Finn Wilson

He/Him

Philosophy PhD Grad Student

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@AleMartnezR1 @Harri18971 I don't think you understood Harald's objection.

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@AleMartnezR1 He has these properties, since it hasn't even been established He is a thing with properties.

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@AleMartnezR1 The rest of the argument is just confusedly treating God as a real thing with real properties. But if you treat God hypothetically (as I have above), the force of the argument vanishes. If He exists, then He would have the properties you describe. It doesn't follow from this...

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@Nonlin_Org What does that mean?

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@DPadenAkaterry @pray2pesci It shouldn't be blindly accepted, but the evidence for it is blindingly obvious.

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@AleMartnezR1 God as you define Him exists in no possible world.

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@Nonlin_Org You're still not making any sense.

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@Nonlin_Org Could you elaborate?

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@AleMartnezR1 Why do you keep posting bad but different renditions of ontological arguments?

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@DPadenAkaterry @United_Updates1 @projo44 @NotEvolution1 "First man" in biblical context means first human, physically formed, spiritually enlivened, imago Dei bearer, with no pre-existing hominid ancestors."

Yes, on this model, Adam is the first hominid who is an ensouled imago dei bearer.

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@DPadenAkaterry @United_Updates1 @projo44 @NotEvolution1 Yeah, so what?

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@DPadenAkaterry @United_Updates1 @projo44 @NotEvolution1 Metaphors can be metaphors for actual events. Saying He didn't literally breathe doesn't mean He did nothing.

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@DPadenAkaterry @projo44 @United_Updates1 @NotEvolution1 I didn't ask if it's a signature of humanity or imago dei. Can you answer the question I asked?

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@DPadenAkaterry @United_Updates1 @projo44 @NotEvolution1 Since both points were bad, you might want to give up asking ai to make your arguments for you.

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@DPadenAkaterry @United_Updates1 @projo44 @NotEvolution1 Is it a metaphor or not?

[Finn Wilson @FinnWilson9]

@DPadenAkaterry @projo44 @United_Updates1 @NotEvolution1 "If it's more human than ape, then humans are on a continuum from apes" Why are quoting things I didn't say? Please answer my question. If I take your answer and twist it unfairly, call me out, but don't endlessly dodge questions. Can you answer the question?