@GivnerAriel That 3 Circuit judges all had different rationales IMO undercuts any "its clear" pronouncements by any party.
It also highlights that the PMs need to hit a 2 leg parley (swap + field preemption) to win.
Which you cant hedge on a PM b/c all 3 say parley is illegal gambling.😀
@GivnerAriel Do you agree with the same (dissenting) judge that parleys and prop bets are not swaps and are therefore illegal to list?
Where do over/unders fit?
If bet is home team -10, that doesn't hedge your "free beer if home team wins" promo if home team by 5, so is that not a swap?
@0x9212ce55@lex_node@avi_eisen The oracle / price feed manipulation type cases can still be brought under theory #2 (assuming you pick right court).
Same way this case does not mean "crypto front running is legal." If bros had owed some duty to the front runners it was front running, that might've worked.
@0x9212ce55@lex_node@avi_eisen For #2 with Avi, court answer was "yes he manipulated the market so committed a crime, but you DOJ brought it in wrong court so have to dismiss." Answer would have been different if DOJ filed the case in PR (or EDNY - cant remember the details of where he traded from)
@bgrace805 Inner City Press is a follow because I love hearing the updates from random courtrooms in SDNY/EDNY - he does yeomen's work and the items are pithy and well written.
@Truthcoin 50 million + voters sat out midterms where Trump was not on the ballot bc Trump did not pardon Storm?
Considering that crypto was not on the list of issues voters said mattered in the midterms, where are you getting that stat from?
@TraceSchmeltz@DustinGouker@WALLACHLEGAL For the casino one, yes (same way reinsurance hedges insurance).
But what about the 2 DCMs with their in house MMs? Can they each 50 leg parley & then say "look - bona fide hedging economic utility".
@TraceSchmeltz@DustinGouker@WALLACHLEGAL The "hedging" here is "If I get one-sided in my tribal casino sports book, I can hedge using this contract."
Isn't that circular? Under that logic, any 2 DCMs can issue similar contracts and each DCM can then point to its in house MM and say "other guys K allows me to hedge"
@billsperos Unless this is a kick to the nuts of the sportbooks like FD (who CFTC approved in summer) to force them to serve all states - even those it excluded b/c believed it would be illegal - and deny an exemption so their execs get indicted in Utah too?
@billsperos What is the point then?
PMs raised and lost in 6th & 9th argue of “impossible to comply with geofencing b/c would violate impartial access.”
CFTC’s “yes it violates impartial access, but we will let you do it if we like you” doesn’t really improve the impossibility argue.
@CarloDAngelo The kicker on Waters amends to House Clarity rejected by GOP in 2025 was no crypto agency rulemaking without a quorum.
I'm generally in favor of balanced regulatory agencies.
But that would kill everything bc 0% chance DJT fills any empty seats at CFTC (Or SEC).
@CarloDAngelo Wouldn't clearer delineation of responsibility help and not derail? It would avoid things like the upcoming injunction against single stock perps (with court having already saying they are NSE products & not CFTC venue products). Same for CME re crypto perps.