GA74 Rationale:
https://t.co/s32f5XRdTX
CC: @selfdrivenMark@phillewisit@yojoflo@Hahero7@OscarW3st@andreassosilo@CardanoMiyatake
#Cardano #Governance #Voltaire #ECC #OnChainVoting
๐ CC MEMBER VOTE ALERT! ๐
๐ณ๏ธ The vote is: Constitutional
๐ฅ Voted by: Eastern Cardano Council
๐ Gov Action: https://t.co/rVAkKu1QTj
๐ The vote rationale: https://t.co/hPLSQnQ5R5
#Cardano#Blockchain#Governance