Connecting investment professionals with structured products expertise. Founder and Co-Managing Director of iBC Structured Products. #structuredproducts
@thetimes Appalling behaviour for a barrister in court, as Rosamund says. I hope the bar counsel take appropriate action amd show their teeth and denosbtare such behaviour of lawyers is not tolerable.
I’m pleased to share with you some important correspondence sent to @TheFCA CEO Nikhil Rathi by @johnmcdonnellMP in his capacity as Chair of the @appgonifandffs.
The correspondence was in the form of an open letter, hence our being able to share it with you.
The letter is necessarily detailed and long, but a fair summary would be as follows:
The letter challenges the FCA’s handling of whistleblowers and calls for greater independence, transparency and accountability following the death by suicide of whistleblower Simon Andriesz.
There are three important topics covered:
1. Independence and scope of the Paterson Review
John McDonnell MP questions the appointment of FCA Non-Executive Director Lea Paterson to review the FCA’s handling of Simon Andriesz’s case. He argues that Nikhil Rathi’s evidence to the Treasury Committee on 13th October was contradictory and failed to unambiguously establish whether the review is confined to the FCA’s communications with Mr. Andriesz or extends to wider whistleblowing practices. He requests clear, published terms of reference, clarification of who controls the review’s scope and reconsideration of appointing an independent external reviewer. He also seeks confirmation that the report will be published in full with only redactions as necessary.
2. FCA participation in the APPG’s summit about protecting whistleblowers from retaliation
John McDonnell MP criticises the FCA’s decision not to provide an executive-level participant at the APPG whistleblowing summit on Monday 2nd November, offering only an observer. He argues that discussing general principles of whistleblower protection would not compromise the Paterson Review and urges the FCA to participate meaningfully and engage directly with whistleblowers. By not doing so the FCA misses a unique opportunity to learn through engagement; not a good look when the FCA is undertaking a lessons-learned review.
3. Independent survey of whistleblowers
The letter strongly challenges the credibility of the FCA’s 2022 whistleblower survey, which received only 21 complete responses from 68 selected individuals, out of 1,041 reports received during the relevant period. FOI disclosures show the exercise was conducted in a purposive and seemingly contrived manner. For example, only cases selected by the FCA’s whistleblowing case handlers were included. John McDonnell MP calls for an independently administered survey of every individual who has contacted the FCA about whistleblowing since January 2022, with the methodology, questionnaire and results published.
The letter calls for substantive answers to important questions covering whistleblower protection, regulatory responsibilities and historical FCA practices. It requests an urgent response on summit attendance and a comprehensive reply to the other issues raised within 14 days, emphasising that credible scrutiny, demonstrable accountability and a culture of openness are essential to restoring confidence in the FCA.
The full open letter is available for you here:
https://t.co/rsnC3Epydq
We believe this is a legitimate and necessary challenge of @TheFCA's handling of whistleblowers, particularly following the death by suicide of whistleblower @SAndriesz.
And note that there have been serious concerns in Parliament and in particular by @CommonsTreasury about how @TheFCA deals with whistleblowers going back to at least 2016 - see here, by Lord Tyrie when he was Chair of @CommonsTreasury.
Also if you would like to express interest in taking one of the few remaining complimentary places available at the APPG summit in Parliament on Monday 2nd November, which is all about protecting whistleblowers from retaliation and dedicated to the memory of @SAndriesz, please see here:
https://t.co/MhnQZnyAOQ
Thank you for taking time to read what we believe to be an important message; we hope you agree.
Please share your thoughts and repost as you wish - we need to get this message 'out there.'
📢 FINAL REMINDER! Whistleblower Summit | UK Parliament | Monday 2nd November, 2pm–5pm
The APPG on Investment Fraud and Fairer Financial Services invites you register your interest for a complimentary place at a special event in Parliament on the vital role whistleblowers play in society, and the need to protect them from retaliation.
The summit is dedicated to the memory of whistleblower Simon Andriesz, who took his own life after reporting retaliation by his former employer. His case featured on BBC File on 4 Investigates.
Simon had pleaded with the FCA for help, explaining that he and his family “were in crisis.”
His death has led whistleblowers around the world to unite in condemning the regulator. As far as we know, this is the first time whistleblowers worldwide have spoken out together on behalf of a fellow whistleblower.
Baroness Kramer has also spoken about Simon’s death in the Lords, and the case has received widespread media coverage.
🤝 Show your support for whistleblowers by attending.
👉 Register your interest for a free place: https://t.co/e4fpBDDrm6
🎧 BBC File on 4: https://t.co/aoJ03jaIct
📰 Press coverage: https://t.co/qYStYycD0n
#Whistleblowers #WhistleblowerProtection #UKParliament #FCA #APPGIFFFS #SimonAndriesz
I would encourage anyone with an interest in whistleblowing, particularly in financial services, to take the time to read this exceptional letter from John McDonnell MP to Nikhil Rathi, Chief Executive of the FCA, that is attached to the post below, from John Robertson:
If you haven’t heard of Simon Andriesz, google his name. He’s the whistleblower who tragically took his own life recently. It is a terribly sad story.
Nobody should find themselves in the position that Simon Andriesz did.
https://t.co/cifcdWuJRs
@AlanJLSmith So very true. Find a job you love, and you never work a day in your life. And for some people this can involve staying involved in their jobs / companies / industries well into later years, out of choice ...
@ClarksonsFarm1@MerlinBirdID Yep, saw what looked like a storm of starlings the other night, noting I'm a layperson re birds, so downloaded the app, having seen it on the show, and found out they were Eurasian Jackdaws. Who knew?!
Insightful look at Stephen Yiu / Blue Whale fund. The top calls have clearly gone right, and the decision making is well explained.
But do the failings of other star managers leave the question of future calls / key decisions not working out?
https://t.co/kyFIf6RxVO
@TheSecretAcct I was involved in one of the first such funds, 20 years ago. Dawnay Days. In addition to selling calls, if I remember correctly (I was only passing through the business, on the way to starting my own) it also bought some puts, so you properly motivated downside.
@DanNeidle Wouldn't a tribunal claim for unfair dismissal be limited to c£125k - without other factors involved (such as whistleblowing etc to make it automatic unfair dismissal)?
@ArashMassoudi@FT Interesting.
The rotation back towards undervalued growth is key.
This morning, I added an FT article re equal weight to a LinkedIn post I did a week ago re Citywire on the same subject:
https://t.co/fMO2yqnlBh
📽️EXCLUSIVE
For the first time ever, @skynews has been into the @bankofengland's gold vaults to see the world's second biggest trove of physical gold. An extraordinary place. An extraordinary sight.
Have a watch of our film👇 https://t.co/9bL5njGo04