A question for my Calvary Chapel friends. If we can read 1 Corinthians 11 and 14 in light of their culture, why can't we do the same with 1 Timothy 2? I wrote out my thoughts below. You may land somewhere different than I do, and that's okay. I'm just asking for consistency.
https://t.co/RAbZiZUIXQ
@Tru5ting@Charbrodersen You are correct about that historical date. I will update the article. I would ask you to wrestle with the actual question in the article.
Is @Charbrodersen a heretic?
TLDR: No he is not! His “take” is biblical and a strong maturing of a Calvary Chapel theological position that has been murky.
https://t.co/wPVzuGuSTb
@TheoManBabies@AmyMantravadi@JosiahHawthorne Isn’t what you are saying about her true about all of us? It is a mistake to create heroes who are flawless. That’s Jesus role alone.
Elizabeth Elliott is at the top of my Christian hero list. I read the CT article last week. I was grateful that it was published. I hold a conservative view of sexuality. I’m not bothered by the substance of the article. Who knows what was actually going on in the 60s and 70s with Elizabeth. It seemed so dumb to read all the people who were bent out of shape. I’m grateful for CT.
I'm grateful for @LucySRAusten writing it up because the Stell interview with Mollenkott was already out. I'd rather have rumors fleshed out in established journalistic platforms by the leading authorities on the subject. One could make the case that @LucySRAusten amplified the Stell interview, but I would personally prefer substantive rumors be dealt with as thoroughly as possible.
Elisabeth Elliot is at the top of my Christian hero list. Her writing on suffering and surrender shaped me, and my respect for her hasn't changed.
Here's what happened. In 2020, historian William Stell interviewed Virginia Mollenkott, who died later that year. She described a private 1975 conversation with Elliot, and Stell published that account this summer. Lucy Austen, Elliot's biographer, responded in Christianity Today.
Does Mollenkott's story make it clear that Elliot was bisexual? No. It's one secondhand account of a conversation from decades earlier, and both women are gone. It doesn't fit Elliot's moral convictions about sexuality. It's interesting, but it isn't convincing.
That's why I was glad @LucySRAusten wrote her article. She's an authority on Elliot's life. Instead of leaving Stell's minority report out there unanswered, she held it up against the letters and journals she had access to and told us honestly what can and can't be known. She couldn't slam the door on the story with the record she had, so she didn't pretend to. That isn't gossip or slander. It's fair reporting, and it's the work of building an accurate public record.
We will all leave a legacy, and the hope is that the story told about us after we die is as true as possible.
The knee-jerk condemnation of @CTmagazine treats Elliot like a saint who can't be examined. Christians rightly demanded the truth about Ravi Zacharias, but that came from a documented pattern of abuse. This is one account that can't be confirmed. Elliot's legacy is strong enough to handle an honest look, and this story doesn't come close to disrupting it.
@MichaelHyatt Running my life on the material you created over the past two decades have been the perfect setup for an agentic future.... life plans, full-focus... all of it was the perfect path to being prepped for the current agent world.