@charizardavis It’s a secret ballot. And moreover it is not the Jewish members who have opposed him. Publicly it’s been the progressive wing.
https://t.co/sKrF0zVl5z
@delieberman I don’t support the death penalty for a variety of ethical and practical reasons, but few things anger me more than animal abuse. Disgusting.
@HillelNeuer There is definitely lots of hypocrisy abound. But the free speech problem with the definition is real. Racism, sexism, antisemitism, is not an itself actionable. Discrimination or violence along those lines is. We don’t statutorily define any of those terms. Courts use context.
Tonight Veronica and I said goodbye to a great companion and old friend who had been a fixture in our lives for the last 24 good years. Sleep well, Shane.
@morris__brown@HenMazzig More speech & enforcing laws against acts of discrimination & violence are the only things that change that. Hate speech laws don’t curtail bigotry. They push it underground where it festers. We have to contest propaganda against it by making the strong case for Israel.
@rozz_friedman@HenMazzig Nope. You can see my feed and you will find hundreds of posts defending Israel. But censorship doesn’t defeat bigotry it magnifies it. Lots of anti-Zionism is antisemitic, but not all of it. Also the U Presidents were hypocrites. I have 20 years of defending speech consistently.
@guemanirteherin@HenMazzig That is not how it has been used. Plenty of examples of it being used to silence people in U.S.. Also the examples with the definition say it is automatically antisemitic to have a double standard with respect to Israel. Double standards can also just be ignorant.
@morris__brown@HenMazzig That is literally the opposite of the evidence. Literally. No evidence of hate speech laws working a single time. Zero point zero examples of them working. Tons of evidence of them being used against all types of unpopular opinions.
@guemanirteherin@HenMazzig Then why isn’t any other form of discrimination given a statutory definition? No one is saying words can never be action but antisemitic words on their own are no more action than racist words alone. You need facts and contexts to determine whether or not there is conduct.
@morris__brown@HenMazzig Censorship never works. Ever. There are no examples of it working. We must fight antisemitism with better arguments when responding to words and actions when we are responding to conduct. All other ways are doomed to fail.
Would you let our adversaries define Islamophobia?
@guemanirteherin@HenMazzig Words are not discrimination. Actions are discrimination. Firing someone. Refusing to serve or rent, etc.. We don’t define what is and is not sexist, racist, or Islamophobic either. Discriminating on those bases, however is not protected. Whether that is so is a factual analysis.
@HawkEmDownChris Yes, by a razor thin margin. But it seems clear that Charles is one of the greatest humans and if the allegations against Karl Malone have any truth to them, the gap in their character is huge.
@Varela4NJ Not great. I share your criticism of Bovino. But our commitment to free expression cannot end when it’s our adversaries who speak. Leadership requires setting examples. Support protesters by showing them how to do it lawfully. Excusing this is not the way.
@dogmawdogpaw@krassenstein I don’t know what Rutgers will do. Schools don’t have good track records disciplining students for disruptions.
Protest loses protection when it creates a substantial/material disruption of a university function or event in a reserved location.
Forsyth v Nationalist Movement.
@RepBonnie Rutgers is supposed to provide a good education. Part of that is protecting all students’ civil liberties. That includes the right to hear speakers many classmates disagree strongly with. I disagree with Bovino too. Hearing a speaker with bad policies doesn’t make anyone unsafe.