They built the American Dream. Now, they’re fighting to protect it.
A trucking business owner. A voice for minority-owned businesses. Both challenging Washington’s income tax.
Meet Mike Sotelo and Curt Nuccitelli.
🎬 BEYOND MILLIONAIRES: Taxing the American Dream
EPISODE 01 | LIVE NOW
#WashingtonState #IncomeTax #AmericanDream #waleg #taxingtheamericandream
WA is increasingly antagonistic to the business community, but especially to those outside the tech sector. Excited to see the story of these business owners and why they're pushing back on yet another cost stacked on top of all the others.
They built businesses. Created jobs. Chased the American Dream.
Now, they're fighting Washington's income tax.
Their stories deserve to be heard.
🎬 Introducing a new CADF documentary series: Beyond Millionaires: Taxing the American Dream.
Launching tomorrow, 11/19.
Stay tuned.
#TaxingTheAmericanDream #IncomeTax #waleg
Voters did not approve Initiative 645, leaving our state’s new income tax in place. But the election did not settle whether that tax violates the state Constitution.
That question remains before the courts, where former Attorney General Rob McKenna, former state Supreme Court Justice Phil Talmadge, and the Citizen Action Defense Fund (@CADFWashington ) are challenging the law. Their lawsuit, filed this spring in Klickitat County Superior Court, seeks to invalidate the tax.
There is now a date to watch: February 5, 2027.
According to a post-election update from CADF Executive Director and attorney Jackson Maynard, the court is scheduled to hear a motion for summary judgment, asking a judge to resolve the legal questions without a full trial. Briefing is expected to begin in December.
(Read that post election update here: https://t.co/l64jPE7oPW)
The February 5th hearing is an important milestone, but it is unlikely to be the final word. A ruling striking down the income tax would almost certainly draw an appeal from the state. The case could then move directly to the State Supreme Court, if the justices accept review. That would mean additional briefing and oral arguments before a final decision. A resolution in 2027 is possible, but no Supreme Court hearing or decision date will be set until after the superior court rules.
The constitutional argument remains straightforward. Washington courts have long treated income as property. The challengers argue that the new 9.9% income tax violates both the Constitution’s requirement that property taxes be uniform and its 1% limit on property taxation.
“For nearly a century, Washington courts have been clear: income is property, and property taxes must be uniform and limited,” McKenna said when the lawsuit was filed in April.
As Future 42 reported earlier this year, McKenna laid out those constitutional objections before lawmakers passed the tax. The lawsuit now asks the courts to enforce those protections.
(Read that earlier article here: https://t.co/4SNQCS8cW8)
The November election also helped shape the court that could ultimately decide the case. This week’s latest results show Jaime Michelle Hawk and Sean O’Donnell leading races for two open seats, while sitting Justices Colleen Melody and Theo Angelis will win their races to remain on the court.
Those changes deserve attention, but they do not establish how any justice will rule. Maynard addressed that concern directly in his recent interview, emphasizing that every justice has a responsibility to interpret the law and precedent. He also pointed to the court’s 2023 capital gains tax decision, which upheld that tax without overturning the income-as-property precedent.
Under the current law, the income tax begins January 1, 2028, with the first returns due in April 2029. Those dates will not necessarily impact the timeline for a court decision, however.
For taxpayers in our state, the message is clear: the effort to stop this income tax is still moving forward, and the election results did not change the timeline, nor the strategy.
Future 42 will continue following the case and keeping you informed as this consequential constitutional fight moves through the courts.
- Future 42 Team
Sign up at https://t.co/z26ac4JcOr
You can support the effort behind this historic lawsuit by making a tax-deductible contribution to Citizens Action Defense Fund here: https://t.co/mp5a19Vw02
NEW FILING: Who decides which journalists can cover the WA Legislature?
CADF's motion for summary judgment reveals evidence that The House followed every recommendation made by the Capitol Correspondents Association, denying credentials to journalists Ari Hoffman, Brandi Kruse, and Jonathan Choe while approving others under unpublished and inconsistently applied criteria.
Press freedom isn't a popularity contest - period.
READ: https://t.co/kv1As1qPDX
@thehoffather@BrandiKruse@choeshow
#waleg #freepress
Contrary to the rhetoric purported by people in favor of the unconstitutional income tax, our plaintiffs are not comprised of just “the wealthy.”
Our plaintiffs include farmers, a trucker, a builder, and small business owners - hardworking Washingtonians that will be unlawfully impacted by this tax, all of whom actively contribute to our economy, and yet will be hit the hardest.
@JacksonMaynard8
#incometax #waleg
Jackson Maynard, a member of the plaintiffs’ legal team and executive director and counsel with the @CADFWashington , said Democrats in the Legislature will get their wish and “have the high court review whether or not an income tax is constitutional.” #waleg
https://t.co/cnP37dbjG7
I hate that it ended this way. I wanted it to work for Mike Norvell. He poured his entire heart and soul into the program. But for whatever reason it just didn't translate into consistently winning. I wish him nothing but the best moving forward.
Bad law. Bad policy.
During his recent TVW debate, @JacksonMaynard8 outlined CADF's legal and policy objections to Washington's income tax, raising concerns about constitutional limits, taxpayer protections, and government accountability.
#CADF#incometax#waleg
A Seattle public records fight that began in 2023 has reached another turning point.
Washington's Supreme Court declined to review the city's appeal, leaving a ruling in favor of @BrandiKruse in place.
Congrats to @BrandiKruse & @CADFWashington!
Seattle taxpayers should be angry. Besides again breaking disclosure rules, they cost taxpayers a lot more money due to their ideological intransigence.
WA Supreme Court today rejected @CityofSeattle appeal of ruling against city in case brought by @BrandiKruse in public records fight. City taxpayers will foot bill for 3-and-a-half year legal drama. @TCSWashington https://t.co/ejXBfZxNow
ANOTHER MAJOR WIN FOR GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY. ⚖️
The Washington Supreme Court has rejected the City of Seattle's petition for review in CADF's unDivided case, leaving our unanimous Court of Appeals victory intact.
And there's more: The City has been ordered to pay attorney fees for the Supreme Court proceedings.
This is a significant victory for accountability, transparency, and the rule of law.
With the case heading back to the trial court, CADF will pursue additional attorney fees and penalties.
Seattle tried to overturn our victory. The state's highest court declined.
We're proud of our legal team's work and remain committed to holding government accountable.
@BrandiKruse
#CADF #waleg
BREAKING: This morning, the State Supreme Court handed us a long-awaited legal victory, refusing to hear the City of Seattle's desperate request for review of our public records lawsuit dating back to 2023. The City of Seattle has officially run out of lifelines.
The City Attorney's Office has needlessly drawn this case out for years, at growing taxpayer expense. As the State Court of Appeals ruled unanimously, the city's failure to adhere to the Public Records Act was not in factual dispute. They failed to follow the law in responding to a request for documents related to former Councilman Andrew Lewis' controversial vote to reject a proposal by the former city attorney to prosecute drug offenses – delaying release until after an election where Lewis was on the ballot.
The Public Records Act is a critical tool to ensure government transparency. Seattle should have admitted its error early on and moved on – rather than wage a long and costly legal battle. We offered to settle multiple times over the past three years. I believe the city refused strictly due to animus over my political leanings, not based on their likelihood to prevail on the merits.
Without organizations like @CADFWashington, challenging these government abuses would be cost prohibitive. I am grateful for their determination in seeing the case through. Onward.
The Legislature doesn't get to rewrite the Washington Constitution.
CADF Executive Director Jackson Maynard took to TVW to debate the constitutionality (or lack thereof) of Washington State's new income tax and explain why constitutional protections must take precedence over political priorities.
Watch the debate here: https://t.co/oT4GEHrTc3
#cadf #waleg
Gee, Jim. Maybe your paper should speak out about the state hiring high priced attorneys hundreds of thousands of dollars to keep me, @choeshow, and @thehoffather from having press passes.